OPINION: CBN and the Nigerian economy – Henry Boyo

Published:21 Jan, 2013

CBN-HeadquartersLast Monday, January 14, the Pastor Tunde Bakare-led ‘Save Nigeria Group’ marked the anniversary of the 2012 “Occupy Nigeria” fuel subsidy protest in Lagos with a public lecture titled “Nigeria’s Fiscal and Monetary Crisis: the Way Forward”.  The occasion afforded the Central Bank of Nigeria the opportunity to publicly defend its failure to create an enabling environment for industries and businesses to bloom, in consonance with its core mandate for price stability.  The major indicators of price stability, of course, relate to conducive low single-digit interest rates for bank loans and an even lower inflation rate.

I was privileged to be a guest speaker at the forum, where the CBN Directors of Research and Finance argued that it was virtually impossible to resolve what they described as the “unholy trinity” of low interest and inflation rates, and simultaneously also improve  naira’s exchange rate.

Nonetheless, the apex bank commended its own performance on these indices when compared with other economies in West Africa.  Why they chose to benchmark their performance against ducks, when indeed, they should be aspiring to be eagles, remains unclear.

However, the directors were hard pressed to identify any nation that successfully grew its economy with cost of funds to the real sector at over 20 per cent, and abiding inflation rate at over 12 per cent, while its domestic currency rate is constantly threatened by increasing export dollar revenue.  In order to compensate for its failure to enthrone an enabling monetary strategy, the CBN reported its involvement in several projects such as the cash-lite policy and various selective bailout packages involving hundreds of billions of naira.

The source of these huge cash injections including the N1bn donation to a particular university remains a mystery. Regrettably, these rogue interventions have so far failed to revitalise beneficiary subsectors and stimulate economic growth and employment opportunities.

Interestingly, the CBN rejected responsibility for the nation’s poor infrastructural base, as well as blame for the inability to diversify production in our economy.  The apex bank’s representatives were obviously in denial of the fact that massive infrastructural enhancement is impossible with double digit interest and inflation rates. For example, Bi-Courtney would most probably have since revamped the Lagos-Ibadan Expressway if cost of funds were as low as five  per cent rather than 20 per cent or more.  Also, the agricultural, power, aviation, textile, transport and other sectors would similarly be much stronger if operators in each sector also had access to much cheaper funds.

Indeed, Nigeria’s paltry annual capital budget of barely $9bn indicates that our hope for rapid infrastructural enhancement is better placed on private sector investments.

Nonetheless, the CBN boasted that only the uninformed would demand a stronger naira rate of exchange, as textbook economics suggests that a strong naira rate would make Nigerian products more expensive than imports!  The fallacy of this argument was obviously ignored, as reckless depreciation of the naira from stronger than parity to about N160:$1 has obviously had a negative rather than a positive growth impact on exports and other sectors of the Nigerian economy.  The CBN certainly misses the point that the demand for oil, our major export, does not depend on naira’s exchange rate!

Surprisingly, the CBN’s understanding of its core mandate of price stability seems related primarily to modulation of excessive high and low cycles in the levels of interest and inflation rates rather than the promotion of enabling rates as in industrialised and successful economies elsewhere!  Besides, according to the CBN, the capital market remains a cheap source of funds for all investors, including Small and Medium Enterprises.

The CBN directors were obviously acquainted with my strident advocacy for an urgent review of Nigeria’s monetary strategy, but quickly described the thrust of our argument as “misleading, misguiding and miseducating”!  Regrettably, however, they failed to demonstrate the logic beneath this questionable conclusion.

They also failed to justify why Nigeria’s economy has remained a victim of surplus cash for decades, or indeed, why the burden of excess liquidity exists side by side with the failure of the real sector to access adequate and cheap funds!  Besides, there was no satisfactory explanation why the CBN combats inflation by borrowing back perceived excess cash in the economy from commercial banks at rates above 12 per cent, only to warehouse the loans as idle funds.  It is inexplicable that any commodity would become more expensive whenever the market is awash with a surplus of that item, especially when the CBN also agrees that our high rates were the product of market demand and supply.

The CBN is obviously unrepentant for crowding out the real sector by borrowing at outrageous levels of interest rate while such risk-free sovereign borrowings in successful economies elsewhere generally attract lower single-digit interest rates; rates level, which the CBN insists are inapplicable in our state of development.

The directors did not even attempt to fault my observation that the CBN’s inability to achieve its core mandate of price stability is actually the product of its poor management of money supply!  It is nonetheless, irrefutable that the ever-present burden of excess liquidity induces heavy government borrowings at high interest rates and also fuels inflation rate as the increasingly huge cash surplus in the system cannot be immediately matched by available goods and services.  This systemic cash surplus is regularly pitched against relatively paltry dollar auctions by the CBN, and this ultimately also depreciates naira’s exchange rate!

Undoubtedly, the CBN’s alleged “unholy trinity” of interest, inflation and exchange rates have a common causative influence; i.e. the ever-present burden of excess liquidity.

Instructively, massive reduction or total elimination of excess liquidity will actually create a “holy trinity” of lower single-digit interest and inflation rates and also engender a stronger naira, all of which constitute the requisite profile for an enabling environment for growth and economic development with increasing employment opportunities.

In truth, the economic poison of excess liquidity is not administered by increased government spending, as often alleged, but by CBN’s capture of the nation’s dollar revenue and substitution with naira allocations to the three tiers of government.

The CBN’s claim that they are compelled by the constitution to substitute naira allocation for dollar revenue is certainly not substantiated by Section 162 of the constitution, which simply states that all monies must be paid into the federation account.  The section really does not stop the three tiers of government from maintaining domiciliary accounts just like any other citizen.

We will discuss the CBN’s lion share of our reserves next week!

 

Henry Boyo (lesleba@lesleba.com

  • http://emmahenry1010@wordpress.com Henry emmanuel

    Great insights into the dilapidation in our economy, from the above write up, it’s obvious that we need strong policies to check liquidity level in Nigeria.

Related Posts

Recent Posts

EFCC Storms Fani-Kayode’s House

Operatives of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission have stormed the home of a former Minister of Aviation, Chief Femi Fani-Kayode, for receiving N840m from the Director of Finance, Goodluck Jonathan Campaign Organisation, Senator Nenadi Usman. Fani-Kayode wrote on his official Facebook page, “Today the EFCC invited me to come their office on Monday. I have their letter. I agreed to be there. Now they have surrounded my house. “The letter of invitation was served this morning and it was dated...

Returning PDP Members Should Be Stoned Like Satan In Kaaba – Gov. Shettima

The Borno State Governor, Kashim Shettima, has berated members of the state Chapter of the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP, who left when there was an internal crisis only to return when peace has being restored. Shettima said this during the distribution of relief materials to Internally Displaced Persons, IDPs, in Maiduguri, the state capital, by the National Logistics Committee on Distribution of Relief Materials. According to the governor, “The politicians who left us to our troubles in the last five years...

Full Text Of President Buhari’s Speech At Signing Of 2016 Budget

1. It gives me great pleasure today to sign the first full-year budget of this administration into law. I thank the leadership of the National Assembly, in particular, the Senate President and the Speaker of the House of Representatives, and indeed all members of the National Assembly for their cooperation in making this a reality. 2. The budget is intended to signpost a renewal of our commitment to restoring the budget as a serious article of faith with the Nigerian...

Budget 2016 Shows We Can Work Together For The People – Saraki

The Senate President, Bukola Saraki said on Friday that the signing of the appropriation bill into law showed that the legislative and executive arms could come together to work for the electorate. He said this in his remark at the signing of the N6.06 trillion appropriation bill into law by President Muhammadu Buhari. ``We have shown again that, despite the challenges, we can come together again and work as a government in the interest of the people that put us here. ``We...

Nigeria Solicits EU’s Support On Corruption, IDPs

The Federal Government has solicited more support from the European Union (EU) in addressing the country’s problems, especially corruption and Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs). Senior Special Assistant (SSA) to the President on Foreign Affairs and Diaspora, Mrs Abike Dabiri-Erewa, made the call when the Head of EU delegation to Nigeria and ECOWAS, Amb. Michel Arion visited her on Thursday in Abuja. Dabiri-Erewa commended the EU for its efforts at assisting the country, adding that much could still be done by Europe...

Ukraine To Invest $1bn In Ajaokuta Steel Company

The Ukrainian Ambassador to Nigeria Mr Valeriy Aleksandruk has said that his country is ready to invest one billion dollars into Ajaokuta Steel Company in order to revive the plant. This is according to a statement by Mr Alex Okoh, Head, Public Communications, Bureau of Public Enterprises (BPE) in Abuja on Thursday. It said that the ambassador made the disclosure when he paid a courtesy call on the Acting Director General of the BPE, Mr Vincent Akpotaire. It also stated that Aleksandruk...

N165bn Monthly Salaries of Federal Civil Servants Not sustainable – Adeosun

  The Minister of Finance, Kemi Adeosun said on Thursday in Lagos that the N165 billion monthly salaries to federal civil servants was over-bloated and could no longer be sustained by government. The minister spoke at a meeting with Newspaper Proprietors Association of Nigeria (NPAN) hosted by her counterpart in the Ministry of Information and Culture, Alhaji Lai Mohammed. Adeosun who was speaking on the economy reform agenda of the government said that the N165 billion being paid to federal civil servants monthly...

Buhari’s Govt In Talks With US Government For Purchase Of 12 Super Tucano Attack Planes

As the fight against terrorism continues, the Federal government is presently in talks with the US government for the acquisition of 12 specialized attack planes known as Super Tucano planes. Senior Special Assistant to President Buhari on Media and Publicity, Shehu Garba, confirmed this to BBC. The Super Tucano is a propeller-driven plane that can carry a range of weapons and can be used for attack and surveillance.

President Buhari Finally Signs 2016 Budget Into Law

President Muhammadu Buhari has on Friday, finally signed the 2016 appropriation bill into law. Vice President Yemi Osinbajo, Chairmen of the National Assembly Appropriation Committees were present at the signing in ceremony which held at the presidential villa. This development is coming few hours after the National Assembly submitted a corrected copy of the budget to the President. In April, NASS transmitted details of the budget to the president after it had...

FCTA Set To Provide Land For Low Income Houses

The Minister of FCT, Malam Muhammad Bello, on Thursday said the administration would partner with Federal Mortgage Bank of Nigeria (FMBN) to develop houses for low-income workers in the territory. Bello stated this while receiving a delegation of the bank led by its Acting Managing Director, Mr Richard Esien in in Abuja. The minister, however, made case for the consideration FCT Administration workers first; observing that the administration had the highest number of employees in the territory. He said there were so...

AEDC Decries Vandalism Of Electrical Installations

The Abuja Electricity Distribution Company (AEDC) has identified vandalism of electrical installation, non-payment of electricity bills as challenges in the distribution of electricity to its customers. Its Regional Manager, Mrs Hauwa Mohammad, said in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Abuja on Thursday that the activities of vandals was a major challenge to the company.   ``In every company, fund has been the challenge, because people are actually not responding to billing. ``The major challenge should be fund, because customers are not responding and as well...

Sheriff, Others Must Go – PDP Northern Elders

A group known as Peoples Democratic Party Northern Elders, has called on the National Chairman of the party, Sen. Ali Modu Sheriff and other members of the party’s National Working Committee to vacate office on May 21. It also called for the postponement of the party’s national convention slated for that date in Port Harcourt, Rivers State. The group led by a former...

Ghost Workers: Yobe To Save N2bn – Gaidam

The Yobe Government on Thursday projected that it would save over N2 billion at the end of the on-going local government staff verification exercise in the state. The Governor, Alhaji Ibrahim Gaidam, made the projection while fielding questions from newsmen in Damaturu. He said that the state had so far saved N169 million in one month from seven local councils and expected the sum to rise to N250 million at the end of the exercise in the councils. Gaidam said over N2...

Protesters Set 17 Schools Ablaze In South Africa

South African protesters torched 17 government schools during violent protests against the redrawing of municipal boundaries ahead of local elections this year, police and education officials said Thursday. The protests started on Monday night in three neighbouring villages in the northern province of Limpopo when residents blockaded streets with rocks, pipes and burning tyres. Of the 22 schools that were attacked, two were destroyed and 17 were damaged by fire, leaving 26,000 students without classrooms, education ministry spokesman Elijah Mhlanga told...

Cross River Sea Port Construction To Begin In Three Months – Ayade

The Cross River State Governor, Prof. Ben Ayade, on Thursday disclosed that the construction of the state deep sea port would commence in three or four months. Ayade said this in an interview with State House correspondents shortly after meeting President Muhammadu Buhari at the Presidential Villa, Abuja. The governor said he was at the Presidential Villa to give Buhari updates on the two projects, the sea port and the super highway. He said preliminary and detailed designs had been completed while...

Herdsmen Killing: SERAP Sues FG At ECOWAS Court

The Registered Trustees of the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project have urged the Economic Community of West African States Court in Abuja to hold the Federal Government responsible for various violent incidents across the country leading to loss of property and human lives. The plaintiffs accused the Federal Government of permitting human rights violations in form of killings, raping and maiming of citizens by violent herdsmen, military and police operatives  because the Federal Government allegedly failed to address the situation. The...

Saraki Shuts Senate For One Week Over PDP Congresses

  Senate President, Bukola Saraki, on Thursday, adjourned plenary for one week to enable members of the Peoples Democratic Party, in the chamber, to attend the on-going party’s congresses. The senate did not consider any motion or bill as the number of senators present during the day’s plenary was not up to the required number to form a quorum. The absence of senators mostly from...

Ogbeh Harps On Imported Grass To Feed Cows

The Minister of Agriculture, Chief Audu Ogbeh, on Thursday said the importation and cultivation of good and nutritious grass will put a stop to the clashes between herdsmen and farmers. The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that Ogbeh said this in Lagos during interactive session with the Newspapers Proprietors Association of Nigeria (NPAN). He said that Nigerian cows, which should be among the best breed in the world, lacked the capacity to produce quality milk because they wandered about. ``The largest...

PDP Ready For LG Congress In Kaduna State – Gaiya

The Kaduna State Chairman of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Mr Abubakar Gaiya, on Thursday said that the party had concluded arrangements for ‘’a successful local government congress’’. Gaiya told the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Kaduna that 18 local officials and one Zonal officer would emerge from each of the local government areas after the congress. He said that the Prince Tajudeen Aleshinloye-led 11-man Congress Committee had arrived the state capital ahead of the local government congress. NAN recalls that...

Minister Seeks Review Of Business Laws To Boost Investment

The Minister of Industry, Trade and Investment, Dr Okey Enelamah, has urged the National Assembly to review some of the existing business laws to provide the enabling environment to attract more investment into the country. Enelamah spoke on Thursday when he appeared before the House of Representatives for the ongoing ``Sectoral Debate’’ on strategies for the diversification of the nation’s economy. He said that legislative intervention was crucial to guarantee ease of doing business in the country. According to him, the Companies...

Army Headquarters Garrison Holds Route March Friday

The Army Headquarters Garrison will on Friday hold its Route March for officers and soldiers serving in the FCT, for May. This is contained in a statement issued by the Deputy Director, Army Public Relations, Col. Aliyu Yusuf in Abuja on Wednesday. The statement said the exercise would hold between 6:00 a.m. and 8:00 a.m., and that it would progress from the Guards Brigade Sports Complex to Niger Barracks to Mambilla Barracks and back to the Guards Brigade Sports Complex. It said...