How reduced budget deficit will challenge the economy – Henry Boyo

Published:7 Jan, 2013

In successful economies, budgets are usually laid before the respective national parliaments many months before the commencement of the New Year to provide the lawmakers with adequate time to assess and interpret the potential impact of the proposed budget.  The legislature’s judgment would invariably also be guided by evidence of actual implementation of the outgoing year’s budget, in order to ensure transparency and also avoid duplication in expenditures in the new budget under consideration.

However, since the advent of civil rule in Nigeria, the Federal executive has routinely presented the budget to the legislature between November and December each year; such late submission delayed budget approval until well into the first, and sometimes even the second quarter of the year for which the budget was designed.  It was, therefore, a welcome departure from tradition when the National Assembly received the 2013 budget proposals from the President in early October 2012.  The early submission allowed the legislature to effectively sharpen its oversight functions on a host of government ministries and agencies, and in the process, uncover huge shortfalls between approved budget sums and actual implementation in 2012.  Indeed, some critics maintain that the legislative oversight inspection and fact-finding visits could not have been thorough considering the hundreds of government agencies that needed to be examined within the very limited time available.  Critics have always blamed poor budget implementations on the late passage of budgets.  However, the evidence of large unspent funds in the coffers of government agencies nationwide at the end of each year may not corroborate this observation.

Incidentally, the Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, Dr. Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, had promised, at the beginning of her tenure, to ensure that budgets were promptly laid before the National Assembly, to allow the Legislature and the Executive adequate time to consult and agree on Mr. President’s budget proposals.  In reality, if our annual budgets are based on a rolling three to five year medium term framework, it should be possible to lay the Appropriation Bill before the National Assembly in August/September each year.  Nonetheless, we commend Okonjo-Iweala for the earlier-than-usual budget presentation.  Indeed, if the Appropriation bill receives President Goodluck Jonathan’s assent in the next week or so, late presentation would not be a valid reason for failure to fully implement the 2013 budget.

However, it seems Nigerians may have placed too much faith on the impact of comprehensive budget implementation.  After all, the total capital budget of about N1.7tn is equal to just about $9bn, an amount that is grossly inadequate when compared with the speculated requirement of over $100bn just for provision of adequate power nationwide.  Indeed Okonjo-Iweala had also promised to gradually reduce recurrent expenditure ratio below 70 per cent in steps of between one and two per cent annually!  In this event, however, analysts have observed that it would take between 10 and 20 years to raise capital expenditure above 50 per cent of the total spending.  These analysts contend that such snail speed adjustment is not in consonance with the realities of our severe infrastructural deprivations.  It is argued that our infrastructural predicament requires a surgical procedure with a battle-axe rather than a thin-edged razor blade.  Nonetheless, critics also insist that early assent to the 2013 Appropriation Bill is no guarantee for full budget implementation.

Fortunately, the adoption of a crude oil price benchmark of $79 per barrel instead of the Executive’s insistence on $75 per barrel would mean a daily accretion of about $10m (i.e. $3.6bn annually) to budgeted revenue.  Thus, the earlier projected 2013 budget deficit of almost a trillion naira would fall by over N550bn with the higher benchmark.  The additional $4 per barrel would consequently also reduce the need for additional government borrowing to finance the proposed trillion naira deficit, which evolved from the initial deliberate understatement of crude oil price benchmark.  Indeed, with prevailing interest rates of between 15 per cent and 17 per cent for government borrowings, we would also avert liability for additional debt service charges of over N75bn if crude oil benchmark had remained at $75 per barrel as per the Executive’s proposals.  These huge savings are undoubtedly positive outcomes as our debt burden will fall by over N550bn in 2013!

Then again, they say,  “All that glitters is not gold”. The additional $4 per barrel has an ugly flip side;  the resultant increase in total dollar revenue of over $3.6bn would paradoxically create severe challenges in the economy as the substitution of naira allocations for the increased dollar revenue will exacerbate the spectre of surplus cash (excess liquidity) when over N550bn is lodged into the bank accounts of beneficiaries of the federation pool this year.  This huge cash inflow into the vaults of commercial banks will sustain additional liquidity and increase credit capacity of the banks by over N5tn.  In such event, the Central Bank of Nigeria would ‘altruistically’ step in to deepen the ‘racket’ of mopping up excess liquidity with greater vigor.  Consequently, the CBN would be induced to borrow hundreds of billions of naira it does not need, while paying interest of between 10 per cent and 15 per cent for the joy of just warehousing idle public funds and sequestering the funds from a credit-starved real sector.  The profits of commercial banks and other investors in government securities will ultimately become bloated by an additional sum of over N100bn with such government borrowings.  Thus, the increased dollar revenue stimulated by higher crude benchmark will, ultimately, also deepen our debt burden inexplicably.

We may deduce from the above that our economy appears severely challenged by the prospect of increasing dollar revenue.  Paradoxically, increasing dollar revenue will inevitably impel the CBN’s creation of additional naira, which will ultimately result in the albatross of excess liquidity or surplus cash in the system;  as if on cue the CBN will step in to contain the prevailing ‘surplus cash’ with increased government borrowings at suicidal rates of interests!  The CBN’s response will also crowd out the real sector from available credit in the market, and the resultant high cost of borrowing will further precipitate inflation, industrial contraction and increasing rate of unemployment.

However, the hydra-headed dilemma of increasing dollar revenue and increasing debt and the paradox of increasing wealth and deepening poverty will only be satisfactorily resolved when the CBN ceases substituting naira allocations for distributable dollar-derived revenue.  The above analysis should answer any question regarding the social prospects of the impact of the 2013 budget.

 

Henry Boyo (lesleba@lesleba.com)

Related Posts

Recent Posts

FG Approves Review Of Counter-Terrorism Strategy.

The Federal Government on Tuesday took stock of its war against terrorism, especially since the inception of President Muhammadu Buhari, and effected changes in its counter-terrorism strategy.   In doing this, the Presidency attributed the popularity that the terrorist sect seemed to enjoy during the immediate past administration on embezzlement perpetrated by those who stole funds meant to acquire equipment to fight terrorism in the North-East.   Buhari made the remarks at the launch of the reviewed National Counter-terrorism Strategy (NACTEST), which was...

5 Reasons Pretty Girls Are Still Single

1. She's grown out of "dating for the sake of dating." These girls are not into wasting their time or energy on a guy they really can't see themselves being with long term. Casual dates just seem like a waste of time. It doesn't mean she isn't interested in dating, she's just not interested in attending ONE more mediocre date. Mediocre dates happen solely for the sake of going on a date. This is a concept...

LOL! You Won’t Believe What This 105-Year-Old Woman Requested For Her Birthday

After 105 years on this planet, all Ivena "Ivy" Smailes wanted for her birthday was a bunch of "hunky firefighters" to sweep her off her feet — and that's exactly what she got. Thanks to the crew over at Addison Court Care Home in Crawcrook, England, Smailes was surrounded by 40 friends and family members along with five gorgeous firefighters from the Tyne and Wear Fire and Rescue Service for her birthday...

Cancelled Kano Mass Wedding Leaves Couples Frustrated- Report

Twenty-two-year-old Inuwa Inuwa and his 16-year-old girlfriend Kaishia Yunusa are in love. “I met him three years ago when I was 13. Other suitors were coming, but I fell in love with him and now he is the only one,” says Kaishia. “I liked her because she is very kind and she has a very good upbringing. She upholds the teachings of Islam,” Inuwa says. Both are from agrarian families in a rural community...

Flood Destroys 300 Houses In Yobe

Alhaji Musa Jidawa, Executive Secretary, Yobe State Emergency Management Agency (SEMA), on Wednesday, said that over 300 houses, farmlands and livestock had been destroyed by flood in Jakusko and Adaya communities. He made the disclosure in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Damaturu. Jidawa said, “We received report of over 250 houses destroyed in Jakusko and about 54 others in Adaya but no life was lost, the affected people are taking shelter with relations in the communities.” The...

Adamawa Workers Shut Government House, Demand Removal Of Some Officials

Civil servants in Adamawa State on Tuesday staged a protest in front of the Government House Yola calling for the removal of three government officials from office.   The protesters, led by the state chairman of the Nigeria Labour Congress, Dauda Maina, shut the entrance to the Government House for several hours.   They were demanding for the sacking of the Chairman of the Adamawa State Primary Healthcare Agency, Dr. Abdullahi Belel.   They also demanded for the sacking of the Executive Secretary Adamawa State...

Buhari’s Fight Against Corruption Not Targeted At Any Party – AGF Insists

Federation, AGF, and Minister of Justice, Mr. Abubakar Malami, SAN, yesterday insisted that President Muhammadu Buhari’s fight against corruption was not targeted at any particular political party, and that nobody who is found to be corrupt would be spared. Speaking at the ongoing 56th annual general conference of the Nigerian Bar Association, NBA, in Port Harcourt, the Rivers State capital, he declared that there are no sacred cows in the anti-corruption campaign of the administration of Buhari. The minister stated...

Prices Of Rice, Corn, Other Food stuff Crash

PM News is reporting that the prices of food items have crashed in Hadejia, Jigawa state. Quoting News Agency of Nigeria (NAN), PM News reports that the crash in food price is as a result of ‘a significant increase in the supply of agricultural produce to the market’. According to investigations by NAN on Tuesday at Hadejia market, food prices were down by about 30 percent. Now, a bag of millet goes for N14, 000 as against N18, 000 while...

“Anti-Corruption War Will Be Institutionalized”, President Buhari Assures.

President Muhammadu Buhari has pledged that the anti-corruption crusade in the country will be deepened and institutionalized to last beyond the life of the current administration.   Receiving American Secretary of State, Mr John Kerry, at an audience in State House, Abuja, Tuesday, the President declared: “We will insist on the standards we’re establishing. We are laying down administrative and financial instructions in the public service that must be obeyed. Any breach will no longer be acceptable.”   “We will retrain our staff,...

Shallow Graves Found In Lagos Pastor’s Home

The police in Lagos yesterday claimed that shallow graves were discovered at the residence of 70-year-old Prophet Emmanuel Adeyemi arrested for chaining his son and 27 others. Police Commissioner Fatai Owoseni who confirmed the allegation said the place was raided following a tip-off that the suspect traded human parts to ritualists. He claimed that Adeyemi who was arrested alongside his first wife on Friday, buried some dead persons in the swamps and three others at...

Olympic Flag Arrives In Tokyo For 2020 Games

The Olympic flag arrived in Tokyo on Wednesday as Japan’s capital gears up to host the 2020 Games, with officials promising smooth sailing after Rio’s sometimes shaky 2016 instalment. Tokyo governor Yuriko Koike carried the flag during a ceremony at Haneda airport after stepping off a plane from the Brazilian host city, accompanied by a delegation who picked up a record 41 medals in Rio. “I feel the full weight of the responsibility that this...

Aviation Workers Protest Privatisation Of MMIA, Others

Vehicular movements into the Murtala Muhammed Airport (MMA), Lagos, was difficult yesterday as airport workers staged a protest against the planned privatisation of four of the nation’s airports. There was a severe gridlock on the road as vehicles coming into the airport from the Ikeja axis and the NAHCo end of the road were obstructed by the protesting workers even though there were  policemen from the Lagos Domestic Airport Police Station on ground to ensure free flow of...

Police Arraign Katsina Prison Inmate For Attempted Suicide

A middle-aged man alleged to be a member of a gang of thieves in Dutsin-ma town, Katsina State, is currently standing trial before a Katsina Chief Magistrates’ Court for his alleged attempt to commit suicide while in police detention. The offence is contrary to Section 231 of the Penal Code. Abubakar Mustapha is also facing charges bordering on alleged disturbance of public peace under Section 113 of the Penal Code; mischief, under Section 327 of...

Akwa Ibom To Build Camps In Anticipation Of Flood

Akwa Ibom  State Government has directed the chairmen of 15 local government areas prone to flooding to build camps for rescue of victims in view of anticipated flood. The State Flood Sensitisation Campaign Team led by the Director of Administration, Deputy Governor’s Office, Mrs Ekaette Ekanem, gave the directive yesterday at Itu centre of the campaign. It was learnt that the state government had already categorised the 15 flood prone local government areas (LGAs) into four...

Bangladesh Praises Military On Boko Haram

The Bangladesh Armed Forces yesterday praised the military for its success in combating insurgency in the country. Bangladesh said it would adopt the same strategy in combating insurgency and criminality. A team from Bangladesh National Defence College on a geo-strategic study tour to Nigeria visited the Chief of Defence Staff (CDS), General Abayomi Gabriel Olonisakin at the Defence Headquarters, Abuja. The leader of the delegation, Rear Admiral Anwarul Islam, said the dramatic way in...

Lawmaker Kidnapped In Kaduna

A member of the Kaduna State House of Assembly, Ibrahim Ismaila, was yesterday abducted in front of his residence at Abakpa area of Kaduna. The lawmaker, who represents Tudun Wada constituency, was abducted at about 9:00 am as he came out of his house to go to his office, according to one of his aides. Ismaila, who was accompanied to the gate by his wife as he drove out of the premises, his aide said, was...

Man Who Named Dog Buhari Still In Prison

The man who named his dog Buhari, Joachim Iroko, aka Joe, has spent two days in the Ibara Prison, Abeokuta, due to the inability of his family members to perfect his bail conditions.   The Public Relations Officer, Nigerian Prisons Service, Ogun State Command, Victor Oyeleke, confirmed this to PUNCH Metro on Tuesday.   He told our correspondent on the telephone around 6.44pm that the defendant’s family members had yet to perfect his bail conditions.   He said, “The man is still in Ibara Prison....

Budget Scandal: Abdulmumin To Meet Presidential Arms Committee Aug 31

The sacked Chairman of the House of Representatives Committee on Appropriation, Hon. Jibrin Abdulmumin, has received an invitation from the Presidential Advisory Committee against Corruption to brief the committee on the allegations of corruption levelled against the House Speaker, Yakubu Dogara, and three principal officers. Abdulmumin revealed this on his twitter handle Tuesday. “In another victory for my...

Hajj Stoning To Be Shortened After Deadly Stampede

A stoning ritual which led to the deaths of about 2,300 people during last year’s hajj will be more tightly controlled during next month’s pilgrimage, Saudi newspapers reported on Wednesday. The period during which pilgrims can perform the Jamarat ritual will be reduced by 12 hours, the Saudi Gazette and Arab News said. The symbolic stoning of the devil will be performed as usual over three days beginning September 11 at Mina, about five kilometres...

No Criminal Implications In Naming Dog After Person- Lawyers

The incoming Second National Vice President of the Nigeria Bar Association, NBA, Mr. Monday Ubani, yesterday, said that no offence is committed by someone naming his dog after somebody else. He said: “In the eye of the law, it is not criminal for somebody to name his or her dog after another person. It may be offensive by examining the circumstances under which the incident happened. “I understand that a particular dog was named after...

Gov. Ayade’s Brother Arrested Over Alleged N2.4billion Fraud

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission has arrested a brother to Governor Ben Ayade of Cross Rivers State over alleged N2.4billion contract scam. Sources at the EFCC said that Francis Ayade was arrested on Tuesday in connection with the scam. Mr. Ayade, managing director of Leophina Nigeria Limited and Hally Brown International Limited, was fingered in alleged shady deals involving diversion of public funds into his companies’ accounts. “Specifically, four different allocations from the Federation...