Abati: The Grammarian’s Funeral – by Bayo Oluwasanmi

Published:5 Feb, 2013

abatiOne of the most important and dramatic emblem of democratic citizenship is the right to criticize a government. No amount of glorious hyperbole by the government or its agents could stop critics from airing their views.

Reuben Abati’s article “The Hypocrisy of Yesterday’s Men” is a sharp rebuke of revolving PDP beneficiaries of political spoils.
Reuben Abati, President Jonathan’s senior adviser on media and publicity as well as Aso Rock attack dog came out swinging on past and present critics of Jonathan’s administration.

I will not dignify the article by responding to the phantom of fear dressed up as substance by Abati. However, a general comment will be in order.
The write-up is undisguised propaganda ploy of Abati’s pleasant fantasy to shut up the critics of Jonathan’s government and hope they’ll for ever remain silent.

The Aso Rock way of operating a democratic government is to hurl accusations and insults on critics who are merely expressing their democratic rights.
Abati’s writings are anti-democratic. They amount to democratic apartheid to stifle the freedom of speech and freedom of expression of Nigerians.

He has been consistently hostile by trying to gag, coerce, intimidate, and muzzle voices of dissent and views diametrically opposed to the PDP led federal government.

In representative democracy, the majority that rules has all the powers over the minority that loses. Elections have consequences. However, the succinct characteristic in the relationship between majority rule and democracy is the right of dissent.

Whenever a government sees critics as enemies, and is all out to erect barriers to prevent opposing views, such government is delicately perched on the coat tail of tyranny of the majority.

James Madison warned, “If a majority be united by a common interest (corruption, fraud, repression of people’s views as in the case of PDP government), the rights of the minority (those outside the ruling class) will be insecure.

Madison elaborates further that in order to prevent the tyranny of the majority, there must be safeguards to protect “one part of the society against injustice of the other part.”

The concentration of all powers in the same hands, Madison warned, “whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self-appointed, or elective, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny.”

Madison’s concern about the tyranny of the majority is that the majority may not represent the whole. As in the case of the majority rule PDP federal government, the government does not represent all the competing interests of our people.

As the PDP central government has demonstrated through financial profligacy, redundant     policies and programs time after time, the majority is self-interested, greedy, arrogant, ignorant, insensitive, and indifferent to the concerns of the people.

The majority becomes tyrannical when the self-interested majority does not give a damn about what the governed thinks, says, or feels.

When the majority is fixed and permanent in power for so long similar to PDP’s hold on power for years now, there will be no checks on its ability to be overbearing. Despotism, Madison insists, must be opposed “whether it came from kings, Lords, or the people.”

Abati, no doubt has taken leave of his senses. He’s an obsessive advocate of anything Jonathan – senseless or stupid.

He believes the critics of Mr. Jonathan are implacably hostile to the person of Mr. Jonathan. Abati feels the critics are not authenticated Nigerians.

The battle for spin control on the views, perceptions, and criticisms of Jonathan’s administration can never be won by propaganda. Rather, it will leave Aso Rock more distracted, more disorganized, more disarrayed, and more paralyzed.

We need a debate on issues not on personalities. What Abati is doing is when the Jonathan administration is criticized, he demonized, when challenged, he demonized some more!

Abati no doubt, is willing to be mean, nasty, rude, crude, and raw because he’s willing to do anything to deceive the people.

It’s been said that “differences of opinion make horse races.” But in Abati’s case they do not. In his pontifical defense of a corrupt, insensitive, and ineffective government; Abati has surnamed thoughtful and creative critics as dangerous radicals.

Tocqueville once asked: “What is a majority, in its collective capacity, if not an individual with opinions, and usually with interests, contrary to those of another individual, called the minority?”

Tocqueville believes that a group (such as Aso Rock propagandists) is not wiser that its parts.

The fact that the PDP run government supports or initiates a policy/program or enacts a law is no evidence of its wisdom. The people’s interests more often than not are excluded in the PDP’s scheme of things.

I think it is a cruel joke on the part of Abati to attack critics of Jonathan’s administration with distorting vituperations and to label them as yesterday’s hypocrites.

In the words of the Sanza Player in Aime Cesaire’s play, A season in the Congo, “Even when a man has good eyes, you have to show him some things.”
If the critics were yesterday’s hypocrites, what shall we call Abati of today? :  Yesterday’s hypocrite and today’s pharisee!

Political struggles should not be a contest between rulers and people. For a government that worth its salt, political struggle should be a struggle to make life happier, safer, better, and prosperous for the people.

The work of a responsive and responsible government is not to transcend different interests, but to reconcile them.

In an ideal democracy, the majority would rule but the people would also be protected against the power of majorities.

No amount of propaganda, arm-twisting, distortions, fabrications, and intimidation by the Aso Rock propaganda coterie will quell the firestorm that the ineptly corrupt Jonathan administration continues to ignite.

The tirade unleashed on the critics by Abati sends our intellectual and moral nature to a fierce revolt. In essence, Abati has derationalized the debate.
Abati’s venom on the critics is a product of some heated imagination. It’s a product of blurred vision typical of ecstatic and half-hysterical propaganda disciple.

In days like these when death is busy and loss is common to Nigerians, when hunger, joblessness, and homelessness ravaged the land, when young ones are written off as lost generations, when the country is headed into the abyss, no academic writing can rewrite the situation on the ground.

The reality on ground lends no evidential value to Abati’s article. Blogger Sunkanmi Adesina on The Nigerian of Our Dream Group sums it better: “The article is full of words, yet it conveys no iota of common sense regarding the allegation on ground.”

Abati reminds me of the great truth which Browning teaches in his poem “A Grammarian’s Funeral.” There he depicts a scholar “dead from the waist down” because of his fastidiousness to the practice of his craft.

Like the Grammarian, Abati pursues the goal of distortion and disinformation with effortless stylistic literary gem believing that will change the hard life faced by impoverished millions of Nigerians.

The Hypocrisy of Yesterday’s Men – is Abati’s Grammarian’s funeral!

Only last week, US Billionaire and philanthropist Bill Gates in an interview said: “Nigeria really needs to think that relative to its level of wealth, it is really far from behind.”

British Prime Minister David Cameron the G8 President in a similar vein remarked: “…corruption and mismanagement of huge oil wealth still continues to deny the nation’s (Nigeria) people of their prosperity.”

“Nigeria oil exports were worth almost a hundred billions,” continued Cameron. “That is more than the total net aid to the whole of sub Saharan Africa,” said Cameron.

“So, put simply, unleashing the natural resources in these countries dwarfs anything aid can achieve, and transparency is absolutely critical to that end,” concludes Cameron.

Instead of Mr. Jonathan and his staff to roll up their sleeves and get down working and solving the country’s problems, they continue to churn out useless and sickening cacophonies.

I’m sick and tired of the threadbare excuse that Mr. Jonathan didn’t create the problems. That’s not the issue and of course it is beside the point. That’s a dishonest way of debating the issue.

What we’re saying is what’s Mr. Jonathan doing and what’s he going to do about the problems?

Can Abati and other congenital fools employ some rational thinking and nuggets of wisdom instead of using reverse psychology to slice and dice important national issues?

Is Abati saying that we don’t have right to question the government for allocating N4bn for First Lady’s Mission House?

Can’t we discuss the rationale for: N5bn rehabilitation of Abuja prostitutes? Seven billion Naira for a new city gate for Abuja?  N16bn for the Vice-President’s house? Cell phones for farmers?

How can a government gets its priorities so twisted, so warped, so comedic, and so completely out of logic to allocate money for the above absurdities when the country’s safety and stability are being threatened by 80% unemployment and 70% of our people living below the poverty line?

The critics of the government may lose in the short run, but they cannot be suppressed in the long run. Public dialogue is critical to represent all perspectives. No one viewpoint should be permitted to monopolize, distort, caricature, or shape public debate.

Suppressing the people’s viewpoint is part of the tyranny of the majority. It is excluding their representation or preferences from government’s priorities and policies.

We need a broad public conversation about issues of representative justice that seeks practical solutions to real-life problems.


– by Bayo Oluwasanmi  (byolu@aol.com)

via SaharaReporters

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Sen. Baba-Ahmed appointed as Chairman of the NYSC Hope Alive Foundation’s Board of Trustees

Sen. Yusuf Baba-Ahmed has been appointed as Chairman, Board of Trustees (BOT) of the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) Hope Alive Foundation. Brig.-Gen. Johnson Olawumi, Director-General, NYSC, announced this in a statement issued in Abuja on Friday by the NYSC Public Relations Unit. It said the BOT, which comprised persons from different sectors of national life, would be inaugurated by the incoming Minister of Youth Development. The statement explained that the foundation would be expected to drive the initiative of the scheme...

Kebbi govt. to establish international market at Nigeria-Benin Republic border

The Kebbi State Government on Friday said it would establish an International Market at Nigeria-Benin Republic border to fast track the take off of a Dry Port in the area. This is contained in a statement issued by Mr Abubakar Dakingari, Chief Press Secretary to Kebbi governor, Alhaji Atiku Bagudu, and made available to the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Birnin Kebbi. It said establishment of the market would enhance socio-economic activities and ensure sustainable development of the state. It assured...

EFCC nabs two with 448 travelers’ cheques, 108 ATM cards

Two Nigerians, identified as Jonathan Odu Isikwei and Paschal Onuora Udeh, have been arrested by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) with no fewer than 556 banking instruments purportedly belonging to four banks in America, Europe and Canada, with which they had been using to commit ‘unsuspecting large scale fraud,’ Vanguard reports. The two men were rounded up by operatives of the commission for unlawful possession of 448 travelers’ cheques...

Jurgen Klopp unveiled as Liverpool’s new manager, inks £15m deal

Jurgen Klopp was unveiled as Liverpool's new manager on Friday, succeeding Brendan Rodgers who was sacked last week.   The former Borussia Dortmund Manager, Jurgen Klopp signed a three-year deal with Liverpool FC at the city’s Hope Street hotel in the company of the chairman, Tom Werner, and chief executive, Ian Ayre, on Thursday...

NESG Presents the 21st Nigerian Economic Summit #NES21

The Nigerian Economic Group presents the 21st Nigerian Economic summit; theme: Tough Choices: Achieving competitiveness, inclusive growth and sustainability. Come and be part of the crucial talks targeted at addressing how to achieve competiveness and inclusive growth for the Nigerian economy through measurable outcomes This summit seeks to examine and facilitate stakeholders’ consensus on how best to achieve competitiveness and inclusive growth in a sustainable way, through measurable outcomes and as such...

Akwa Ibom govt. trains 700 civil servants on ICT

Akwa Ibom Government said a total of 700 civil servants have been trained on Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in the state.   The state Head of Service, Mrs Cecilia Udoessien, disclosed this on Friday in an interview with newsmen in Uyo.   Udoessien, the Head of Service since 2011, said that many civil servants had benefitted from various training programmes initiated by her office.   She said that she had introduced into the yearly public service week celebration, essay competition and debate among civil...

Messi, father to appear in court over $4.5 million tax fraud charges

Argentine forward Lionel Messi and his father Jorge have been ordered to appear in court on charges of defrauding Spanish tax authorities over an amount worth more than four million euros (about $4.5 million; about N990 million).   Spain's public prosecutor has recommended a jail sentence totaling 18 months and fines of more than two million euros for Jorge Messi.   This is for allegedly defrauding the state of 4.2 million euros for the years 2007-2009.   The prosecutor has however argued that Lionel Messi should...

Arsenal Goal Keeper Petr Cech Offers Thoughts On The Mourinho Vs Arsene Wenger Rivalry

The former Blues goalkeeper, who moved to the Emirates, in the transfer window has offered his thoughts on the two club's managers Arsenal goalkeeper Petr Cech has suggested manager Arsene Wenger and his Chelsea counterpart Jose Mourinho are regularly at odds because of similar personalities. Wenger and Mourinho have experienced a fractious relationship on the touchline...

Lacasera reinstates 700 sacked workers

The National Union of Food, Beverage and Tobacco Employees (NUFBTE) on Friday confirmed that Lacasera Company Plc has reinstated the 700 workers it sacked in September.   Mr Mike Olarenwaju, Head of Education Department in NUFBTE, confirmed the development to the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Lagos.   Olarenwaju said that the management of the company met with union members to resolve the issues in dispute and that the workers had been asked to start work.   He said that officials of the union...

Tribunal Reserves Judgement In Akwa Ibom Governorship Petition

The Akwa Ibom Governorship Election Tribunal has reserved judgment in the petition filed by the All Progressives Congress (APC) and its governorship candidate, Mr. Umana Umana, challenging the victory of Governor Emmanuel Udom at the April 11 election in the state. The tribunal resumed hearing after a 2-week recess to adopt the final arguments of the parties. The Chairman of the tribunal, Justice Sadiq Umar, reserved ruling following the conclusion of hearing...

Femi Gbajabiamila’s Election Victory Up Held By Tribunal In Lagos

The National Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal sitting in Ikeja on Friday upheld the victory of the Majority Leader of the House of Representatives, Mr Femi Gbajabiamila. The tribunal held that Gbajabiamila of the All Progressives Congress (APC) validly won the March 28 election for Surulere Federal Constituency I in Lagos State. The three-man tribunal led by Justice C.U. Anwuka resolved all issues raised in favour of the respondent. The tribunal consequently dismissed the petition...

Tribunal upholds Gbajabiamila’s election

The National Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal sitting in Ikeja on Friday upheld the victory of the Majority Leader of the House of Representatives, Mr Femi Gbajabiamila.   The tribunal held that Gbajabiamila of the All Progressives Congress (APC) validly won the March 28 election for Surulere Federal Constituency I in Lagos State.   The three-man tribunal led by Justice C.U. Anwuka resolved all issues raised in favour of the respondent.   The tribunal consequently dismissed the petition filed by the Peoples Democratic Party candidate, Mr...

Buruji Kashamu loses senate seat as Tribunal nullifies election

The Election Tribunal in Ogun State has nullified the election of alleged US wanted drug baron, Buruji Kashamu.   The tribunal made the decision today in Abeokuta and ordered a rerun in 110 polling units, where irregularities were established.   Indications that the Tribunal would arrive at this conclusion were foreshadowed in the cancellation of the election of Buruji’s party colleague in the House of Representatives, Aremo Adesegun Adekoya Abdel-Majid, who represented Buruji’s Ijebu North local council and two other councils.   Prince Dapo Abiodun,...

National security remains our topmost priority – President Buhari

President Muhammadu Buhari has said that significant improvements in national security remains the topmost priority of his administration.   The president made the statement on Thursday in Abuja when he granted audience to Britain's Chief of Defence Staff, Gen. Nicholas Houghton.   He said that security was imperative because other socio-economic initiatives could not be successfully implemented without adequate security in the country.   He reaffirmed the determination of his administration to end the Boko Haram insurgency as quickly as possible.   Buhari said: "for a country...

French Train Attack Hero Stabbed Multiple Times In A Bar Fight

Spencer Stone, one of the men who foiled a terror attack on a Paris-bound train in August, was seriously injured after being stabbed four times in the chest near a gay bar in downtown Sacramento early Thursday morning Police in Sacramento are searching for two Asian men after hero US airman Spencer Stone was knifed during a fight on a night out with friends in Sacramento. He suffered a collapsed lung and was being...

Serena Williams And Drake Deny Engagement Rumors

While we all  that Serena Williams and Drake have been dating, OK Magazine started a whole new round of celeb gossip on Thursday with the news that the two were now engaged. Even though no confirmation was given for the tabloid report, social media went crazy about the rumor and started to announce the couple’s supposed engagement. Ok Mag said Drake got down on one knee and proposed They...

Boko Haram: IDPs From Gwoza Write Buhari, Reveal Insurgents’ Hiding Place

Internally Displaced Persons from Gwoza have appealed to the Military High Command to undertake an operation within the Bayan Dutse area of Gwoza to flush out the insurgents and bring back peace to their homeland. In an open letter written to President Muhammadu Buhari on their behalf by five community leaders, the IDPs stated that if only the Bayan Dutse area would be attacked, all the Boko Haram insurgents hiding there would be flushed out and peace would...

News Alert!! Kashamu, 6 Others Sacked By Ogun State Election Tribunal

The Election Petition Tribunal sitting in Ogun state has sacked Senator representing Ogun East Senatorial district, Senator Buruji Kashamu a member of House of Representatives from Ijebu East /Ijebu North /Ogun waterside, Adekoya Adesegun and five members of the state assembly over non-compliance of electoral law. The tribunal has therefore ordered a fresh election in the areas affected. More details later......

Kanye West Says He’s Been Discriminated Against By The Fashion Industry Because He Is Not Gay

In an interview with Showstudio, rapper Kanye West said he believes he's being discriminated against by the fashion industry because he's not gay as he tried to further his career in fashion. “I feel like I got discriminated in fashion for not being gay,” the 38-year-old said during a two-hour live interview with SHOWstudio: ‘In music, you definitely get discriminated in music if you are gay. It takes...

Daniel Craig Becomes ‘Highest-Paid’ James Bond Actor Ever As He Earns $60m For ‘Spectre’ Movie

Daniel Craig is the highest-paid James Bond star ever as the Spectre action hero is said to be in line to earn around £39million for his role in 007's latest adventure. According to The Sun, the actor's deal for his salary and profit share is worth more than the combined earnings of all the men to take on the role.A source close to MGM said: Daniel's deal means he'll bank $24million (£15.66m) for acting, around $6million (£3.82m) for...

Khloe Kardashian Frustrated With Caitlyn Jenner, Says “I Don’t Know This Person Anymore”

Speaking to her sister, Kim in a sneak peak of their reality show, Keeping Up With the Kardashians yesterday, Khloe Kardashian expressed her frustration with step dad turned step mum, Caitlyn Jenner, saying his transition has killed any relationship they had. She said; "I don't know this person anymore. Bruce is gone, and I don't know Caitlyn. Simple as that. They have way different personalities. Polar opposites. Genuinely they are two different people....