OPINION: Of Debt and Nigeria’s Infrastructural Development – Professor Sheriffdeen Tella

Published:26 Nov, 2012

OPINION: Of Debt and Nigeria’s Infrastructural Development – Professor Sheriffdeen Tella

Borrowing has become fashionable in Nigeria for states to test their viability by going to the capital market to borrow money, even for consumption purpose or just to satisfy kleptocratic urge. The Federal Government serves as the route and the surety for such loans. As of September 30, 2012, the nation’s external debt stood at $6.2bn and the government is proposing a total of $9.3bn external loan between now and 2014 to develop infrastructure. The way the government is pursuing requests and approval of loans from the National Assembly seems to indicate that the country is broke. But recent statistics from government sources do not support such situation.

There have been improvements in the external reserves and even in the excess crude oil account. The creation of the Sovereign Wealth Fund is indicative of a healthy economy such that new ratings from S&P and other international financial rating agencies have shown improvement. Although such ratings give some leverage or support to countries intending to borrow in international financial markets, it does not mean you have to borrow. The positive rating might even be the source of optimism that made the government to raise its initial request for loan from $7.9bn to $9.3bn.

If you have ever lived in Europe or United States, you would understand the banking mentality. Once the banks know you have a source of income, they pursue you with credit cards and letters that you could borrow at will and at low interest rates. Almost everyone in such economy lives on credit and gets tied to the banks and other financial agencies. It is that same way that international financial institutions lure countries to obtain credits until they get discredited. There is this high debt-GDP ratio that makes countries feel they have under-borrowed and have opportunities to borrow almost indefinitely. If a government wants to deceive its citizen in order to borrow from the markets, it will just increase the GDP and make the ratio quite small. This could also be possible in the case of Nigeria where the increasing oil output and high price give the country impressive GDP value.

There is a Yoruba proverb which says, literarily, that someone who has N200 at home and goes out to borrow N200 is merely spending the money at home. That is on the understanding that there is no interest on the borrowed money, which is not so in borrowing from commercial institutions where, no matter how low the interest charges, something has to be paid for parting with the fund. In the last 10 years, we have been doing well in terms of revenues coming in from oil as the price remained very close to $90 per barrel on the average, which is over $15 per barrel above the budgeted amount and, in the last four years the output or quantity produced per day for the same period has improved from less than 1.8 million barrels per day to average of 2.4 million barrels per day. With these figures, it is easy to calculate how many days oil sales will make up for the loans we are running after. The reports on the economy from the Central Bank of Nigeria also indicate that revenues from non-oil sources are also growing.So what is the problem?

In 2006, we exited from the claws of the international financial creditors after hard negotiation and parting away with billions of dollars that could have been used for the country’s development. Now we are going back to the same credit market, even when there is no need for it. The Co-ordinating Minister for the Economy and Finance Minister, Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, has been showing great concern about the huge domestic debt, which the country’s managers should turn attention. But the same Minister who was involved in paying the unsubstantiated external debt in her first tenure is now championing a return to the debt trap!

In negotiating the debt relief in 2005-2006, the creditors agreed with the federal government to invest the relief proportion of the debt in areas that would make the government achieve the MDGs but today, many of the beneficiary state governments could not account for the funds allocated to them.Hence, the present precarious situation with respect to meeting the MDGs in 2015.

The focus now should be on reducing drastically, the domestic debt. When domestic creditors, who are mainly private sector business enterprises, are paid the various sums owed them, there will be injection of money in circulation with multiplier effects on productive sectors of the economy. The current borrowing from financial institutions by federal, States and local governments to meet recurrent expenditures do crowd out the private sector from getting funds to run their businesses. This, coupled with unpaid funds for services by the different levels of government, are responsible for the inability of the leading sectors of the economy,like agriculture and industry, to grow or engineer growth in other sectors.

It was one of Nigeria’s great economists, Professor OjetunjiAboyade of blessed memory, who said that that by the time a man borrows money from his spouse, it would become clear that he is actually broke. This is because men are so egoistic that borrowing from one’s wife is seen an abomination whereas it is the best way to let your wife know that you are broke. Women have this feeling that the man is always having some reserve somewhere and until that reserve is finished, spending must continue.So if you borrow money from friends to keep the home going, then she believes you are still spending part of your reserve. Our desperation to forcing the National Assembly to approve borrowing could be taken asindicative of the fact that published rosy figures from the Central Bank and Federal Bureau of Statistics are not genuine. Is the country truly broke?

One may not bother when a country is borrowing, even when there is some surplus or healthy foreign reserveand the government’s judgement for judicious use of the loan is not in doubt. In the case of Nigeria, it is not advisable to fold arms and watch the country plunge headlong into debt. One needs to ask what the over $30 billion that the country owed before was expended upon. What were the projects and what were the benefits?Were those funds not purportedly spent on infrastructure like power and roads? Also, what have been the positive outcomes of the huge oil windfall in the last ten years?

The President of the International Monetary Fund, Christine Lagade, advised that “countries that are commodity exporters have in recent years benefitted from higher prices. For them, the challenge is to use the gains from higher prices wisely – to preserve macroeconomic stability, but also to share the natural resource wealth fairly across society, and across generations.” Nigeria is one of the beneficiaries of higher prices and higher revenues but it is also one of the few naturally-endowed countries that are far from meeting the Millennium Development Goals, most of which fall due in 2015. What this implies is that the government has not been able to “share the natural resources fairly across the society”. Can we trust this government with borrowed fund?

Presently, the country has enough money from exports to invest in four major areas without putting moratorium of external reserves. These are education, power, health and transport infrastructure, which are the same sectors the government wants to borrow money to develop. About $600m of the loan is reportedly meant for providing water for one of the states. One is aware that sometime in the past, Ogun Sstate was reported to have benefitted from loan or grant from the World Bank for the same purpose, yet public water supply remains inadequate when it functions while private boreholes have become a more reliable source of water for the citizens. Instead of the periodic loose sharing of excess crude oil funds among levels of government, the money can be invested in these areas that will improve citizens welfare and equally have spill over benefits on national development.

There is hardly a day without the news of fraud in one government agency or another but hardly also do you find anybody found guilty and jailed. There has been more noise about increase in power output or repair of major highways in the country than actions. The present political circumstance or environment does not augur well for borrowing for development. The level of corruption is alarming and the fear of the loans disappearing into private pockets is real. Can the National Assembly save the future generations of agony of paying debts for which they derived no benefits?

– Sheriffdeen Tella is a Professor of Economics, Department of Economics, Olabisi Onabanjo University, Ago-Iwoye, satellang@yahoo.com

Related Posts

Recent Posts

TSA enhancing autonomy, research, transparency in tertiary institutions – Emmanuel Agha

At no point in the history of contemporary Nigeria has government been able to fully account for all its funds, at once, from a single consolidated view, until now. Thanks to the Treasury Single Account, TSA, which makes this possible. The TSA initiative is not only to the advantage of the federal government and its agencies, but to the benefit of the entire Nigerian populace. This is why it often comes as a surprise when unnecessarily jabs...

Supreme Court Affirms Ishaku As Taraba Governor

The Supreme Court on Thursday affirmed that Mr Diarus Ishaku of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) as the winner of the April 11, 2015 governorship election in Taraba.   The Justice Bode-Rhodes Vivor-led six justices of the Supreme Court held that the appeal lacked merit.   "We have studied and reviewed the submissions of all the counsel to parties in this appeal and found that there is no merit in the appeal. The decision of the Court of Appeal on this matter is hereby...

Free Feeding: Kaduna Govt Sacks Headmaster, Suspends 2 Others For Diverting Pupils’ Biscuits, Oranges

The Kaduna State Government has sacked two senior education officials and suspended two others for diverting food meant for the feeding of primary school pupils. The Commissioner for Education, Science and Technology, Dr Shehu Adamu, said at a news briefing in Kaduna on Thursday, that the officials had circumvented laid down procedures of the government’s Schools Feeding Programme, which commenced in January. “A School Support Officer in Birnin Gwari Local Government Area (LGA), Ibrahim Abdullahi has been...

Consumer Protection Council Orders MTN To Pay 1.85m Naira To Promo Winner

CPC has directed MTN Communications Limited to pay 1.85 million Naira to one of the winners of its Ultimate Wonder Promo for lack of due diligence. The order of the Consumer Protection Council (CPC) came on the heels of a complaint brought by Mr Omeje Fidelis against the mobile telecommunications giant that he had been underpaid after he was declared winner of two million Naira in the said sales promotion held in 2012 According to Omeje, he participated in...

I Refused To Give Future My Number, Later He Became Famous – Victoria Kimani

In a interview with YFm's Dj Sabby, Kenyan born Chocolate City artiste, Victoria Kimani, revealed how future tried to holla but she blocked him. I never got his number, never really gave him a chance, to really holla at me. I felt really messed up about it later and like years later, he ended up being future.

President Buhari Receives German President In Abuja #Photos

President Buhari received the President of Germany, Joachim Gauck, at the state house, Abuja today Feb 11th. See more photos below...

Kendall Jenner Sues Skincare Company For $10m For Using Her Face Without Permission

The 20 year old model is suing a skincare company called Cutera for $10milion with claims that they used her face and name to advertise their Laser acne treatment taking without her permission. The advert in question features a photo of Kendall and claims their products and treatments improved her skin. The ad reads - "Acne "completely ruined" Kendall Jenner's self esteem" TMZ reports that the documents in the...

U.S Embassy Condemns Attack On IDP Camp Dikwa

The U.S. Embassy in Nigeria has condemned the suicide attack on the Internally Displaced Persons in Dikwa town, Borno state which has left over 51 persons dead and scores injured.   A statement from the Public Affairs section in the Information Office of the Embassy at the Federal Capital Territory says the United States remains committed to assisting the Internally Displaced Populations in the North-east through humanitarian relief...

FG Inaugurates $160m World Bank SME Fund

Minister of Trade, Industry and Investment, Dr. Okechukwu Enelamah on Tuesday unveiled a $160 million (about N49.2 million) World Bank powered scheme to improve access to finance to small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in order to boost employment in the country. Also launched, an online vehicle to properly execute the programme was the Business Innovation and Growth (BIG) platform. BIG is landmark initiative of the Federal Ministry of Trade, Industry and Investment, which is...

Germany Seeks Favourable Investment Environment In Nigeria

The visiting President of Federal Republic of Germany, Mr Joachim Gauck, has advised the Nigerian Government to create the right investment environment for more German businesses. Gauck made the call in Lagos at a reception held for him and members of delegation of German Parliament and German companies that visited Abuja and Lagos. The German President, who expressed satisfaction at the successes so far...

Fire Guts NPC Headquarters In Abuja

A mid-day fire outbreak, yesterday, gutted  the headquarters of the National Population Commission (NPC), in Abuja. The fire incident which was caused by a faulty air conditioner affected the training unit on the ground floor of the complex. In a statement signed by Mr Simon Otene, director, public affairs, NPC, at the time of the fire outbreak, technical staff of the commission were undergoing in-house capacity building training. He said some furniture items, office...

Mexican Crime Reporter’s Half-Naked, Bound Body Found By Side Of Road

Half-naked, bound and with a plastic bag over her head,was how they found the body of a Mexican crime reporter who was murdered after being abducted by 8 armed men wearing military uniforms. Mother-of-two, Anabel Flores Salazar, who was a journalist for the newspaper El Sol de Orizaba, was snatched from her home by men with guns claiming they had a warrant for her arrest.

EFCC Seizes N5bn Houses Of Ex-NAF Chief, Amosu, Others

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission has seized houses and other properties belonging to the immediate past Chief of Air Staff, Air Marshal Adesola Amosu (retd.), and other senior military officers worth N5bn.  senior EFCC official, who did not want his name in print, told our correspondent that the suspects and others were cooperating fully with the anti-graft agency. The source in Abuja, said, “We have sealed a block of 12 luxury flats, located on...

Colonel Adegbe, ADC To Ex-President Jonathan Arrested – Report

Nigerian authorities have arrested Colonel Ojogbane Adegbe, a former Aide-de-Camp (ADC) to former President Goodluck Jonathan over an issue we are yet to ascertain as at press time. Colonel Ojogbane Adegbe A usually credible source familiar with...

Naira Crashes Further, Now N318 To A Dollar

The naira on Wednesday continued its fall against the Dollar on the parallel market, closing at 318 against the United States dollar. It was the third time in three days the naira would experience a drop. The currency, which was traded at 310 for a dollar on Monday and 313 on Tuesday, crashed again on Wednesday against the dollar, amid dwindling liquidity and now sells for N318.

NBA Accuses Buhari Of Plot To Intimidate Judiciary

The Nigerian Bar Association has condemned in strong terms the recent criticism of the judiciary in the fight against corruption. Speaking at the valedictory session organised in honour of a retiring Justice of the Supreme Court, Justice Mohammed Muntaka-Coomassie, NBA President, Augustine Alegeh, said the recent attack directed at the judiciary over the ongoing anti-corruption war was unacceptable. “The NBA condemns in its entirety the generalisation and/or categorisation of the Judiciary as being corrupt and...

NLC Calls On Nasarawa Govt. To Implement Full Benefits

The Organised Labour are asking the Nasarawa State Government to pay civil servants full January salaries and to implement all promotions with benefits from two thousand and eleven to date among other demands. The ongoing strike is predicated on twenty one point demands which after five extensive meetings between the government and the Organised Labour has been trimmed to fourteen. Addressing journalists in Lafia, the State Head of Civil Service, Joseph Ancho says the government...

Lai Mohammed Disowns Ministry’s N398m Votes For Computers In Controversial 2016 Budget

Minister of Information and Culture, Lai Mohammed yesterday disowned the N398 million his ministry voted for the purchase of computers in their 2016 budget. During the defence of the ministry's 2016 budget before the Senate Committee on Information, Lai Mohammed said the N230 million and N168 million voted for the purchase of computers for the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) and the National Film and Video Censors Board was strange to him. “No, that is not possible. That was...

New Music: M.I Abaga – ‘Everything’

With the anticipated release of Mi’s Illegal Music 3 Mixtape, the rapper decided to appease his fans with the exclusive release of one track off the mixtape. The track is produced by G-Plus and MI himself. It’s a pretty deep and thought-provoking track that seems to address quite a few issues. He starts off, “I have seen the paper turn a man against his maker. Started making bread and now he don’t...

Anti-Beyoncé Protest To Happen Next Week In Response To Her Super Bowl Performance

Beyonce’s performance at the Superbowl went down a treat with fans and critics. The singer delivered a riveting performance of her new single ‘Formation’ backed by a sea of female dancers. Referencing the Black Lives Matter Movement, Malcolm X and the Black Panthers, it was also the most radical political statement from the star in her 20-year career. Watch clip of...

Church Members Arrested During Service For Noise Pollution

The police in Lagos have arrested six persons for allegedly disturbing the peace of residents of Olaomibiyi Street, Ogba, during a church service.     The members – Ngozichukwu Onyebuchi (44), Clement Eromosele (26), Chukwudi Akwegbu (26), Chibuzor Chukwu (18), Godspower Enudi (21) and Okorie Livonus (36) – were arraigned in a Lagos Magistrate’s Court sitting in Ogba.   They were accused of converting a residential apartment to a church.   It was learnt that the landlord and residents of the building where the defendants gathered...