OPINION: Of Debt and Nigeria’s Infrastructural Development – Professor Sheriffdeen Tella

Published:26 Nov, 2012

OPINION: Of Debt and Nigeria’s Infrastructural Development – Professor Sheriffdeen Tella

Borrowing has become fashionable in Nigeria for states to test their viability by going to the capital market to borrow money, even for consumption purpose or just to satisfy kleptocratic urge. The Federal Government serves as the route and the surety for such loans. As of September 30, 2012, the nation’s external debt stood at $6.2bn and the government is proposing a total of $9.3bn external loan between now and 2014 to develop infrastructure. The way the government is pursuing requests and approval of loans from the National Assembly seems to indicate that the country is broke. But recent statistics from government sources do not support such situation.

There have been improvements in the external reserves and even in the excess crude oil account. The creation of the Sovereign Wealth Fund is indicative of a healthy economy such that new ratings from S&P and other international financial rating agencies have shown improvement. Although such ratings give some leverage or support to countries intending to borrow in international financial markets, it does not mean you have to borrow. The positive rating might even be the source of optimism that made the government to raise its initial request for loan from $7.9bn to $9.3bn.

If you have ever lived in Europe or United States, you would understand the banking mentality. Once the banks know you have a source of income, they pursue you with credit cards and letters that you could borrow at will and at low interest rates. Almost everyone in such economy lives on credit and gets tied to the banks and other financial agencies. It is that same way that international financial institutions lure countries to obtain credits until they get discredited. There is this high debt-GDP ratio that makes countries feel they have under-borrowed and have opportunities to borrow almost indefinitely. If a government wants to deceive its citizen in order to borrow from the markets, it will just increase the GDP and make the ratio quite small. This could also be possible in the case of Nigeria where the increasing oil output and high price give the country impressive GDP value.

There is a Yoruba proverb which says, literarily, that someone who has N200 at home and goes out to borrow N200 is merely spending the money at home. That is on the understanding that there is no interest on the borrowed money, which is not so in borrowing from commercial institutions where, no matter how low the interest charges, something has to be paid for parting with the fund. In the last 10 years, we have been doing well in terms of revenues coming in from oil as the price remained very close to $90 per barrel on the average, which is over $15 per barrel above the budgeted amount and, in the last four years the output or quantity produced per day for the same period has improved from less than 1.8 million barrels per day to average of 2.4 million barrels per day. With these figures, it is easy to calculate how many days oil sales will make up for the loans we are running after. The reports on the economy from the Central Bank of Nigeria also indicate that revenues from non-oil sources are also growing.So what is the problem?

In 2006, we exited from the claws of the international financial creditors after hard negotiation and parting away with billions of dollars that could have been used for the country’s development. Now we are going back to the same credit market, even when there is no need for it. The Co-ordinating Minister for the Economy and Finance Minister, Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, has been showing great concern about the huge domestic debt, which the country’s managers should turn attention. But the same Minister who was involved in paying the unsubstantiated external debt in her first tenure is now championing a return to the debt trap!

In negotiating the debt relief in 2005-2006, the creditors agreed with the federal government to invest the relief proportion of the debt in areas that would make the government achieve the MDGs but today, many of the beneficiary state governments could not account for the funds allocated to them.Hence, the present precarious situation with respect to meeting the MDGs in 2015.

The focus now should be on reducing drastically, the domestic debt. When domestic creditors, who are mainly private sector business enterprises, are paid the various sums owed them, there will be injection of money in circulation with multiplier effects on productive sectors of the economy. The current borrowing from financial institutions by federal, States and local governments to meet recurrent expenditures do crowd out the private sector from getting funds to run their businesses. This, coupled with unpaid funds for services by the different levels of government, are responsible for the inability of the leading sectors of the economy,like agriculture and industry, to grow or engineer growth in other sectors.

It was one of Nigeria’s great economists, Professor OjetunjiAboyade of blessed memory, who said that that by the time a man borrows money from his spouse, it would become clear that he is actually broke. This is because men are so egoistic that borrowing from one’s wife is seen an abomination whereas it is the best way to let your wife know that you are broke. Women have this feeling that the man is always having some reserve somewhere and until that reserve is finished, spending must continue.So if you borrow money from friends to keep the home going, then she believes you are still spending part of your reserve. Our desperation to forcing the National Assembly to approve borrowing could be taken asindicative of the fact that published rosy figures from the Central Bank and Federal Bureau of Statistics are not genuine. Is the country truly broke?

One may not bother when a country is borrowing, even when there is some surplus or healthy foreign reserveand the government’s judgement for judicious use of the loan is not in doubt. In the case of Nigeria, it is not advisable to fold arms and watch the country plunge headlong into debt. One needs to ask what the over $30 billion that the country owed before was expended upon. What were the projects and what were the benefits?Were those funds not purportedly spent on infrastructure like power and roads? Also, what have been the positive outcomes of the huge oil windfall in the last ten years?

The President of the International Monetary Fund, Christine Lagade, advised that “countries that are commodity exporters have in recent years benefitted from higher prices. For them, the challenge is to use the gains from higher prices wisely – to preserve macroeconomic stability, but also to share the natural resource wealth fairly across society, and across generations.” Nigeria is one of the beneficiaries of higher prices and higher revenues but it is also one of the few naturally-endowed countries that are far from meeting the Millennium Development Goals, most of which fall due in 2015. What this implies is that the government has not been able to “share the natural resources fairly across the society”. Can we trust this government with borrowed fund?

Presently, the country has enough money from exports to invest in four major areas without putting moratorium of external reserves. These are education, power, health and transport infrastructure, which are the same sectors the government wants to borrow money to develop. About $600m of the loan is reportedly meant for providing water for one of the states. One is aware that sometime in the past, Ogun Sstate was reported to have benefitted from loan or grant from the World Bank for the same purpose, yet public water supply remains inadequate when it functions while private boreholes have become a more reliable source of water for the citizens. Instead of the periodic loose sharing of excess crude oil funds among levels of government, the money can be invested in these areas that will improve citizens welfare and equally have spill over benefits on national development.

There is hardly a day without the news of fraud in one government agency or another but hardly also do you find anybody found guilty and jailed. There has been more noise about increase in power output or repair of major highways in the country than actions. The present political circumstance or environment does not augur well for borrowing for development. The level of corruption is alarming and the fear of the loans disappearing into private pockets is real. Can the National Assembly save the future generations of agony of paying debts for which they derived no benefits?

– Sheriffdeen Tella is a Professor of Economics, Department of Economics, Olabisi Onabanjo University, Ago-Iwoye, satellang@yahoo.com

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Presidency Has Clear Direction On Food Production – Osinbajo

Vice President Yemi Osinbajo said on Wednesday in Abuja that the Buhari presidency had a clear idea on how to execute its agricultural policy to achieve self-sufficiency in food production. Osinbajo spoke at a meeting with a delegation of the Rice Farmers Association of Nigeria, and the Wheat Farmers Association of Nigeria, alongside Kebbi Gov. Atiku Bagudu. The vice president praised rice and wheat farmers, saying “farmers are among the most important people in Nigeria today.” Osinbajo said by launching the CBN...

Mimiko Urges South West PDP Leaders To Embrace Peace

Gov. Olusegun Mimiko of Ondo State has appealed to leaders of the People Democratic Party (PDP) in South West to embrace peace to enable the party move forward. The governor who spoke on Wednesday in Akure at a meeting of PDP leaders in the South West, stressed the need for all party members to come together as one big family. ``Our mission is to get our acts together and recreate the nature of politics in the South West. ``There is no alternative...

Nigeria Will Comply With ICJ Judgement On Bakassi – Buhari

President Muhammadu Buhari on Wednesday assured that Nigeria would abide by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) judgment on Bakassi Peninsula. Buhari spoke at a joint interactive he held with President Paul Biya of Cameroon and the media in Abuja. He said there was no cause for alarm, but added that the Federal Government would react to the maritime issue after a joint committee of Nigeria and Cameroon experts submits its report. ``On this issue, I want to tell the people of...

Gov. Ahmed Calls For National Summit On Education

Gov. Abdulfatah Ahmed of Kwara has called for a national summit on how to reform education at the primary, secondary and tertiary levels. The governor made the call when he received the Executive Secretary of the Universal Basic Education Commission (UBEC), Alhaji Dikko Sulyman in Ilorin on Wednesday. ``It is important that a strong summit is held to improve the availability of school infrastructure; accessibility and the quality of teachers”, he said. According to the governor, the summit has to be taken...

Electoral Act Amendment Bill Passes Second Reading

The Bill to amend the Electoral Act to cover the lacuna associated with death of a candidate in an election before the conclusion of polling passed second reading in the House of Representatives on Wednesday. Also passed second reading is a Bill for amendment of Electoral Act 2010 to empower election tribunals and courts to declare candidates who scored second highest votes as winners of elections if the real winner is unqualified. The bill provides that for the second highest votes...

European Commission Proposes Granting Kosovo Visa-free Access To EU Countries

European Union Home Affairs Commissioner, Dimitris Avramopoulos said on Wednesday that the European Commission has proposed to grant citizens of Kosovo visa-free access to EU countries. He said that five of the bloc's member states are yet to recognise the independence of the former Serbian breakaway province. The explained that the EU should nevertheless be able to lift visa requirements for Kosovo nationals within two or two-and-a-half months. He said that Kosovo authorities had achieved far-reaching and difficult reforms,’’Avramopoulos said. According to him,...

Farmers, Herdsmen Clashes: Northern Senators Warn Against Inciting Comments

Northern Senators Forum in the 8th National Assembly on Wednesday, urged community leaders to eschew inflammatory comments over herdsmen and farmers clashes, saying such could heat up the polity. Briefing newsmen in Abuja, Leader of the group, Sen. Abdullahi Adamu (APC- Nasarawa West) advised state governors to also refrain inciting utterances, adding that the governors should also caution their people. Adamu said that the group would ensure that existing laws were amended and new ones enacted ``to promote the interest of...

I Have No Grudge Against Mimiko, George – Fayose

The Ekiti State Governor, Mr. Ayodele Fayose has refuted the report that he and some leaders of the Peoples Democratic Party in the South-West are having issues over the forthcoming election of the  national chairmanship of the party. He said specifically that he had no score to settle with the Ondo State Governor, Dr. Olusegun Mimiko and the former Vice Chairman of the party in the South-West, Chief Bode George over leadership matters. Fayose stated this while speaking at a meeting...

CCB Confirms Complete Verification Of Buhari, Osinbajo, Saraki’s Assets

The Code of Conduct Bureau said on Wednesday that it had completed the verification of the assets declared to it by President Muhammadu Buhari, the Vice President, Yemi Osinbajo; the Senate President, Bukola Saraki, and other top government officials in the current dispensation. The Head, Press and Protocol Unit of the bureau, Mohammed Idris, said this in a statement debunking a newspaper publication in which it was claimed that the verification of the assets of President Buhari and other government...

Buhari Yet To Receive Corrected 2016 Budget -FG

The Minister of State for Budget and National Planning, Zainab Ahmed, on Wednesday said President Muhammadu Buhari was still expecting the corrected version of the 2016 Budget details from the National Assembly. She expressed the hope that the document would be transmitted to the President either later on Wednesday or on Thursday. Ahmed spoke while briefing State House correspondents at the end of a meeting of the Federal Executive Council presided over by Vice-President Yemi Osinbajo. She was joined at the briefing...

Explosion Rocks Onitsha Market, 12 People Injured

No fewer than 12 persons sustained various degrees of burns following an explosion which rocked a settlement known as Kara Market along Atani Road, Ogbaru near Onitsha in Anambra State. Confirming the incident, the Police Public Relations Officer (PPRO) in Anambra, DSP Ali Okechukwu, said on Wednesday in Ogbaru, that the explosion was caused by fuel stored in a jerrycan for future use. Not bomb as being speculated by people. A jerrycan of petrol that was brought to the settlement exploded...

Lagos State Government Signs Agreement For Establishment Of DNA Forensic Centre

On Tuesday, 3rd of May, 2016, the Lagos State Government signed an agreement for the establishment of a DNA Forensic Centre in the State. Speaking at the official signing of the agreement between the State Government and ITSI Bioscience LCC in Alausa, the State Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice, Mr. Adeniji Kazeem, said that the Lagos State DNA Forensics Centre (LSDFC) is a unique forensic technique that is now being used all over the world and it is aimed at...

Minimum Wage: States Should Decide Accordingly – Oyegun

National Chairman of All Progressives Congress (APC), Chief John Odigie-Oyegun says states should be allowed to fix their minimum wage according to their financial capabilities. Fielding questions from newsmen in Abuja on Tuesday, he said although it was a matter for the Executive arm, the executive at federal and state levels would have to consider the demand in line with their ability to pay. It would be recalled that the Nigeria Labour Congress recently proposed N56, 000 as minimum wage for...

Military To Reassess Performance Of Troops In North East – Buratai

The Chief of Army Staff, Lt-Gen. Tukur Buratai, says the military hierarchy will review the entire counter-insurgency operations in order to improve the performance of troops in the northeast. Buratai made the plan known while addressing troops at the Nigerian Army 7 Division Tactical Headquarters in Bama on Tuesday. Although Buratai assured the troops that the planned overhaul would address observable lapses in the operation. He expressed satisfaction with the performance of the troops involved in the special operation to finally rid...

‘Your Sufferings Will Soon Be Over’, UN Assures IDPs

The UN Resident Coordinator, Ms Fatma Samoura, has assured the Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) by the Boko Haram insurgency that their sufferings would soon become a thing of the past. Samoura told the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) on Tuesday in Abuja that the UN was doing everything possible to ensure that the IDPs resumed their normal lives. Samoura, who is also the UN Humanitarian Coordinator and Resident Representative of UN Development Programme, urged the Boko Haram insurgency victims not to...

Buhari Orders Security Agencies To Deal Decisively With Rampaging Herdsmen

President Muhammadu Buhari has restated his administration's resolve to deal decisively and expeditiously with reported cases of continued attacks on communities across the country by armed herdsmen. The president was speaking on Monday night at a meeting with members of the Catholic Bishops Conference of Nigeria (CBCN) held in the Presidential Villa, Abuja. A statement issued on Tuesday by the President’s Special Adviser on Media and Publicity, Mr Femi Adesina, said that President Buhari confirmed that heads of national security agencies...

Military To Wipe Out Boko Haram Remnants Soon – CDS

Gen. Abayomi Olonisakin, the Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) said on Monday that the military will wipe out the remnants of Boko Haram terrorists from Nigeria in a short while. Olonisakin stated this while speaking with newsmen during a visit to Maiduguri, Borno. Olonisakin said that his visit was aimed at getting first class information on the anti-terrorism war. ``I want Nigerians to know that we are determined to wipe out the terrorists from our land. ``And from the Sambisa axis, we are...

Kano APC Petitions INEC, Party Headquarters Over Cancellation Of Bye Election

The All Progressives Congress (APC) in Kano state has petitioned the National headquarters of the party and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) over the cancellation of the bye-election of Minjibir, State Assembly constituency on Saturday.   The state acting Chairman of the party, Alhaji Abdullahi Abbas disclosed this while speaking with newsmen in Kano on Monday. Abbas, who, described the action of INEC as unjust and complicit, said the reason given for cancelling the election was flimsy. "That is why we are...

Police Recruitment: 843,008 Applications Received

The Police Service Commission (PSC) said it received 843,008 applications as at 1.00p.m May 2 from applicants seeking enlistment into the Nigeria Police Force. This is contained in an update issued by Mr Ikechukwu Ani, Head, Press and Public Relations of the commission in Abuja on Monday. He said that 243,327 applications were received for Assistant Superintendent of Police (ASP) cadre. Ani added that 197,990 and 401,691 applicants applied for the Inspector and Police Constable (PC) cadres respectively. The commission recently said in...

El-Rufai Vows To Uncover District Head’s Killers

Gov. Nasir El-Rufai of Kaduna State on Monday vowed to ensure the arrest and prosecution of those behind the death of the District Head of Fadan Karshi, Mr Bala Madaki. The district head and his 18-year-old nephew, Emmanuel Tanko, were killed by unknown assailants at his residence in Fadan Karshi on Sunday night. El-Ruf'i in a statement by his media aide, Samuel Aruwan urged residents of Sanga Local Government to remain calm and cooperate with the security agents to arrest the...

Umahi Approves Promotion Of Retiring, Retired Civil Servants In Ebonyi

Gov. David Umahi of Ebonyi has approved the promotion of all retiring and some retired civil servants in the state. The State’s Head of Service, Dr Chamberlain Nwele, made this known at a joint news conference he addressed with members of the organised labour in Abakaliki on Monday. Nwele said the governor “graciously approved the promotion in the workers’ interest.” He said that by the decision, the government would commence processing of the entitlement of concerned workers’ retirement. “The governor has given a...