CONSTITUTION AMENDMENT: IS A REFERENDUM REALLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL? BY TOLU OBAMUROH

Published:7 Dec, 2012

The Nigerian democracy is founded on the supremacy of the Constitution. The supremacy of the Constitution in turn rests on the understanding that it emanated from the collective will of the people. The preamble to the 1999 Constitution (as amended) says as much –

“We the people of the Federal Republic of Nigeria
Having firmly and solemnly resolved, to live in unity and harmony as one indivisible and indissoluble sovereign nation under God, dedicated to the promotion of inter-African solidarity, world peace, international co-operation and understanding

And to provide for a Constitution for the purpose of promoting the good government and welfare of all persons in our country, on the principles of freedom, equality and justice, and for the purpose of consolidating the unity of our people

Do hereby make, enact and give to ourselves the following Constitution:..”

The Late Chief FRA Williams SAN lucidly argued that on account of the excerpted provision, the Nigerian Constitution lied against itself because at no time did the people of Nigeria meet to enact the Constitution. The 1999 Constitution was forced on us by the military and by sheer conspiracy of the political elite, it has remained the supreme law of the land.

Having laid this necessary foundation, I turn to the assertion of the amiable Speaker of the House of Representatives, Hon. Aminu Tambuwal and the Senate Majority Leader, Senator Ndoma Egba SAN that the proposition of the Nigerian Bar Association that the 1999 Constitution, which is going through another round of amendment, be subjected to a referendum is unconstitutional.

According to Black’s Law Dictionary, 9th Edition, a referendum is the process of referring a state legislative act, constitutional amendment or an important public issue to the people for final approval by popular vote.

Sen. Ndoma Egba SAN particularly argued that the 1999 Constitution is very clear on the amendment process and makes no reference whatsoever to a referendum. The conceptual tone of this argument is the same as the one that has been mounted over the years in opposition to the clamour for the convocation of a sovereign national conference for the purpose of drafting a true “people’s constitution”. The “anti conference” argument is that there is already a representative government in accordance with the Constitution and there cannot be two sovereign bodies in place at the same time. Put simply, the argument of the National Assembly leans on the false assumption that as representatives of the people, they are sovereign in terms of making decisions on their behalf. They most certainly are not! Even the 1999 Constitution on which they rely says they are not. Section 14 (2) (a) of the 1999 Constitution clearly provides that sovereignty belongs to the people from whom the government through the Constitution derives its authority and power. The people have not surrendered their sovereignty – they gave their elected representatives power and authority, while retaining the authority to revoke the grant of such powers through the process of recall or periodic election. The elected representatives are not high and mighty honourables but servants and hold their terms office subject to the will of the people.

If we venture to take the view expressed by the Late Senior Advocate as wrong and the Constitution actually originated from the people, we will still come to the irresistible conclusion based on its provisions that the Constitution derives its supremacy from the will of the people and it is subject to their ultimate sovereignty. They can call for its amendment or replace it altogether. Even the military that handed us the Constitution had enough constitutional understanding to insert as its preamble “we the people …”

It does appear that the National Assembly is under the mistaken belief that the validity of provisions to be brought into the Constitution by reason of the proposed amendment lay squarely in the procedure stated in the Constitution for its amendment. That belief is itself a propagation of a long held assumption that the validity of the Constitution depends entirely on its provisions ignoring a more fundamental validation that should come from it being an expression of the will of the people. To proceed in this manner will be to continue to ignore our constitutional history, turning blind eyes to the very factor that has led to the structural imbalance that still plagues our democratic endeavor. By now, we ought to have realized that the procedure through which a constitution emerges is as important as its provisions.

Assuming without conceding that the National Assembly is right in its argument on the illegality of referendum premised on its isolated reading of section 9 of the Constitution, will it also be unconstitutional to use referendum as a means of aggregating the views of Nigerians on each and every issue set for amendment? I do not think so. Why is the National Assembly more amenable to conducting public hearings across the six geo-political zones with a few memoranda rather than asking the people directly in a referendum? Your guess is as good as mine. Public hearing is an easy way out – it allows the National Assembly to amend the Constitution as it pleases while giving the impression that it is merely voting in accordance with the will of the people. If the purpose of the public hearings is to collate the views of Nigerians, then the objective is more efficiently accomplished through a referendum, the result of which will be known to all and binding on the National Assembly. Referendum is more inclusive, less vague and its result is easily verifiable. On the other hand, public hearing for the purpose of amending the Constitution is elitist and restrictive, only the views of a select few will be given expression at such a forum and more importantly the result of such a forum (which by experience is the exclusive preserve of whoever called for the hearing) is not binding on the National Assembly. There is absolutely nothing unconstitutional about using a referendum to aggregate the views of Nigerians in respect of the proposed amendments to the Constitution and being bound by such views whenever it chooses to vote in respect of those amendments. This is without prejudice to the competence of the people to change that Constitution altogether without subjecting it to the provisions of the very Constitution which did not emanate from them (by the way, the National Assembly is yet to point to us a single constitutional provision that requires them to embark on public hearings in order to amend the Constitution).

The first and most important obligation of members of the National Assembly is to represent the members of their various constituencies and senatorial districts. In more advanced democracies, legislatures hold public hearings, town hall meetings, caucus meetings and even referendum to aggregate the views of the members of their constituencies in respect of proposed legislations. Few weeks ago, Iceland created a web-based platform using crowdsourcing to aggregate the views of its populace on its proposed constitution. This is because they understand that democracy thrives on popular participation and they are willing to choose any platform which best serves that purpose.

I have observed as a student of comparative constitutional law that the difference between the American constitutional order and the Nigerian lies in the differing view of “the people”. American jurists have over the years interpreted the American Constitution liberally as an expression of the will of the people and as such subject to them, whereas we choose to interpret the Constitution as though it were an end in itself – the Constitution is only supreme because the people say it is and elected representatives must not attempt to fetter the capacity of the people to change it if they so desire.

Tolu is a graduate student of Columbia University Law School, New York

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Hon. Jibrin Suspended From House of Reps

Whistle-blower lawmaker, Hon. Abdulmumin Jibrin, has been suspended by the House of Representatives.   The lawmaker from Kano at the centre of the unfolding budget padding scandal was on Wednesday suspended fron the house for 180 legislative days.   The House seats three days in a week and this consequently means that Mr. Jibrin’s suspension would last more than a year.   In a motion recommended by House Ethics Committee chairman, Nicholas Ossai, and adopted by the whole House, Jibrin will also not be...

Nigeria electricity challenge man-made – Fashola

Former governor of Lagos State and Minister of Power, Works and Housing, Babatunde Raji Fashola, said, yesterday, that Nigeria’s electricity problem is man-made. Fashola, who spoke at the maiden edition of Made in Nigeria Festival taking place at Eko Atlantic, Lagos, said his blueprint for the power sector is in three phases: power-generation, steady supply of power and uninterrupted power supply. He has also pledged to ensure the power sector works to the point where Nigeria has uninterrupted power supply. Speaking on...

Aero Airline Staffs Protest at MMIA, Lagos

This is according to an eye witness account. Aero staffs were seen protesting over non payment of salaries for over 6 months and also they were been suspended by the company. The workers storm their premises and stopped any plane from taking off. See more pictures below..        

Waziri Adio: Recession as Opportunity for Reversing Resource Curse

And, sadly, it came to pass. It is well predicted that most countries blessed with natural resources, even in the best of times, perform worse economically than countries not so endowed; and that, when times are tough, countries that are dependent on natural resources come to an assured grief. There is a popular name for this strange but common condition: resource curse. It sounds metaphysical, it seems counter-intuitive even, but it is a position supported by enough...

Kwara State suspends plan to raise N20 billion for infrastructure

Following the launching of the Kwara State Infrastructure Development Fund IFK, the state government says it has suspended plans to raise a N20b bond from the capital market for infrastructure development. Governor Abdulfatah Ahmed disclosed this in a statement through his Senior Special Assistant, Media and Communications, Dr. Muyideen Akorede on Wednesday. The Governor noted that with the launch of the IF-K, which pools resources for funding infrastructure, the N20b naira bond has become unnecessary as all ongoing and new projects...

Kaduna Pursues Affordable Healthcare Through Contributory Scheme

A scheme to guarantee universal access to basic healthcare is to be introduced in Kaduna State. The state government is already providing free health services for pregnant women, children under five years and the elderly. The proposed scheme is designed to widen the net of coverage, and ensure that all residents of the state, including the poor and vulnerable, have access to healthcare without incurring out-of-pocket expenditure. The Kaduna State Executive Council on Monday, 26th September...

Video: Olamide – Owo Blow

Multi-talented artiste Olamide, whom become well known for his hit back to back since 2009 till date, Baddosneh turns up for all the dancers out there with the brand new compelling music video for his August-released single “Owo Blow. Olamide says “My music is different and it’s real. I don’t try to copy anyone, and I’m only going to spread a positive message while having fun doing it”. Check out the hitmaker’s new video below, Clarence Peters Shot It!” AUDIO DOWNLOAD Watch...

I did not ‘bomb’ Buhari – Tinubu

A National Leader of the All Progressives Congress, Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu, has denied a media report that he “bombed” President Muhammadu Buhari. Some posts had on between Monday and Tuesday quoted Tinubu as having taken on Buhari following his face-off with the National Chairman of the APC, Chief John Odigie-Oyegun. He was quoted to have made snide remarks about the President, including the fact that Buhari begged him to emerge president. But in a statement by the Tinubu Media Office, the...

Jose Mourinho reveals why he may be forced to drop Wayne Rooney again

Rooney could be left out of Manchester United’s Europa League starting lineup after Jose Mourinho claimed he needs to “protect” the striker. Rooney was dropped for last Saturday’s rout of Leicester and has not trained fully this week due to a back injury. The England captain returned to training today at Carrington and United manager Mourinho will discuss whether he should start against Ukraine side Zorya Luhansk or be on the substitutes’ bench. But Mourinho is mindful that the endless debate over...

Rivers rerun: Police must be apolitical – Wike tells AIG

Rivers State Governor, Nyesom Wike has advised the Police High Command to take urgent steps to weed out bad eggs from the force. Governor Wike made the call at the Government House in Port Harcourt during a courtesy call on him by the AIG, Abubakar Marafa of Zone Six. Governor Wike observed that the bad eggs in the police structure negatively affected the implementation of security measures. He assured the Zone 6 Police Command of the continued support of the Rivers State...

Education Reforms: How a Nigerian State is Blazing the Trail

Kaduna State is reputed as having the third oldest University in Nigeria and the only Aviation Technology Institute in West Africa. This is in addition to the fact that the state is home to at least 2 other Universities, 2 Polytechnics, 6 Colleges of Education and 4 Research Institutes that focus on diverse fields from water to leather and agriculture to health. The presence of these institutions has helped the State build a reputation as being...

Stop addressing Ize-Iyamu as Pastor, he’s a pathological liar – Oshiomole

The Governor of Edo State, Adams Oshiomhole, has berated the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP candidate in the ongoing governorship election in the state, Osagie Ize-Iyamu, for claiming to be a pastor. Addressing reporters, the Governor described Ize-Iyamu, who is his former campaign director, as a “pathological liar”, who “lies effortlessly”. Oshiomhole stressed that the PDP flag bearer is not worthy of being addressed as a pastor for alleging that some All Progressives Congress, APC, governors, including Akinwunmi Ambode of Lagos and...

Edo election: Female police officer arrested for collecting bribe from PDP chieftain

A female police officer who was caught by an agent of the APC while collecting money from a chieftain of the PDP at unit 28, ward 7 in Ikpoba Okhai LGA was arrested by APC supporters who handed her over to the police.   The female police officer was locked up at Ugbekun police station after her action caused a little tension in the polling booth.

Army denies Boko Haram hoisted flags near Chibok

The Nigerian Army has refuted the report that Boko Haram insurgents have hoisted flags in some communities near Chibok, Borno State. A statement by the army spokesman, Col. Sani Usman, said the troops of the Operations Lafiya Dole are maintaining a high level of vigilance in and around the area to forestall infiltration by the terrorists. The British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) had yesterday reported that the insurgents hoisted their flags in three villages in northern Borno, after over-running the area. The report...

Inconclusive elections: Senate to probe INEC’s performance

The Senate has resolved to investigate the performance of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) in the last one year, while calling on President Muhammadu Buhari to immediately nominate suitably qualified persons to fill vacant positions in the commission. The decision followed the adoption of a motion on the matter co-sponsored by the Deputy President of the Senate, Senator Ike Ekweremadu and the Senate majority leader, Senator Mohammed Ali Ndume, against the backdrop of the spate of inconclusive elections conducted...

FG needs to spend less, earn more, borrow way out of recession – Obasanjo

Former President Olusegun Obasanjo on Tuesday made a number of recommendations to the federal government as the surest way of getting out of the current economic downturn, saying that the government needs to spend less, earn more, and borrow its way out of the recession. Obasanjo spoke in Abeokuta, the Ogun State capital, yesterday at the National Council on Finance and Economic Development (NACOFED) conference with the theme: “Enhancing Revenue Generation and Obtaining Best Value for Money in Expenditure”. The former...

Jibrin explains why he shunned Ethics Committee hearing

The former Chairman of the House of Representatives Committee on Appropriation, Abdulmumin Jibrin has given reason for his absence at a hearing on his alleged breach of House Rules by the Committee on Ethics and Privileges. Jibrin told newsmen on Tuesday that he shunned the panel because the Chairman, Nicholas Ossai had demonstrated bias in words and action. His words: “Ahead of the resumption of the House I wrote a 17-page letter to all members and one of the issues I...

Buhari, Tambuwal, APC Governors Move To Quell Tinubu, Oyegun’s Rift

President Muhammadu Buhari has endorsed a move by Governor Aminu Tambuwal and two other governors to settle the dispute between All Progressives Congress, APC national leader, Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu and national chairman, Chief John Odigie-Oygeun. A meeting between the peace envoys and the two men will, however, not hold until weekend at the earliest, sources in the party told Vanguard. The delay it was learnt was to enable the party give full attention to the Edo State governorship election...

APC Crisis: Atiku backs Tinubu

A former Vice President and chieftain of All Progressives Congress, Atiku Abubakar, has charged the party to promote the rule of law and due process in the conduct of its affairs, noting that they were germane to its unity and stability.He gave the charge in a statement on Wednesday against the background of the festering crisis trailing the conduct of the APC gubernatorial primary in Ondo State.   A former governor of Lagos State and national leader of the APC, Bola...

Sad! DJ Midas is Dead

Popular Disc jockeys in Ebute Metta, Ibadan Street, Lagos DJ Midas is dead! Sources said DJ Midas, whose real name is Michael Adedoyin, died after a brief illness yesterday Tuesday September 27th. Shortly before his death, DJ Midas worked with Silverbird’s Rhythm FM. He joined the radio station in 1998 as a pioneer and regular DJ host. He was 45. Siverbird Rhythm has confirmed the death, with a statement released on their official...

Mary J. Blige Asks Judge’ To Rule Prenup With Ex Husband As Valid’

Singer Mary J. Blige is determined to make her estranged husband abide by a prenuptial agreement she insists is solid. The 45-year-old filed for divorce from Martin 'Kendu' Isaacs in July citing irreconcilable differences after 12 years of marriage. Now, according to TMZ, she's asking a judge to rule that the prenup that sets out what each takes away from the marriage is valid. The gossip website reports that Blige is...