OPINION: CBN and the Nigerian economy – Henry Boyo

Published:21 Jan, 2013

CBN-HeadquartersLast Monday, January 14, the Pastor Tunde Bakare-led ‘Save Nigeria Group’ marked the anniversary of the 2012 “Occupy Nigeria” fuel subsidy protest in Lagos with a public lecture titled “Nigeria’s Fiscal and Monetary Crisis: the Way Forward”.  The occasion afforded the Central Bank of Nigeria the opportunity to publicly defend its failure to create an enabling environment for industries and businesses to bloom, in consonance with its core mandate for price stability.  The major indicators of price stability, of course, relate to conducive low single-digit interest rates for bank loans and an even lower inflation rate.

I was privileged to be a guest speaker at the forum, where the CBN Directors of Research and Finance argued that it was virtually impossible to resolve what they described as the “unholy trinity” of low interest and inflation rates, and simultaneously also improve  naira’s exchange rate.

Nonetheless, the apex bank commended its own performance on these indices when compared with other economies in West Africa.  Why they chose to benchmark their performance against ducks, when indeed, they should be aspiring to be eagles, remains unclear.

However, the directors were hard pressed to identify any nation that successfully grew its economy with cost of funds to the real sector at over 20 per cent, and abiding inflation rate at over 12 per cent, while its domestic currency rate is constantly threatened by increasing export dollar revenue.  In order to compensate for its failure to enthrone an enabling monetary strategy, the CBN reported its involvement in several projects such as the cash-lite policy and various selective bailout packages involving hundreds of billions of naira.

The source of these huge cash injections including the N1bn donation to a particular university remains a mystery. Regrettably, these rogue interventions have so far failed to revitalise beneficiary subsectors and stimulate economic growth and employment opportunities.

Interestingly, the CBN rejected responsibility for the nation’s poor infrastructural base, as well as blame for the inability to diversify production in our economy.  The apex bank’s representatives were obviously in denial of the fact that massive infrastructural enhancement is impossible with double digit interest and inflation rates. For example, Bi-Courtney would most probably have since revamped the Lagos-Ibadan Expressway if cost of funds were as low as five  per cent rather than 20 per cent or more.  Also, the agricultural, power, aviation, textile, transport and other sectors would similarly be much stronger if operators in each sector also had access to much cheaper funds.

Indeed, Nigeria’s paltry annual capital budget of barely $9bn indicates that our hope for rapid infrastructural enhancement is better placed on private sector investments.

Nonetheless, the CBN boasted that only the uninformed would demand a stronger naira rate of exchange, as textbook economics suggests that a strong naira rate would make Nigerian products more expensive than imports!  The fallacy of this argument was obviously ignored, as reckless depreciation of the naira from stronger than parity to about N160:$1 has obviously had a negative rather than a positive growth impact on exports and other sectors of the Nigerian economy.  The CBN certainly misses the point that the demand for oil, our major export, does not depend on naira’s exchange rate!

Surprisingly, the CBN’s understanding of its core mandate of price stability seems related primarily to modulation of excessive high and low cycles in the levels of interest and inflation rates rather than the promotion of enabling rates as in industrialised and successful economies elsewhere!  Besides, according to the CBN, the capital market remains a cheap source of funds for all investors, including Small and Medium Enterprises.

The CBN directors were obviously acquainted with my strident advocacy for an urgent review of Nigeria’s monetary strategy, but quickly described the thrust of our argument as “misleading, misguiding and miseducating”!  Regrettably, however, they failed to demonstrate the logic beneath this questionable conclusion.

They also failed to justify why Nigeria’s economy has remained a victim of surplus cash for decades, or indeed, why the burden of excess liquidity exists side by side with the failure of the real sector to access adequate and cheap funds!  Besides, there was no satisfactory explanation why the CBN combats inflation by borrowing back perceived excess cash in the economy from commercial banks at rates above 12 per cent, only to warehouse the loans as idle funds.  It is inexplicable that any commodity would become more expensive whenever the market is awash with a surplus of that item, especially when the CBN also agrees that our high rates were the product of market demand and supply.

The CBN is obviously unrepentant for crowding out the real sector by borrowing at outrageous levels of interest rate while such risk-free sovereign borrowings in successful economies elsewhere generally attract lower single-digit interest rates; rates level, which the CBN insists are inapplicable in our state of development.

The directors did not even attempt to fault my observation that the CBN’s inability to achieve its core mandate of price stability is actually the product of its poor management of money supply!  It is nonetheless, irrefutable that the ever-present burden of excess liquidity induces heavy government borrowings at high interest rates and also fuels inflation rate as the increasingly huge cash surplus in the system cannot be immediately matched by available goods and services.  This systemic cash surplus is regularly pitched against relatively paltry dollar auctions by the CBN, and this ultimately also depreciates naira’s exchange rate!

Undoubtedly, the CBN’s alleged “unholy trinity” of interest, inflation and exchange rates have a common causative influence; i.e. the ever-present burden of excess liquidity.

Instructively, massive reduction or total elimination of excess liquidity will actually create a “holy trinity” of lower single-digit interest and inflation rates and also engender a stronger naira, all of which constitute the requisite profile for an enabling environment for growth and economic development with increasing employment opportunities.

In truth, the economic poison of excess liquidity is not administered by increased government spending, as often alleged, but by CBN’s capture of the nation’s dollar revenue and substitution with naira allocations to the three tiers of government.

The CBN’s claim that they are compelled by the constitution to substitute naira allocation for dollar revenue is certainly not substantiated by Section 162 of the constitution, which simply states that all monies must be paid into the federation account.  The section really does not stop the three tiers of government from maintaining domiciliary accounts just like any other citizen.

We will discuss the CBN’s lion share of our reserves next week!

 

Henry Boyo (lesleba@lesleba.com

  • Great insights into the dilapidation in our economy, from the above write up, it’s obvious that we need strong policies to check liquidity level in Nigeria.

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Edo 2016: Of Afemailand, Its Politics And Legacies by Daniel Afekhume

A video emerged last week where a dispassionate President Obama was telling the Black Community that it will be a "Personal Insult" to himself and Michelle if blacks don’t come out in their numbers to vote Hillary Clinton. His argument was that Trump was coming to destroy his "legacies" and by extension that of African-Americans. In the same light, I wish to state the Edo Governorship election of Sept 28th is one for either the preservation or destruction of the...

Boko Haram Leader Shekau Mentally Ill – Army

The Nigerian Army has described the embattled leader of Boko Haram, Abubakar Shekau, as mentally ill following the release of the latest video in which the terror group leader denied claims made by the army that he was seriously injured. “The video has shown beyond all reasonable doubt the earlier suspicion that the purported factional terrorist group leader is mentally sick and unstable,” the spokesman for the Nigerian Army, Sani Usman, said in a statement on...

Ambode Seeks Stronger Tie With Judiciary

The Governor of Lagos State, Akinwunmi Ambode, has called for the continuation of the cordial relationship and peace, which he said exists between the judiciary and the executive arm of government in Lagos State. The governor, who described the judiciary as the last hope of the citizens, also admonished the Chief Judge of the state, Justice Oluwafunmilayo Atilade, and the rest of the judges to continue to dispense justice with the fear of God. Ambode...

Edo guber: IGP Idris orders restriction of movement

The Inspector-General of Police, Ibrahim Idris, has ordered restriction of movement during Wednesday’s governorship election in Edo State. He also ordered the activation of the revised operation plan for the election. The operation plan, according to a statement issued in Abuja on Monday by the Force Spokesman, Don Awunah, is expected to guarantee free, fair and credible election, secure electoral process, enable eligible voters exercise their franchise freely and voluntary, protect election materials and officials and ensure adequate security before, during...

No amount of intimidation will stop our reconstruction efforts — Shettima

Governor Kashim Shettima of Borno on Monday said he was going ahead with the planned rebuilding of damaged buildings in spite of recent attacks by Boko Haram insurgents in some parts of the state. Shettima stated this while interacting with newsmen in Bama, headquarters of Bama Local Government Area of the state. He was reacting to the recent attacks by insurgents at the border villages of Logumani and Dara/Jamal, where an army officer and two soldiers were killed. The governor, who relocated...

Despite recession, Dangote vows to scale up investments in Nigeria, Africa

In recognition of his immense contribution to human capital development in Africa through the establishment of businesses across the African continent, a United States of America-based Organization, Africa-America Institute (AAI) has honoured the President of Dangote Group, Aliko Dangote, with the “2016 African Business Leader Award.” The business guru was named and presented the award at a colourful ceremony held on the side-line of the United Nations Congress held in New York city, United States alongside other prominent Africans like...

Boko Haram: You have not seen the worst – Shekau

The leader of Boko Haram has mocked claims he was seriously injured by the Nigerian military and warned “you have not seen the worst yet”. In a video posted on social media, Abubakar Shekau dismissed claims by the Nigerian air force that he had been seriously wounded in a raid, telling them: “I will not get killed until my time comes”. The leader of the Islamist militant group also taunted parents of the kidnapped Chibok schoolgirls, telling them their children would...

Lagos begins enforcement of Ikoyi, Victoria Island clean-up

Four weeks after issuing public notices and ultimatum, the Lagos State Special Task Force on the Clean-Up of Ikoyi, Victoria Island over the weekend started the clearing of all illegal structures and shanties. The Clean-Up operation team which was led by the Chairman of the Task Force on Environmental and Special Offences, Supol Yinka Egbeyemi, commenced simultaneously in Ikoyi and Victoria Island at 8am on Saturday and has continued on Sunday morning. It featured the removal of kiosks, sheds by the...

Únity Schools Old Students’ Association (USOSA) Announces Date And Theme For 2016 Annual General Meeting

The Unity Schools Old Students' Association (USOSA) has announced November 4th and 5th as dates for its 2016 annual general meeting. According to details released by the organising committee, the annual general meeting is scheduled to hold by 10am on 4th November with a dinner set for the following day by 4pm. The theme for the 2016 annual general meeting is Education, National Unity & Security. The event will hold at Lekki Coliseum, Lekki Phase 1, Lagos.

Labour threaten to shutdown Nigeria over planned national assets sale

Oil workers, under the aegis of the Petroleum and Natural Gas Senior Staff Association of Nigeria, have threatened to shut down the country should the Federal Government carry out its plan to sell national assets to augment revenue shortfall. Also, the Trade Union Congress on Sunday said it would join PENGASSAN to shut down the country if the government remained adamant on its plan to sell some national assets. PENGASSAN, in a statement on Sunday by its National Public Relations Officer,...

NAF explores agriculture to empower barracks youths

Nigerian military is not left out in the nation’s search for a solution to the economic recession the oil-rich nation slid into few weeks ago, as the Chief of Air Staff, Air Marshal Sadique Abubakar, is exploring agriculture to empower youths in barracks. He is confident that further involvement of youths in agriculture will deepen the economic diversification drive of the government. Nigeria is battling to get out of its present economic recession made obvious when the National Bureau of Statistics...

Stop terrorising Zimbabweans or we’ll impeach you – Church leaders tell Mugabe

He’s not as well-known as protest pastor Evan Mawarire. But this Zimbabwe church leader’s brave plea to President Robert Mugabe to stop terrorising protesters or face impeachment may attract the attention of the authorities. Already questioned by police and arrested at least once during the past few months, Bishop Ancelimo Magaya is one of five Zimbabwe church men who this weekend penned an open letter to the 92-year-old Mugabe asking him to “stop unleashing terror on citizens for expressing genuine...

Insane Shekau must release Chibok girls unconditionally – Army

The Nigerian Army has described the controversial factional leader of Boko Haram terrorists, as mentally ill and unstable person whose end is near, despite issuing threats in the latest video. The Director of Army Public Relations (DAPR), Col. Sani Usman, in a statement yesterday, said the video clip is a mere propaganda and sign of desperation for a man who was reported to have been “Fatally wounded” in military air strike. “The attention of the Nigerian Army has been drawn to...

NESREA warns against cutting of trees without replacement

The State Coordinator of National Environmental Standards & Regulations Enforcement Agency (NESREA) in Kwara, Mr. Martins Enenwaene, has warned that cutting of trees without replacement leads to ecological imbalance. Enenwaene gave the warning while speaking with the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) Ilorin on Monday. He said that massive deforestation contributed to the destruction of properties by heavy storm. The NESREA boss said the state had faced different flood cases which were later traced to not having enough trees. Enenwaene said that, “NESREA...

Lungu Lied at UN Summit – Ex-Zambian Leader Scott

Former Zambian president Guy Scott has criticised President Edgar Lungu over the remarks he made during the recently ended United Nations summit in New York. Lungu told the UN 71st summit last week that Africa did not need any strong leaders but strong institutions, adding that his country endeavoured to build a peaceful, just and inclusive society “through the consolidation” of power. Lungu described Zambia as a democracy with an inclusive society where its people enjoyed many freedoms. “The importance of democracy...

BREAKING: Judge Withdraws From Nnamdi Kanu’s Trial

John Tsoho, the judge handling Nnamdi Kanu’s trial, has returned the case file to Ibrahim Auta, chief justice of federal high court, for reassignment. This was sequel to an application by the legal team of Kanu led by Chuks Muoma, claiming that the court was biased in its handling of the matter. “We are only asking the court to hands off; my client has lost confidence in this court,” he said. He claimed that the court was acting in line with the...

Minister Denies Spending N3.4bn On “Change Begins With Me” Campaign

The Minister of Information and Culture, Alhaji Lai Mohammed, has demanded a retraction of libelous publications by the Daily Independent newspaper, Omo Bazuaye and Akin Fadeyi over “Change Begins With Me” campaign. The minister made the demand in letters written to the newspaper, Bazuaye and Fadeyi by Falana & Falana’s Chamber, a law firm of a renown civil right activist and lawyer, Femi Falana. The letters dated Sept. 19 and signed by a lawyer Oludare...

Patience Jonathan To Drag EFCC Before West African Court

Former first lady, Mrs Patience Ibifaka Jonathan has concluded plans to drag the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to the African Commission of Human and Peoples Right in Gambia. Sources close to the legal team said they took the decision to seek legal redress in a court free from manipulation. Already a new group, The Rebranded Indigenous People of Biafra (TRIPOB) has thrown its weight behind the decision to drag the EFCC before the African Commission of Human and Peopless...

Rihanna Named Global Ambassador for Childhood Education

Rihanna is “Work”-ing on education. The global superstar’s Clara Lionel Foundation has partnered up with Global Partnership for Education and Global Citizen on a multi-year initiative to support education across the world. Through this push, Rihanna hopes to advocate for more than a quarter of a billion children who are not currently in school as well as about 330 million students who aren’t learning in the schools they’re in.

3 People You Should Never Take Relationship Advice From (MUST READ)

1. Anyone who is angry and bitter Was your best friend a jilted bride or a groom who was stood up at the altar? Don’t ask friends or family with a chip on their shoulder how to win at love. If you hang around them long enough, their attitude could rub off on you. Then no one will want to date you because you have such a bad attitude. Don’t let someone else’s bad experiences warp...

The 1 Thing Happy Couples Do Every Day

Happy couples communicate with each other. Constant communication seems so obvious, but it can easily slip through the cracks. In order to keep your relationship healthy and happy, there's three things you need to do to communicate successfully. 1. Express your needs and feelings. There's no way for your partner to know what you want out of your relationship if you don't say so. Make sure to clearly express how you are feeling —...