CONSTITUTION AMENDMENT: IS A REFERENDUM REALLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL? BY TOLU OBAMUROH

Published:7 Dec, 2012

The Nigerian democracy is founded on the supremacy of the Constitution. The supremacy of the Constitution in turn rests on the understanding that it emanated from the collective will of the people. The preamble to the 1999 Constitution (as amended) says as much –

“We the people of the Federal Republic of Nigeria
Having firmly and solemnly resolved, to live in unity and harmony as one indivisible and indissoluble sovereign nation under God, dedicated to the promotion of inter-African solidarity, world peace, international co-operation and understanding

And to provide for a Constitution for the purpose of promoting the good government and welfare of all persons in our country, on the principles of freedom, equality and justice, and for the purpose of consolidating the unity of our people

Do hereby make, enact and give to ourselves the following Constitution:..”

The Late Chief FRA Williams SAN lucidly argued that on account of the excerpted provision, the Nigerian Constitution lied against itself because at no time did the people of Nigeria meet to enact the Constitution. The 1999 Constitution was forced on us by the military and by sheer conspiracy of the political elite, it has remained the supreme law of the land.

Having laid this necessary foundation, I turn to the assertion of the amiable Speaker of the House of Representatives, Hon. Aminu Tambuwal and the Senate Majority Leader, Senator Ndoma Egba SAN that the proposition of the Nigerian Bar Association that the 1999 Constitution, which is going through another round of amendment, be subjected to a referendum is unconstitutional.

According to Black’s Law Dictionary, 9th Edition, a referendum is the process of referring a state legislative act, constitutional amendment or an important public issue to the people for final approval by popular vote.

Sen. Ndoma Egba SAN particularly argued that the 1999 Constitution is very clear on the amendment process and makes no reference whatsoever to a referendum. The conceptual tone of this argument is the same as the one that has been mounted over the years in opposition to the clamour for the convocation of a sovereign national conference for the purpose of drafting a true “people’s constitution”. The “anti conference” argument is that there is already a representative government in accordance with the Constitution and there cannot be two sovereign bodies in place at the same time. Put simply, the argument of the National Assembly leans on the false assumption that as representatives of the people, they are sovereign in terms of making decisions on their behalf. They most certainly are not! Even the 1999 Constitution on which they rely says they are not. Section 14 (2) (a) of the 1999 Constitution clearly provides that sovereignty belongs to the people from whom the government through the Constitution derives its authority and power. The people have not surrendered their sovereignty – they gave their elected representatives power and authority, while retaining the authority to revoke the grant of such powers through the process of recall or periodic election. The elected representatives are not high and mighty honourables but servants and hold their terms office subject to the will of the people.

If we venture to take the view expressed by the Late Senior Advocate as wrong and the Constitution actually originated from the people, we will still come to the irresistible conclusion based on its provisions that the Constitution derives its supremacy from the will of the people and it is subject to their ultimate sovereignty. They can call for its amendment or replace it altogether. Even the military that handed us the Constitution had enough constitutional understanding to insert as its preamble “we the people …”

It does appear that the National Assembly is under the mistaken belief that the validity of provisions to be brought into the Constitution by reason of the proposed amendment lay squarely in the procedure stated in the Constitution for its amendment. That belief is itself a propagation of a long held assumption that the validity of the Constitution depends entirely on its provisions ignoring a more fundamental validation that should come from it being an expression of the will of the people. To proceed in this manner will be to continue to ignore our constitutional history, turning blind eyes to the very factor that has led to the structural imbalance that still plagues our democratic endeavor. By now, we ought to have realized that the procedure through which a constitution emerges is as important as its provisions.

Assuming without conceding that the National Assembly is right in its argument on the illegality of referendum premised on its isolated reading of section 9 of the Constitution, will it also be unconstitutional to use referendum as a means of aggregating the views of Nigerians on each and every issue set for amendment? I do not think so. Why is the National Assembly more amenable to conducting public hearings across the six geo-political zones with a few memoranda rather than asking the people directly in a referendum? Your guess is as good as mine. Public hearing is an easy way out – it allows the National Assembly to amend the Constitution as it pleases while giving the impression that it is merely voting in accordance with the will of the people. If the purpose of the public hearings is to collate the views of Nigerians, then the objective is more efficiently accomplished through a referendum, the result of which will be known to all and binding on the National Assembly. Referendum is more inclusive, less vague and its result is easily verifiable. On the other hand, public hearing for the purpose of amending the Constitution is elitist and restrictive, only the views of a select few will be given expression at such a forum and more importantly the result of such a forum (which by experience is the exclusive preserve of whoever called for the hearing) is not binding on the National Assembly. There is absolutely nothing unconstitutional about using a referendum to aggregate the views of Nigerians in respect of the proposed amendments to the Constitution and being bound by such views whenever it chooses to vote in respect of those amendments. This is without prejudice to the competence of the people to change that Constitution altogether without subjecting it to the provisions of the very Constitution which did not emanate from them (by the way, the National Assembly is yet to point to us a single constitutional provision that requires them to embark on public hearings in order to amend the Constitution).

The first and most important obligation of members of the National Assembly is to represent the members of their various constituencies and senatorial districts. In more advanced democracies, legislatures hold public hearings, town hall meetings, caucus meetings and even referendum to aggregate the views of the members of their constituencies in respect of proposed legislations. Few weeks ago, Iceland created a web-based platform using crowdsourcing to aggregate the views of its populace on its proposed constitution. This is because they understand that democracy thrives on popular participation and they are willing to choose any platform which best serves that purpose.

I have observed as a student of comparative constitutional law that the difference between the American constitutional order and the Nigerian lies in the differing view of “the people”. American jurists have over the years interpreted the American Constitution liberally as an expression of the will of the people and as such subject to them, whereas we choose to interpret the Constitution as though it were an end in itself – the Constitution is only supreme because the people say it is and elected representatives must not attempt to fetter the capacity of the people to change it if they so desire.

Tolu is a graduate student of Columbia University Law School, New York

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Praiz, 9ice, Pasuma And Others Set For Battle At The Celebrity Fans Challenge Tomorrow !

The biggest and most exciting celebrity football party is back  !Kiibati Bankole presents another exciting edition of her novel celebrity football contest- Celebrity Fans Challenge; and this time around, it is bigger than ever, as some of Nigeria's biggest names in entertainment go head to head for bragging rights and the title of Nigeria's biggest celebrity SUPERFAN!The celebrities include 9ice, fuji ace- Pasuma, Reminisce, Praiz, Gbenga Adeyinka(GCON), Illbliss, Nollywood stars Segun Arinze and Fred Amata; and representing the ladies- Simi (Jamb...

Troops Kill Boko Haram Members Dressed In Nigerian Military Uniform

Boko Haram members dressed in Nigerian military uniform were killed during a raid of the sect members camp in the North East. See the photos after the cut...be warned it's graphic!

#Pausibility: Gehazi, Vuvuzela-General And The Lesson For The New Generation By Adebayo Coker.

The diverse reactions that were triggered by the recent appointments of the President are funnily incredulous. Very soon we will hear Dauralization or Patriarchization. We voted PMB to deliver to us chenji then we complain when he selected his team. PMB has chosen the people he wants to work with; I hope when playtime comes he will consider some of us. September is a month to look forward to. My...

Chad Sentences 10 Boko Haram Members To Death

Chad has sentenced 10 members of Nigeria-based Islamist militant group Boko Haram to death on terrorism charges, judicial sources said on Friday. "They are all sentenced to death," said one of the sources. Chad's capital N'Djamena, less than 100 kilometres from the Nigerian border, was hit by a series of suicide bombings in June and July that killed more than 40 people. Source: Trust.org

Fayose Appoints 72-yr Old Carpenter As Council Boss

Governor Ayodele Fayose of Ekiti State Friday appointed a 72-year old Carpenter and illiterate, Mr Olatunde Afolayan as the caretaker chairman of Moba Local Government. Fayose, also sworn in members of the State Independent Electoral Commission, headed by a retired Chief Judge of the State, Justice Kayode Bamisile , to be able to conduct local government elections before the end of the year. After administering the oaths on the appointees, Fayose told President Muhammadu Buhari to remove Mrs Amina...

Van Gaal Targets Revenge Against Swansea

The Swans recorded a historic double over Manchester United last season, including victory in the manager's opening game, but the Dutchman says his squad is now more prepared Louis van Gaal is targeting revenge as he prepares his Manchester United squad to face Swansea City. Goals from Ki Sung-yueng and Gylfi Sigurdsson saw Van Gaal lose his first...

Nigeria-Bound Terror Chief Was Coming On Invitation – Report

According to a report by Daily Trust, wanted terrorist, Ahmed Al-Assir, who was arrested in Lebanon on his way to Nigeria, was coming on the invitation of a foreign company operating in the country.  Sources in Nigeria’s security circles, who spoke to Daily Trust on condition of anonymity, said the visa was issued by a Foreign Service official in Beirut based on that invitation. According to the sources, without a letter of invitation...

Photos From BBOG’s Rally In Abuja

The Catholic Archbishop of Abuja, Cardinal John Onaiyekan and Shiekh Nuru Imam joined members of the Bring Back Our Girls group in a peaceful rally to commemorate 500 days since the Chibok girls were abducted by Boko Haram members. The advocacy group also had a candle light session this evening. They tied red ribbons on some trees in Abuja to serve as a constant reminder that the girls are still not back. More photos below...

Boko haram Slaughters 28 In Fresh Attack In Borno

28 people were slaughtered after Boko Haram members attacked Mafurnudi in Damboa LGA of Borno State, on Tuesday. A resident of the state Abubakar Jojo, who confirmed the killings, said ''They attacked our people in Mafurnudi village on Tuesday but we learned about it today because there are no telecommunications in Damboa area. Twenty-four men and eight others suffered gun wounds. They carted away all their foodstuffs and set their homes ablaze,'' he told SaharaReporters

Nicki Minaj To Open The VMAs

?According to a press release from MTV, Nicki Minaj will open the 2015 Video Music Awards on Sunday. Minaj teased the announcement earlier on Instagram and Twitter, with a Moonman in a sonogram. Nicki later deleted the teaser and tweet but it's definitely happening, according to MTV.

What Do You Think About Miley Cyrus? Miley Gets Shocking Answers As She Goes Undercover

?During her Wednesday night appearance on ?Jimmy Kimmel Live?, Miley did many things — wore nipple pasties; talked about how her boobs make Paul McCartney uncomfortable — but most hilariously, she disguised herself as an Australian TV reporter named Janet and asked people on the streets of L.A. what they thought of her. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=juSrk9VUkUU Credit: Jimmy...

Tyga Flaunts Bank Withdrawal At Paparazzi

Tyga's bank account is still stacked and he wants everyone to know it. He walked out of a Calabasas bank Thursday afternoon with a wad of hundreds and he made sure to flash it for cameras. Doesn't look like the nearly $300k he spent on Kylie Jenner's Ferrari and the thousands in back rent he owes are slowing him down in the cash department ... he also sped off in a Bentley. Credit: 

Protest At Times Square As New York Authorities Move To Ban Posing Topless

?Posing topless in Times Square in New York City has been legal since 1992, and Mayor De Blasio and Governor Cuomo are currently trying to ban it. One of the topless women, Saira thinks the attempt to ban being topless is helping their cause. " made it actually better, and letting people pick a side. Are you on our side or are you on their side? And we have a lot more people on our side than I think...

Kim Kardashian To Cut Her Uterus After Baby No. 2?

Kim Kardashian's current pregnancy may be her last.

Woman Grows Gigantic Horn In The Middle Of Her Head

An elderly Chinese villager has been dubbed “the unicorn woman” due to an abnormal growth on her head that looks like a large horn, it’s reported. Liang Xiuzhen started growing something that resembled a “black mole” on her head around eight years ago, according to her son Wang Chaojun. The 87-year-old, from Guiyan village in Ziyang City, Sichuan Province, was left stunned when two years ago it gave way to a finger-sized horn-like mass.

Ugochukwu Favour-Mayor: Linda Ikeji Is Making Millionaires From Her Self-made

From the timeless word that says, “If you see a woman that has everything going for her, and you’re not ready to add value to her life, just admire her from afar. Please, don’t interrupt her greatness.” And extremely, it is difficult being a woman in a society like ours. Here, the women are facing the challenge of identity. And I think after our Queen,...

Kim Kardashian Allegedly Trying To Stop Amber Rose’s Reality TV Show

Kim Kardashian has reportedly ‘tried her hardest’ to prevent Amber Rose/Black Chyna's reality TV show from ever happening. And failing that, it’s believed that Kim will stop at nothing to make sure that no one watches their soon-to-be filmed MTV reality show. “This is the worst possible scenario for the Kardashians,” a source told RadarOnline.com, adding: “Giving these two more of a voice than they already have is going to be...

Bolt To Retire After 2016 Olympics?

Usain Bolt will decide after next year’s Rio Olympics whether to retire or continue until the London 2017 world championships. The Jamaican star Bolt told the BBC after in Thursday’s 10th career world title in Beijing, in the 200m, that he is `50-50’ on whether he will compete in London, where he won a second Olympic treble in 2012. “I really want to run at London but I think the sport is not as fun...

Kingsley Ohajunwa: Before We Get Distracted By The Corruption Fight

Corruption has been a clog in the wheel of progress in Nigeria; there are too many corrupt individuals in Nigeria; the level of corruption in the civil service is gargantuan and mind-blowing; political office holders embezzle funds meant for projects, effectuation of progammes and welfare of the people; Nigeria has continually been ranked as one of the most corrupt countries in the world; the level of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has continually dwindled as a result of...

Dangote Inaugurates $250 Million Plant In Cameroon

Dangote Cement Plc inaugurates a 250 million-dollar (N48.75 billion) cement grinding plant in Douala, Cameroon. Dangote Group also laid the foundation stone for a 200 metre jetty in Douala. Alhaji Aliko Dangote, President/ Chief Executive, Dangote Group, said at the ceremony, that the plant, with a capacity of 1.5 million metric tonnes per annum (mmtpa), was a great feat in the operations of the company. "The plant is our largest greenfield project in a neighbouring country...

Information Ministry Workers Protest Against Staff Negligence, Fund Misappropriation

Workers of the Ministry of Information have staged a protest against what they described as the ministry’s negligence of staff welfare and gross misappropriation of public funds. The protesters who gathered at the Radio House in Abuja, urged President Muhammadu Buhari to probe activities of the ministry’s Permanent Secretary, who they accused of mismanagement of the Subsidy Re-investment and Empowerment Programme (SURE-P) funds, non-payment of allowances, refusal to train staff, among others. Read More: