Sports Illustrated revealed that Serena Williams was its Sportsperson of the Year, an already rarefied honor that’s made even more so by the fact that Serena is a woman.

But there is something about the cover — specifically, something about Serena’s legs. The discussion has become less about Serena’s achievement and more about whether or not SI had Photoshopped Serena’s thighs to look smaller.

Credit: Cosmopolitan