The timely reaction of the senate to the policy of the Nigeria Customs Service to compel all vehicle owners to pay appropriate duties has once again questioned the extent of the oversight powers of the national assembly.
In contributing to the interesting debate I shall examine the legal validity of the policy, the legal competence of the senate to summon the comptroller-general of customs to justify the policy and the legality of the directive that he should appear before the senate in uniform.
Illegal policy of Nigeria Customs Service on payment of appropriate duties.
We are aware that the Nigeria Customs Service has announced the suspension of the implementation of the policy to compel all vehicle owners in Nigeria to pay appropriate customs duties from March 13-April 12, 2017. Notwithstanding the suspension we deem it fit to point out that the policy is illegal as the Nigeria Customs Service is completely estopped from collecting additional duties from vehicle owners who had paid the duties charged at the time of importation. Under the doctrine of estoppel by conduct the Nigeria Customs Service cannot be permitted to deny the payment of what was charged and collected as appropriate duties from vehicle owners several years ago.
In Alhaja Abibatu Mogaji v Board of Customs (1982) 3 NCLR 552, the armed agents of the defendant invaded and raided markets in Lagos and seized contraband goods. In the process, some of the traders were brutalized. They sued the defendant for damages in the Lagos high court. Apart from condemning the violations of the traders to dignity the Lagos high court cautioned that “Those in authority in customs and excise matters ought to intensify methods for apprehending offenders at the point of entry of goods into the country as it becomes more difficult to do so afterwards.” In Margaret Stitch v Attorney-General of the Federation (1986) 2 NSSC 1389 the Supreme Court held that the appellant was only liable to pay the customs duty based upon the rate of duty payable when she imported her used Mercedes Benz car. It was the view of the apex court that it was unjust and retrospectively punitive to impose an additional financial liability of about N13,000 on the appellant.
In view of the settled position of the law on the matter what is required on the part of the management of the Nigeria Customs Service is not a suspension of the illegal policy but its outright annulment without any further delay. Of course, the authorities of the Nigeria Customs Service cannot be precluded from arresting and prosecuting highly placed individuals who usually forge importation documents in order to evade the payment of the appropriate duties to the coffers of the federal government.
Incompetence of the senate to summon CGC on policy matters
Under the pretext of exercising its oversight powers last week the senate summoned the CGC to appear before it to justify the policy on payment of appropriate duties from March 13-April 2017. Since he did not appear in uniform the senate decided to adjourn its debate on the matter to enable him to comply with the directive. In spite of the importance attached to the trifle and diversionary directive on uniform it is submitted that the senate lacks the vires to summon the CGC on policy matters. Indeed the oversight power of either house of the national assembly is not at large but limited by section 88 (2) of the constitution to enable it to “make laws with respect to any matter within its legislative competence and correct any defects in existing laws and expose corruption, inefficiency or waste in the execution or administration of laws within its legislative competence and in the disbursement or administration of funds appropriate by it”.
Since the decision of the senate has nothing to do with making laws or exposing corruption, inefficiency or waste in the disbursement of funds appropriated by it the summoning of the CGC constitutes a blatant violation of the constitution. No doubt, the policy was designed to generate revenue for the federal government. To that extent the senate may be accused of shielding criminal elements who have engaged in the evasion of the payment of customs duties. If the senate had wanted to protect the interests of vehicle owners including themselves they ought to have entered into dialogue with the minister of finance. There is no legal or moral basis for the arrogance of power being displayed by the senate whose leadership has recently being linked with the illegal importation of a bullet proof limousine with fake papers to evade the payment of appropriate customs duties.
In El-rufai v House of Representatives (2003) 46 W.R.N 70 the court of appeal placed heavy reliance on the case of senate of the National Assembly v Tony Momoh where it was held that “no power exists under the section for general investigation not for personal aggrandizement of the house”. So the appellants were not entitled to have invited the respondent in the first instance. In the instant case, the senate is not conducting an investigation but challenging the policy of the Nigeria Customs Service on payment of duties. With respect., the summons served on the CGC is illegal and unconstitutional as it cannot be justified under section 88(2) of the constitution.
Illegal directive on wearing of uniform by CGC
However, the senate engaged in another illegality when it exceeded its powers by asking the CGC to appear before it in customs uniform. Neither the constitution not the rules of procedure of the senate has conferred on it the power to compel the CGC to wear customs union when he is not a serving customs office. Indeed, the directive is a reckless usurpation of the powers of the board which is the only competent body to decide on the wearing of uniform by customs officer.
In many countries including South Africa customs officers do not wear uniforms. It is on record that the first 4 heads of the customs department in Nigeria never wore uniforms.
Under the defunct military junta, officials of the security agencies wore uniforms as they claimed that they were either military or paramilitary forces. With respect to the customs service, its officers are required to wear uniforms in accordance with section 8 of the customs excise and preventive service regulations which provides that “clothing and equipment shall be of such pattern and worn in such manner as the board shall determine.” The suit challenging the legal validity of Col Hameed Ali’s appointment has been dismissed on the ground that the President has the power to appoint a non-customs officer to head the customs service. Since a competent court has held that he is not a customs officer, Ali cannot be made to wear any uniform by the senate.
If I am said to be wrong I challenge the senate to refer to any law that supports the wearing of uniform by the head of the customs service who is not a serving customs officer. The EFCC has been headed by 3 serving police officers and a retired police officer but the senate never mandated any of them to wear uniform whenever they appeared before it. Even the embattled acting chairman of the EFCC, Ibrahim Magu who appeared for confirmation in the senate last week was not directed to wear his uniform even though he is a serving police officer.
I should not be understood as saying that the senate deserves to be treated with disdain. All I am saying is that the senate should have appreciated the limit of its powers under the constitution. Thus, instead of playing into the hands of the CGC by invoking the provision of section 88 of the constitution, the senate could have summoned the minister of finance to justify the policy of the Nigeria Customs Service, a parastatal under her supervision. That would have been in consonance with section 67 (2) of the constitution which has imposed a duty on every minister to attend either house of the national assembly to explain “the conduct of his Ministry, and in particular when the affairs of the Ministry are under discussion.”
Finally, the Nigeria Customs Service should be directed by the minister of finance to cancel the illegal policy on payment of appropriate excise duties. If the federal government remains recalcitrant on the matter we shall not hesitate to challenge the policy at the federal high court. However, if the federal government is seriously committed to end the importation of vehicles into Nigeria via neighboring countries it should direct the Nigeria Customs Service to reduce the prohibitive duties charged on imported vehicles.
order digoxin 250mg sale lanoxin pills molnunat ca
buy acetazolamide online cheap order isosorbide 40mg pill imuran generic
digoxin sale cost telmisartan 20mg purchase molnupiravir pills
generic amoxil 250mg stromectol for people ivermectin 9 mg tablet
order coreg generic carvedilol 6.25mg for sale amitriptyline price
priligy pills order priligy 60mg online cheap purchase domperidone online
order fosamax generic nitrofurantoin pill buy motrin online cheap
order indomethacin 75mg sale buy cenforce pill cenforce medication
buy nortriptyline 25mg pill paroxetine pill paxil cost
buy generic doxycycline 100mg chloroquine pills methylprednisolone 8 mg over counter
famotidine 40mg pills oral tacrolimus 5mg remeron 30mg tablet
ropinirole 2mg drug buy requip generic labetalol pill
buy tadalafil online cheap brand tadalafil 20mg buy generic amoxicillin 250mg
fenofibrate 200mg ca sildenafil citrate 50 mg buy sildenafil 50mg for sale
order esomeprazole 20mg pill order biaxin 250mg generic brand furosemide
cialis 20mg drug tadalafil health store cost sildenafil 100mg
buy minocin for sale terazosin 5mg cost hytrin online buy
tadalafil brand top ed pills over the counter ed pills that work
brand glucophage 1000mg buy tamoxifen online tamoxifen tablet
oral modafinil provigil 100mg without prescription promethazine 25mg sale
serophene cheap buy atorvastatin 20mg pills buy generic prednisolone 5mg
prednisone 20mg uk buy generic accutane 10mg amoxicillin 250mg ca
isotretinoin 40mg price order generic isotretinoin 40mg oral ampicillin 250mg
purchase fildena online cheap sildenafil 100mg pills order proscar 1mg without prescription
ivermectin 6mg online stromectol 3mg generic buy prednisone 10mg generic
cheap zofran 4mg order bactrim 480mg pills buy bactrim pills
buy accutane 40mg for sale amoxil 500mg sale buy zithromax generic
albuterol without prescription buy levothroid augmentin for sale online
buy prednisolone for sale prednisolone 5mg generic buy furosemide 100mg generic
purchase provigil without prescription provigil 100mg without prescription metoprolol 50mg cheap
avodart for sale order xenical pill how to get xenical without a prescription
doxycycline 100mg pill doxycycline price buy acyclovir 800mg
order azathioprine 25mg for sale telmisartan for sale online order naprosyn 500mg for sale
order ditropan 5mg online oxcarbazepine medication oxcarbazepine 300mg for sale
omnicef pill protonix 40mg brand order pantoprazole 40mg generic
order zocor without prescription sildenafil india cost sildalis
buy dapsone 100 mg sale generic atenolol 100mg order atenolol 100mg sale
generic alfuzosin 10mg diltiazem 180mg without prescription diltiazem us
order viagra 100mg for sale viagra pharmacy cialis 5mg us
purchase ezetimibe generic buy zetia 10mg buy methotrexate 5mg online
promethazine for sale online provigil 100mg tablet buy cialis 40mg generic
levaquin order levaquin 250mg oral bupropion 150 mg without prescription
warfarin 2mg canada order reglan 10mg generic order zyloprim 100mg pill
order zyrtec generic buy generic cetirizine 5mg zoloft 100mg ca
cenforce 100mg pill where can i buy chloroquine glucophage 500mg pills
escitalopram 10mg ca order sarafem 20mg naltrexone 50 mg cheap
lipitor 20mg us oral atorvastatin 20mg buy sildenafil 100mg without prescription
femara pills sildenafil oral cheap viagra
buy tadalafil 20mg pills how to get cialis erection pills viagra online
purchase cialis sildenafil pills 50mg best pills for ed
ivermectin 12mg over the counter isotretinoin over the counter buy accutane for sale
modafinil without prescription provigil 100mg usa prednisone 20mg tablet
order amoxil 250mg pill zithromax generic order prednisolone 10mg generic
oral accutane 10mg amoxil cheap order azithromycin
gabapentin for sale doxycycline 200mg pill how to buy doxycycline
buy generic ventolin inhalator cheap synthroid online generic synthroid
prednisolone tablets gabapentin 600mg canada buy furosemide 40mg online cheap
clomiphene 100mg sale buy vardenafil 10mg online cheap brand hydroxychloroquine
doxycycline uk buy generic augmentin over the counter augmentin us
atenolol 50mg without prescription methylprednisolone 4mg tablet buy letrozole pill
levothyroxine tablet clomid 50mg oral levitra buy online
buy albendazole generic albenza 400 mg for sale medroxyprogesterone 10mg ca
metformin order online atorvastatin 40mg without prescription norvasc us
buy biltricide sale cyproheptadine sale order generic cyproheptadine 4mg
buy generic zestril 2.5mg buy metoprolol 50mg generic buy lopressor 50mg
lyrica 75mg brand claritin 10mg pills dapoxetine 60mg pills
methotrexate 5mg pills metoclopramide 20mg without prescription buy metoclopramide generic
order xenical 60mg generic brand allopurinol 100mg order zyloprim generic
losartan 25mg for sale nexium uk buy topiramate without a prescription
buy crestor 10mg generic order motilium without prescription order motilium 10mg online
buy imitrex 25mg online levofloxacin 500mg cheap avodart order
buy tetracycline for sale buy cheap lioresal order generic baclofen 25mg
toradol cost buy ketorolac without prescription where can i buy inderal
buy zantac 300mg for sale celecoxib 200mg usa order celebrex 100mg without prescription
buy clopidogrel 75mg without prescription luvox 50mg canada nizoral 200 mg oral
buy tamsulosin online cheap purchase zofran sale buy spironolactone medication
buy cymbalta online cheap buy glipizide 10mg sale order generic nootropil 800mg
order betamethasone 20 gm generic anafranil online buy itraconazole 100mg pill
combivent 100mcg pills linezolid sale buy linezolid 600mg sale
buy generic prometrium prometrium ca order zyprexa generic
cost bystolic 5mg order generic clozaril 50mg buy generic clozaril over the counter
buy nateglinide without prescription order candesartan pill how to get candesartan without a prescription
buy generic zocor over the counter buy viagra online cheap order viagra 50mg online cheap
order carbamazepine 200mg without prescription buy ciprofloxacin 500mg generic order lincomycin 500mg generic
buy duricef 250mg cefadroxil usa buy proscar 5mg sale
tadalafil india buy cialis on line purchase sildenafil online cheap
fluconazole 100mg us ampicillin pill buy cipro 1000mg sale
order estrace online cheap lamotrigine pill minipress online
buy flagyl 200mg generic purchase bactrim for sale order cephalexin generic
mebendazole usa oral retin tadalis 10mg pills
order generic cleocin buy fildena 50mg buy sildenafil 50mg generic
buy tamoxifen paypal ceftin 500mg sale ceftin ca
indocin medication brand indomethacin order generic cefixime 100mg
careprost oral oral trazodone 100mg trazodone medication
trimox 250mg cheap clarithromycin 500mg cost biaxin uk
sildenafil without prescription sildalis canada buy generic sildalis online
buy generic minocycline over the counter buy hytrin 1mg generic purchase pioglitazone generic
absorica online buy zithromax generic buy cheap azithromycin
azipro order azipro 250mg over the counter order neurontin
tadalafil 20mg without prescription order cialis without prescription cialis 20mg canada
cost stromectol buy generic stromectol buy deltasone 20mg sale
buy furosemide generic monodox generic ventolin inhalator ca
vardenafil pills buy tizanidine for sale hydroxychloroquine 200mg ca
altace 10mg cost ramipril 10mg cost arcoxia 60mg us
levitra price order levitra buy plaquenil 200mg without prescription
buy mesalamine online cheap astelin online irbesartan buy online
purchase olmesartan pills calan 120mg ca depakote over the counter
temovate tablet amiodarone oral order amiodarone 200mg pill
buy coreg 25mg oral chloroquine brand aralen
diamox for sale order acetazolamide 250mg pill buy imuran 50mg sale
order lanoxin 250 mg generic molnupiravir online order buy molnunat generic
Informative article, just what I was looking for.
My site free mp3 download
where can i buy naproxen naprosyn pill buy lansoprazole online
Keep this going please, great job!\r\n\r\nFeel free to surf to my website : youtube mp3 downloader
buy generic albuterol for sale buy generic pantoprazole phenazopyridine 200 mg usa
baricitinib 4mg cheap olumiant generic order lipitor 20mg