OPINION: The Manitoba imbroglio – Eze Onyekpere

Published:19 Nov, 2012

OPINION: The Manitoba imbroglio – Eze Onyekpere

Recent media reports that the Presidency has cancelled the contract for the management of the Transmission Company of Nigeria, a contract it entered with the Canadian firm, Manitoba Hydro International, reveals a major hiccup in the power sector reform programme. Presidential spokesman, Reuben Abati, stated that the cancellation of the contract signed in July 2012 was based on the lack of due process on the part of the Bureau of Public Enterprises. The government had earlier declared Manitoba as the preferred bidder.  The management contract worth $24m was geared to turn around the fortunes of the TCN while the Federal Government retained its ownership and funding. Manitoba was scheduled to take over TCN on September 1, 2012 but the take-over did not happen. However, a few days after the reported cancellation, the media further reported that the Presidency was merely considering the process that led to the management contract and that no decision had been taken.

First, it was the employees of the Power Holding Company of Nigeria who resisted the take-over by Manitoba in accordance with the terms of the contract. Manitoba’s tasks under the contract include, inter alia, the functions of a market operator, systems operator and transmission service provider.  It is a matter of public knowledge that entrenched interests in the system, especially the workers, have been resisting the power sector reforms, especially the privatisation and management contract processes.  Second, bureaucrats who have been feeding fat on the system have also been in opposition to the management contract. Don Priestman, the chief executive officer of Manitoba had recently disclosed to the media that two months into the commencement of the management contract, Manitoba had yet to receive the full authority to begin work at the company. Officials of the TCN and the Ministry of Power were busy singing a different tune as they could not justify the delay in handing over the management of the company to Manitoba. Indeed, the ministry wanted Manitoba to focus on the technical aspects of the job, leaving revenue issues and personnel to them. This would have meant the continuation of business as usual. Apparently, the exit of the reform-minded Bath Nnaji as Minister of Power had allowed the retrogressive bureaucrats and workers to regain momentum and mainstream their opposition to the contract. The delay in handing over the TCN to Manitoba by the Ministry of Power since September had now been shown to be a ploy to buy time to plan for the repudiation of the contract.

Further, the Bureau of Public Procurement had charged the BPE with mis-procuring the Manitoba contract. Section 55 of the Public Procurement Act of 2007, dealing with disposal of public properties, makes it clear that the Section shall apply subject to the provisions of the Public Enterprises (Privatisation and Commercialisation) Act of 1998. Upon all known canons of legal construction, the task of finding a management contractor for the TCN lies squarely with the BPE. So, where is the due process failure? If there is any failure, the facts have not been laid bare to the public. It appears that there is a turf war between the Federal Government agencies and this protection of turf cannot be in the public interest.  This raises the poser: What exactly informed the purported cancellation of the management contract?

Further, it is a matter of fact that the Electric Power Sector Reform Act of 2005 makes it clear that private sector efficiencies must be introduced into virtually all the segments of the power sector. This has been reinforced by the Power Sector Roadmap of the Goodluck Jonathan administration. The Roadmap sought to set timelines and deepen the provisions of the Act by providing a clear and structured approach to resolving the challenges besetting the power sector. Virtually all the timelines for the achievement of key targets have been missed. Earlier, the National Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy of the President Olusegun Obasanjo administration had set milestones and timelines for the improvement of electricity services. Also, all the timelines and milestones were missed after several billions of dollars had been spent. It is on record that it took Nigeria about five years to conclude the process of choosing a management contractor for the TCN.

There are a number of implications if this cancellation holds. The first is that it will be a big setback for the electricity reform process. It will be illogical to have privatised generating and distribution systems while the TCN drags back the system with its inefficiencies and bottlenecks. A process that took five years to conclude will definitely not produce a new management contractor in six months. The second issue is that Nigeria will definitely be made to pay some compensation to Manitoba which can effectively claim to have suffered loss. And the compensation will be made from the public purse. The third issue is that it will affect the readiness and willingness of investors to start and continue investments in the emergent private sector entities. The cancellation is a bad precedent and as such investors who do not pull out of the reform process will require double assurance to ensure that their contracts will not be repudiated after incurring heavy costs. The fourth is that the government is portraying itself as irresponsible. For a contract concluded and signed-off between the Bureau of Public Enterprises and the National Council on Privatisation to be seen to have serious pitfalls and lacking in due process is a big dent on the image of the administration. It is imperative to recall that the Vice-President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria presides over the National Council on Privatisation!

For President Goodluck Jonathan, it is important that he is made to know that one of the cardinal parametres that will be used to determine the success or failure of his administration is the power sector reforms. It is therefore not in his interest to continue to allow unnecessary policy reversals. The public officers advising in favour of this cancellation would not necessarily be blamed when the reforms fail but it is the President who will definitely take the blame because the buck stops at his desk.  There is little or no time left and Nigerians cannot continue to be guinea pigs of an endless experiment and turf war by bureaucrats who have not considered the suffering of the masses.

Finally, the failure to find a suitable replacement for Nnaji some months after his resignation shows that the President’s acceptance of his resignation (or asking him to resign) was not well-thought out. Such highly skilled and knowledgeable men are in short supply in Nigeria and you cannot definitely find a replacement over the counter. Even the commitment and passion he brought to the electricity reforms table is no longer available to the nation. There was nothing stopping the President from asking Nnaji to stop any further participation in the privatisation process and disqualify companies that had any link with him while allowing him to continue serving the nation. If Nnaji had still been the Minister for Power, this unfortunate challenge leading to the cancellation of Manitoba’s contract would not have arisen. The President must act fast to stabilise the power sector reforms.


Eze Onyekpere (censoj@gmail.com: 08127235995)

  • http://Website NameAngai

    I assume this article was written before Abati and the President himself came out to clarify that the Manitoba contract has not been cancelled. Be that as it may, this Government has once again shown its double mindedness and instability as well as lack of will power to engender reform. Daily we receive earfulls of the transformation mantra but whenever it comes to action, the same people keel over!
    We are aware of the Indian interests in TCN and we also know that they can go to any lengths to have their way. The Exit of Prof. Nnnaji has no doubt set the Power sector reform back some distance and if nothing is done urgently to get it back on track, this Govenrmnent might just be writing its orbituary even before 2015!
    Brilliant write up!

Related Posts

Recent Posts

APC appoints el-Rufai as chairman of Kogi guber primaries panel

The All Progressives Congress (APC) has named Kaduna state governor, Mallam Nasir el-Rufai, as the chairman of a 7-man committee that will oversee the conduct of the primary election of the party slated for August 29 ahead of the forthcoming Kogi State governorship poll on November 21. The panel also has Senator Magnus Abbe as secretary, while Alhaji Ibrahim Sarki, Mrs. Omorge Osifor, ?Mr. Mohammad Wali, Mr. Lanre Asiwaju and Mr. Greg Egwu will serve as members. Inaugurating the committee yesterday...

38 Swazi virgins going for reed dance die in tragic crash

Not less than 38 girls and young women were killed in a crash on Friday while travelling to Swaziland's most famous traditional festival.   Trucks transporting scores of young women to the traditional Umhlanga Reed Dance collided on Friday near the town of Matsapha on Swaziland’s major highway, the Times of Swaziland reported.   The young women and girls were travelling on the back of an open truck, the rights group said.   “According to inside sources, a total of 38 young girls have been...

Appointments: Buhari, APC move to pacify S’East

There are indications that President Muhammadu Buhari and the All Progressives Congress have begun moves to compensate the South-East for not getting any appointments so far in the current administration. According to reports reliably gathered by Sunday Punch, some states in the South-East geopolitical zone might get more than one ministerial slot.

Japheth J, Omojuwa: Government Appointments and Cries of Marginalisation

This is one of the most lucrative periods of business for ethnic entrepreneurs; it is appointment season and trust them to whip up every sentiment under the tent of bigotry and hatred. Nigeria’s heterogeneous reality makes it impossible for any Nigerian president not to select his/her team from across the different geo-political zones that make up the country. President Buhari’s appointments so far haven’t quite reflected that, but if you note, these ethnic entrepreneurs started screaming ‘marginalization’...

Nigeria’s Paschal Dike Nominated for Junior Chamber International World President

Since JCI became an international organization in 1946, it has produced till date 70 World Presidents from about 36 countries. JCI started in Nigeria in 1957 making it a 58 year old organization in Nigeria. Unfortunately, no Nigerian has ever been elected as President of this International Organization for these numbers of years. A look at the JCI Website www.jci.cc indicates it is a truly international organization but with local and national impacts....

NNPC recommends sale of refineries, Buhari disagrees

The Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation has recommended the sale of the nation’s three refineries in Port Harcourt, Warri and Kaduna due to some challenges the agency described as critical elements, which may continually hinder their effective operation in the hands of the Federal Government. NNPC has equally finalised its position on the protracted pipeline...

Pastor Tunde Bakare gives out daughter’s hand in marriage (Photos)

General Overseer of the Latter Rain Assembly, Pastor Tunde Bakare yesterday gave out his first daughter Olubunmi in marriage in an exquisite and exclusive occasion. The first daughter of the former running mate of President Muhammadu Buhari in the 2011 presidential elections, Olubunmi’s wedding was met with pomp and pageantry.

Jonathan, Diezani, Obuah face probe over purchase of $6.9m campaign stages

The financial heist committed under former President Goodluck Jonathan's administration has come under probe by President Muhammadu Buhari as he beams his anti-corruption searchlight on the alleged purchase of three mobile stages, costing $6.9m, by former President Goodluck Jonathan and two of his officials, a Presidency source has said.  

Actress Mercy Johnson heavily pregnant with baby number 3 (photos)

Nollywood actress Mercy Johnson Okojie who recently turned a year older has shared photos from her birthday celebration on her Instagram page which revealed she's expecting baby number 3.   The beautiful mother of 2 who got married to her husband, Prince Okojie, in 2011 has since kept a low profile.   Below are photos from her birthday celebrated with her family...

Amaechi denies criticizing Buhari over appointments, arrives Port Harcourt

Former governor of Rivers state, Chibuike Amaechi has debunked rumours that he flew to London on Friday in anger because he was not offered an appointment in any key position recently announced by President Buhari.   The former Governor Amaechi who arrived Port Harcourt, Rivers state capital on Saturday to attend the opening of St. Vincent Due Paul Catholic Church, Elechi beach Port Harcourt, was received at the airport by Dakuku Peterside, the governorship candidate of All Progressives Congress (APC) and...

Ogunsanya Tosin: Welcome Into The Nigerian School Of Public Governance

A welcome speech by the institute head… Listen up everybody, we welcome you all to NSPG, a place where we transform individuals to leaders primarily in the public sector. You are left with only one option and that option is to learn. More specifically, NSPG covers all aspects of governance in domestic and global organizations, from risk assessment to policy analysis, disregarding societal status to whoever jettison the rule of law, design and evaluation.

#DeltaTribunal: Lack of Proper Certification of Election Results by INEC Threatens to Render Evidence Inadmissible

?The Delta State election tribunal proceeded with a hearing on Friday, 28th August. The counsel to the petitioner (Emerhor/APC), Chief Okpoko (SAN), drew the attention of the tribunal to the failure of INEC to properly certify results from polling units in 24 LGAs. He noted that certification is to be done by an authorized scripted signature rather than an unscripted signature, and further stated that INEC, being an electoral body, should be an unbiased umpire instead of...

Kylie Jenner Allegedly Paid Tyga’s Rent

Tyga made headlines last month when he allegedly had his girlfriend Kylie Jenner lend him cash and by cash we mean $50,000 to pay off rent on his Calabasas, Calif. mansion. The 25-year-old was pictured on Thursday leaving a bank, openly holding a stiff looking stack of dolla billz! We can clearly see a Ben Franklin at the top of the stack, an can only assume there is more where that came from! Read...

OPC Opens Up On Buhari’s Appointments

Reacting to Buhari's appointments on Thursday, founder, Oodua Peoples Congress,OPC, Dr Fredrick Fasehun has implored Ni­gerians not only to be vigilant but also get prepared for a long battle ahead. According to him, Buhari through the appointments has shown himself to be insensitive to the feelings of oth­er ethnic groups across the country. ‘’What Buhari has done is evil. Through his actions since his inau­guration, he has been pandering to­wards the interests of a particular...

Senate Begins Probe Of Power Sector

The stage appeared set for a comprehensive probe of the nation’s power sector as the Senate declared on Friday that officials of the Federal Ministry of Power, its departments and agencies and other key players within the sector would soon appear before it. The Chairman, Senate Ad-hoc Committee on Power, Senator Abubakar Kyari, stated this when the Senate President, Bukola Saraki, inaugurated the 14-member fact-finding panel at the National Assembly Complex. Kyari said stakeholders in...

Seven Die As Nigerian Air Force Aircraft Crashes

Seven people have been killed after an aircraft belonging to the Nigerian Air Force crashed at the old site of the Nigerian Defence Academy Kaduna , Northwest Nigeria. The casualties include all four crew members and three passengers. The victims were travelling from the Nigerian Air Force Base in Kaduna en route Abuja. Emergency officials say the helicopter crashed less than ten minutes after taking off. Read More: channelstv

Appointments Will Be Balanced By September, Buhari Defends Appointments

President Muhammadu Buhari yesterday defended the appointment of the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (SGF), Babachir David Lawal and five others. The Special Adviser to the President on Media and Publicity, Mr. Femi Adesina, yesterday assured Nigerians that President Muhammadu Buhari’s political appointments will balance out soon. Adesina spoke on a radio programme, Political Platform, on RayPower 100.5FM. Adesina said the President was aware of federal character and expressed the belief that...

BUSTED! Boko Haram Planned To Bomb Nnamdi Azikiwe Int’l Airport

A plot by Boko Haram terrorists to bomb the Nnamdi Azikiwe International Airport was uncovered last Monday by the Department of State Service, DSS. The DSS made this known on Saturday in a statement by an official, Tony Opuiyo in which he said a fourteen year old boy,  Sulaiymon Abdulraman (a.k.a Sunday AJAYI), of Kogi State was apprehended inside the airport. On interrogation, Abdulraman allegedly disclosed that he infiltrated the airport with the assistance of...

Buhari’s Appointments “Totally Unacceptable To Ndigbo”- Igbo Youths

The Ohaneze Youth Council (OYC), on Friday, condemned President Muhammadu Buhari’s latest appointment for the positions of the Secretary to the Government of the Federation, the Chief of Staff to the President and others. Okechukwu Isiguzoro, the president of the group, said in a statement he jointly signed with the OYC’s spokesperson, Obinna Adibe, said the appointments were “totally unacceptable to Ndigbo”, arguing that they violated the principle of federal character as enshrined in the Nigerian...

Jonathan’s Bodyguards Posted Out Of Villa

Department of State Services personnel who served as bodyguards to President Goodluck Jonathan have been posted out of the Villa to various state commands. Competent sources at the Presidential Villa said that the signal for the posting of the over 150 bodyguards who had remained redundant following the directive by the ADC to President Buhari that they should leave the presidential villa came yesterday. “Almost all of our personnel who were bodyguards in the villa...

Lagos-Based Journalist Arrested In Cameroon, Accused Of Spying For Boko Haram

A Lagos-based Cameroonian journalist, Simon Ateba, has been arrested by Cameroonian authorities as he investigated the conditions of Nigerian refugees camped in the country’s far north. The journalist, who managed to leave a messages on his Facebook page before he was locked up Friday, said he was arrested for venturing, without permission, into a refugee camp with 50,000 Nigerians. He later told a colleague that the authorities were threatening to charge him for espionage –...