OPINION: The Manitoba imbroglio – Eze Onyekpere

Published:19 Nov, 2012

OPINION: The Manitoba imbroglio – Eze Onyekpere

Recent media reports that the Presidency has cancelled the contract for the management of the Transmission Company of Nigeria, a contract it entered with the Canadian firm, Manitoba Hydro International, reveals a major hiccup in the power sector reform programme. Presidential spokesman, Reuben Abati, stated that the cancellation of the contract signed in July 2012 was based on the lack of due process on the part of the Bureau of Public Enterprises. The government had earlier declared Manitoba as the preferred bidder.  The management contract worth $24m was geared to turn around the fortunes of the TCN while the Federal Government retained its ownership and funding. Manitoba was scheduled to take over TCN on September 1, 2012 but the take-over did not happen. However, a few days after the reported cancellation, the media further reported that the Presidency was merely considering the process that led to the management contract and that no decision had been taken.

First, it was the employees of the Power Holding Company of Nigeria who resisted the take-over by Manitoba in accordance with the terms of the contract. Manitoba’s tasks under the contract include, inter alia, the functions of a market operator, systems operator and transmission service provider.  It is a matter of public knowledge that entrenched interests in the system, especially the workers, have been resisting the power sector reforms, especially the privatisation and management contract processes.  Second, bureaucrats who have been feeding fat on the system have also been in opposition to the management contract. Don Priestman, the chief executive officer of Manitoba had recently disclosed to the media that two months into the commencement of the management contract, Manitoba had yet to receive the full authority to begin work at the company. Officials of the TCN and the Ministry of Power were busy singing a different tune as they could not justify the delay in handing over the management of the company to Manitoba. Indeed, the ministry wanted Manitoba to focus on the technical aspects of the job, leaving revenue issues and personnel to them. This would have meant the continuation of business as usual. Apparently, the exit of the reform-minded Bath Nnaji as Minister of Power had allowed the retrogressive bureaucrats and workers to regain momentum and mainstream their opposition to the contract. The delay in handing over the TCN to Manitoba by the Ministry of Power since September had now been shown to be a ploy to buy time to plan for the repudiation of the contract.

Further, the Bureau of Public Procurement had charged the BPE with mis-procuring the Manitoba contract. Section 55 of the Public Procurement Act of 2007, dealing with disposal of public properties, makes it clear that the Section shall apply subject to the provisions of the Public Enterprises (Privatisation and Commercialisation) Act of 1998. Upon all known canons of legal construction, the task of finding a management contractor for the TCN lies squarely with the BPE. So, where is the due process failure? If there is any failure, the facts have not been laid bare to the public. It appears that there is a turf war between the Federal Government agencies and this protection of turf cannot be in the public interest.  This raises the poser: What exactly informed the purported cancellation of the management contract?

Further, it is a matter of fact that the Electric Power Sector Reform Act of 2005 makes it clear that private sector efficiencies must be introduced into virtually all the segments of the power sector. This has been reinforced by the Power Sector Roadmap of the Goodluck Jonathan administration. The Roadmap sought to set timelines and deepen the provisions of the Act by providing a clear and structured approach to resolving the challenges besetting the power sector. Virtually all the timelines for the achievement of key targets have been missed. Earlier, the National Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy of the President Olusegun Obasanjo administration had set milestones and timelines for the improvement of electricity services. Also, all the timelines and milestones were missed after several billions of dollars had been spent. It is on record that it took Nigeria about five years to conclude the process of choosing a management contractor for the TCN.

There are a number of implications if this cancellation holds. The first is that it will be a big setback for the electricity reform process. It will be illogical to have privatised generating and distribution systems while the TCN drags back the system with its inefficiencies and bottlenecks. A process that took five years to conclude will definitely not produce a new management contractor in six months. The second issue is that Nigeria will definitely be made to pay some compensation to Manitoba which can effectively claim to have suffered loss. And the compensation will be made from the public purse. The third issue is that it will affect the readiness and willingness of investors to start and continue investments in the emergent private sector entities. The cancellation is a bad precedent and as such investors who do not pull out of the reform process will require double assurance to ensure that their contracts will not be repudiated after incurring heavy costs. The fourth is that the government is portraying itself as irresponsible. For a contract concluded and signed-off between the Bureau of Public Enterprises and the National Council on Privatisation to be seen to have serious pitfalls and lacking in due process is a big dent on the image of the administration. It is imperative to recall that the Vice-President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria presides over the National Council on Privatisation!

For President Goodluck Jonathan, it is important that he is made to know that one of the cardinal parametres that will be used to determine the success or failure of his administration is the power sector reforms. It is therefore not in his interest to continue to allow unnecessary policy reversals. The public officers advising in favour of this cancellation would not necessarily be blamed when the reforms fail but it is the President who will definitely take the blame because the buck stops at his desk.  There is little or no time left and Nigerians cannot continue to be guinea pigs of an endless experiment and turf war by bureaucrats who have not considered the suffering of the masses.

Finally, the failure to find a suitable replacement for Nnaji some months after his resignation shows that the President’s acceptance of his resignation (or asking him to resign) was not well-thought out. Such highly skilled and knowledgeable men are in short supply in Nigeria and you cannot definitely find a replacement over the counter. Even the commitment and passion he brought to the electricity reforms table is no longer available to the nation. There was nothing stopping the President from asking Nnaji to stop any further participation in the privatisation process and disqualify companies that had any link with him while allowing him to continue serving the nation. If Nnaji had still been the Minister for Power, this unfortunate challenge leading to the cancellation of Manitoba’s contract would not have arisen. The President must act fast to stabilise the power sector reforms.

 

Eze Onyekpere (censoj@gmail.com: 08127235995)

  • http://Website NameAngai

    I assume this article was written before Abati and the President himself came out to clarify that the Manitoba contract has not been cancelled. Be that as it may, this Government has once again shown its double mindedness and instability as well as lack of will power to engender reform. Daily we receive earfulls of the transformation mantra but whenever it comes to action, the same people keel over!
    We are aware of the Indian interests in TCN and we also know that they can go to any lengths to have their way. The Exit of Prof. Nnnaji has no doubt set the Power sector reform back some distance and if nothing is done urgently to get it back on track, this Govenrmnent might just be writing its orbituary even before 2015!
    Brilliant write up!

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Senate May Revoke Lands Allocated To Jonathan, Others

The Senate Committee on Federal Capital Territory, on Friday, threatened to order the immediate revocation of plots of land allocated to former President Goodluck Jonathan and 29 others in the Maitama district of Abuja.     The Chairman, Senator Dino Melaye, who stated this during a budget defence by the FCT ministry led by its Minister, Muhammed Bello, said the affected plots of land were in a reserved area.     Melaye said the plots of land allocated to Jonathan and others in the Maitama...

SSANU Suspends Strike

The Senior Staff Association of Nigerian Universities (SSANU) has suspended its one month old industrial action and directed its members to return to work on Monday.     The National President of the association, Mr Samson Ugwoke, told the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Lagos of the developments on telephone on Friday.     Ugwoke told NAN that the resolution to suspend the strike was taken after the association met with officials of the Ministry of Labour and other concerned stakeholders on Feb. 2.   "We...

FG Plans Nationwide Campaign For Made-in-Nigeria Products

The Minister of State for Industry, Trade and Investment, Hajia Aisha Abubakar, on Friday in Abuja said that the ministry would soon launch a nationwide to encourage Nigerians to patronise made-in Nigieria products.     Abubakar stated this at the signing of a footwear production agreement between Global Smartfit Nigeria Ltd and Labora Shoes Ltd of South Africa in her office.     The campaign is tagged, '' Patronise Naija Products’’.     Represented by the Permanent Secretary in the ministry, Mr Aminu Bisala, the minister lauded the...

50,000 Farmers In Zamfara To Benefit From CBN Agric Loan – Commissioner

Over 50,000 farmers in Zamfara state are expected to benefit from the Anchor Borrower’s loan programme introduced by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN).     Hajiya Fatima Shinkafi, the Commissioner of Commerce and Industry, made the disclosure on Friday in Gusau in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN).     She said that the Anchor borrower’s programme was introduced by the federal government through the CBN in collaboration with state governments to assist Nigerians farmers boost food production.     "The programme was launched...

NNPC To Establish 800 Retail Outlets

The Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) is set to establish 800 additional retail outlets across the country, Dr Babatunde Adeniran, the Group Executive Director has said.     He spoke on Friday in Ilorin, when he led the NNPC team on a courtesy visit to Gov. Abdulfatah Ahmed of Kwara at the Governor's Lodge.     He said that out of the 800 stations, three retail outlets would be established across the senatorial districts of Kwara.     Adeniran said already 503 retail stations had been established across...

Nigeria-China Trade Volume Exceeded $13bn In 2015 – Envoy

China has said that its trade volume with Nigeria exceeded $13 billion in 2015.   The Chinese Ambassador to Nigeria, Mr Gu Xiaojie, said this at a reception to mark 45 years of diplomatic relations between both countries in Abuja on Thursday night.   Xiaojie explained that both countries had strengthened bilateral relations since 1971.   "China and Nigeria have enjoyed longstanding friendly exchanges 45 years ago on February 10, 1971 since the two countries established diplomatic relations. In 1971, the bilateral trade volume was only...

Nigeria’s 2015 GDP, Lowest In 15 Years – Adeosun

The Minister of Finance, Mrs Kemi Adeosun on Friday said the growth recorded by the country in the 2015 fiscal period was the lowest in the last 15 years.     Nigeria’s Gross Domestic Product grew by 2.84 per cent year on year in real terms in the third quarter of last year.     The growth of 2.84 per cent represents an increase of 0.49 percentage points when compared to the 2.35 per cent recorded in the second quarter of 2015.     Adeosun said in a...

World Condom Day: Foundation To Distribute 500,000 Condoms In FCT

The AIDS Health Care Foundation (AHF), an NGO, says it will distribute 500,000 condoms in the FCT as part of activities to commemorate the 2016 World Condom Day.     The Site Coordinator of AHF Clinic, Dr Kena Onu, made this known in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Abuja on Friday.     He said that the distribution of the condoms, with other activities lined up for this year’s occasion, would help increase awareness on the use of condom and...

Kogi Govt., NLC In Fresh Row Over Salary Arrears

The Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) Kogi chapter, has said that the state workforce would not participate in the fresh screening as ordered by the government.     The state chairman of NLC, Mr Onuh Edoka, made the statement on Thursday in Lokoja while addressing a press conference.   He gave the government up till Feb. 10 to pay the Sept. 2015 salaries of workers or face industrial action.     Edoka accused the government of insincerity in its dealing with workers.     He said that the issue of fresh...

Rihanna To Perform At The Grammys

Ok it's official, Bad Girl Riri is going to lit the upcoming 58th Grammys Award. The diva shared the news on her Instagram page. The 58th Grammys Award will be held on the 15th of February. See her post below:

Tinubu Withdraws Suit Against AIT After Apology For Embarrassing Documentary

The African Independent Television has apologized to Bola Tinubu, a national leader of the ruling All Progressives Congress, for a documentary it aired before last year’s general election. In a letter of apology tendered before a Lagos High Court on Friday, Daar Communications, the owners of the TV station, said they hold Mr. Tinubu in high esteem. “Daar Communications Plc acknowledges that Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu is an outstanding political leader of unblemished character and...

Muslim Teen Defies Tradition To Become First Hijab-Wearing Ballerina

With a dream of becoming the first hijab-wearing Muslim ballerina, 14-year-old Stephanie Kurlow recently launched a fundraising page in the hopes of pulling together more than $7,000 so she can get her certification to open a performing arts program in her native Sydney because, she has said, “I don’t want certain people who are discriminatory to hold anyone back from achieving their dreams and being unique.”

Harvard Psychologist Says This Surprising Trait Can Make You More Successful

While researching her new book, "Presence," Harvard Business School professor Amy Cuddy interviewed a number of venture capitalists about what personal qualities successful entrepreneurs demonstrate. Perhaps the most striking observation she collected was this: "I don't mind if they're a little bit nervous; they're doing something big, something that matters to them, so it makes sense they'd be a little bit nervous." In the book, Cuddy outlines two key reasons why...

Earth, Wind & Fire Founder, Maurice White, Dies At 74

 Earth, Wind & Fire founder Maurice White, whose horn-driven band sold more than 90 million albums and made hits like “September,” “Shining Star” and “Boogie Wonderland,” died Wednesday at his home in Los Angeles, his brother Verdine said. White, who was 74, suffered from Parkinson’s Disease and had retreated from the...

See This Puzzle That Children Solve Instantly But Adults Find It Hard

A simple logic puzzle can bamboozle a lot of adults - but 80% of children can solve it near-instantly, National Geographic has said. The puzzle is this - which way is the bus going? The identical windows at each end of the bus seem to offer no clue as to...

Nicki Minaj Teases Miley Cyrus & Kylie Jenner In Her New Remix

It's been more than five months since the VMAs and Nicki Minaj's now-iconic "Miley what's good," but the incident is still fresh enough in her mind to make it into a new remix of Yo Gotti's "Down in the DM." In her verse, she mentions Miley, Kylie Jenner, and Bill O'Reilly all in the span of three lines, because that's how a master works. First, Kylie, in a line that compares her famous lips to Nicki's,...

See What This VAGINAL WEIGHT LIFTER Does To Prove That Vaginas Are Strong, Claims It Enhances Multiple Orgasms

Kim Anami is a 44-year-old intimacy coach and vaginal weight lifter who claims she can lift up to 10 pounds with nothing but her genital muscles and can have up to 20 orgasms in a row. She just ties a thin piece of string to a jade egg (which in Chinese medicine is thought to have healing reproductive properties), inserts the egg into her vagina, and then she's got an extra set of ... something that can carry anything from...

Osinbajo Takes Over As Acting President As Buhari Begins Short Vacation

President Mohammadu Buhari has begun a short vacation today. A statement by Special Adviser to Buhari on Media and Publicity, Femi Adesina, says that while Buhari is away, the Vice President, Prof. Yemi Osinbajo will perform the functions of the President. The statement added that in compliance with Section 145 (1) of the Nigerian Constitution, President Buhari has dispatched a formal notice of his vacation to the Senate President and the Speaker of the House of Representatives.

See How Much Buhari Saved Using TSA

President Buhari says he has so far saved 2.2 trillion Naira using the Treasury Single Account (TSA). The President gave the revelation while interacting with a cross section of the Nigerian community in the United Kingdom on the side-line of the Supporting Syria Conference in London. He berated the past administration for operating several accounts with which they siphoned money belonging to Nigerians vowing not to relent in the fight against corruption. President Buhari...

Nigeria-China Trade Volume Exceeds $13 Billion In 2015- Envoy

The Chinese Ambassador to Nigeria, Gu Xiaojie, said this at a reception to mark 45 years of diplomatic relations between both countries in Abuja on Thursday night. Mr. Xiaojie explained that both countries had strengthened bilateral relations since 1971. “China and Nigeria have enjoyed longstanding friendly exchanges 45 years ago on February 10, 1971 since the two countries established diplomatic relations. “In 1971, the bilateral trade volume was only $10 million, nowadays the bilateral...

CBN Extends BVN Registration For Nigerians In Diaspora To June 30

Four days after the deadline for Nigerian bank customers abroad to enroll for the Bank Verification Number, BVN, lapsed, the Central Bank of Nigeria, CBN, yesterday gave another respite to Nigerians in Diaspora by extending till June 30, the timeline for their compliance with the guideline. A Notice to the effect sourced by our correspondent from the apex bank’s website signed by the Director of Banking Supervision, Mr. ‘Dipo Fatokun, indicated that the deadline...