OPINION: In sympathy with Ribadu – by Chido Onumah

Published:9 Nov, 2012

OPINION: In sympathy with Ribadu – by Chido Onumah

I sympathise with Mallam Nuhu Ribadu, ex-Chairman of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission and, more recently, Chairman of the Petroleum Revenue Special Task Force. It is often said that once bitten, twice shy. That best describes the situation Ribadu found himself a week ago during the submission of his committee’s report to the President.

Nine months ago when the public awoke to the surprise appointment of Ribadu to head the PRSTF, it set tongues wagging. Many Nigerians had questioned the wisdom in accepting the job. The objection ranged from the fact that the committee was set up by the Minister of Petroleum Resources (who is deeply enmeshed in the controversy that dogs the oil sector) and not the President, to the fact that for an administration with a predilection for committees, this may just be another committee. The cynics had argued that it was an attempt to shore up the government’s integrity deficit and boost its anti-corruption credentials.

I was one of those who had some reservations about Ribadu’s appointment, but  I did not make my feeling public. Even though I had worked with him closely at the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission and much later during his presidential campaign, I didn’t attempt to discuss his new job with him. I assumed that as a man of strong convictions, he had his reason for accepting the job.

I met Ribadu in late August. Prior to that meeting, we had not seen for eight months since the public presentation of my book, Time to Reclaim Nigeria, in Abuja, on December 15, 2011, which meant there was a lot of catching up to do. Part of our discussion centred on his committee’s work. He expressed his frustration and explained some of the problems his committee encountered. He hinted about the pecuniary influence from oil “stakeholders” and the possibility of divided allegiance of some members of the committee.

Listening to him, I got a feeling that his was a committee primed to fail. I saw a man tormented by betrayal, yet upbeat. What was of interest to him was what to do to curb the monumental fraud his committee had discovered in the oil industry. He sounded to me like someone who knew the inevitable outcome of the report, but wanted to give the administration the benefit of the doubt.

Looking back, I am not sure he knew or felt at the time of our meeting that the government was contemptuous enough to undermine the report of a committee it set up. I left him and looked forward to the submission of his committee’s report. The submission of the report turned into a fiasco, predictably so. So much has been written about the events surrounding the presentation of the PRSTF report to President Jonathan on November 2. What is missing in the narrative is the complicity of the Presidency, the Minister of Petroleum Resources, Mrs. Diezani Alison-Madueke, and major oil multi-nationals in the effort to scuttle the work of the PRSTF.

For a man who promised to do things differently, President Jonathan is awfully predictable. Last week, as the nation waited patiently for the submission of the PRSTF report, I had noted that we would be treated to the same rhetoric that has become the hallmark of the Jonathan administration. It was exactly what happened; except that this time, the President conspired to embarrass himself and the entire nation.

When Reuters first put the PRSTF report in the public domain a little over two weeks ago, the Presidency promised that there was no attempt to “cover up” the findings of the committee. The Minister of Petroleum Resources said a committee had been given 10 days to look at the report and make some “input”. The minister had received the report more than a month earlier, but decided to sit on it.

So, what happened? Here is my take: I think the government was caught in a bind, it panicked and the result was the embarrassing situation that played itself out on Friday, November 2. The Presidency, it seemed, had been wondering what to do with the PRSTF report since August when it was submitted to the Minister of Petroleum Resources. A minority report by members who weren’t “comfortable” with the main report may have been an option. But once the report became public, it changed everything. Enter Steve Orosanye and Bernard Otti.

It is instructive that the report the Minister of Petroleum Resources promised would be ready in 10 days was not presented to the President as expected. Instead, Orosanye and Otti made themselves available or were recruited to wreck the final report submitted to the President. Their only reason: “The process adopted by the committee in arriving at its report was flawed”.

Orosanye’s verbal diarrhoea at the submission of the PRSTF report could only have come from a man who had the backing of the Presidency. “What I am saying is that the President has said come and submit the report, so what, if we are not ready, we are not ready,” Orosanye asserted confidently and condescendingly. “When I say so what, the President has spoken, we should be man enough to tell the President that we are not ready. That is the reason why you are handing over a report that is not process-driven”.

Two things are at play here. One, only a man that is incredibly reckless would speak the way Orosanye spoke before the President. I don’t think Orosanye is a reckless man considering he is a career civil servant who rose to become the Head of the Civil Service of the Federation. The only other thing is that his comments were carefully scripted and contrived. This was evident when he offered the coup-de-grace in these words: “I don’t know what the report contains. Therefore, in my view, I do not think the report should be accepted at this time, I challenge any member of this committee to take me on”.

Expectedly, Ribadu, the committee chairman, took him on. As it turned out, Orosanye and Otti, barely participated in the committee’s work. According to Ribadu, “He (Oronsaye) was not at the inauguration and he never participated in the deliberations of the committee.  The only time he came was when we wanted to start deliberations on recovery and he came on behalf of one company which is owing $1.5bn. That was the only time he came. In fact, he scuttled the payment of the $1.5bn”.

Whether it was for financial gains or compensation for their appointments while serving as members of the PRSTF — Orosanye became a member of the board of the NNPC and Otti became a director in NNPC — both Orosanye and Otti have written their names in infamy. So long as their sense of propriety did not detect a conflict of interest and instruct resignation from the committee so long will they remain on the wrong side of history. They sold their conscience and mortgaged the future of their children for lucre.

President Jonathan, in his characteristic tepid response to official sleaze, “urged Nigerians not to be distracted by the small disagreement, but to focus on the subject matter of the committee which is the sanitisation of the petroleum sector for the benefit of Nigeria and Nigerians”. The President said he was “not surprised there are disagreements between the members of the committee on the Petroleum Revenue Task Force. It is about money. There are some lapses and probably not everyone agreed”. He advised any member of the PRSTF “who had a contrary opinion from those expressed in the report to submit his opinion to him through his chief of staff or the Minister of Petroleum Resources”.

Clearly, we have heard the last of the PRSTF report, going by the President’s dismissive response. Like Ribadu, I weep for Nigeria!


Chido Onumah (conumah@hotmail.com)

  • Lawal Sulaiman Kayode

    Same old mentality about our leaders. Who’ll dry away our suffering tears?

  • @khay9yne

    Like El-rufai said, the report was already dead-on-arrival, ”a graveyard of white papers”. This administratn doesn’t suprise me anymore.

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Ministerial list: Submission of petitions against nominees begins Tuesday

The Senate will start receiving petitions against President Muhammadu Buhari’s ministerial nominees on Tuesday. The Chairman, Senate Committee on Ethics and Public Petitions, Senator Samuel Anyanwu, told reporters on Friday in Abuja that the committee would give the petitions prompt attention once they were presented.

Tribunal: Police commissioner says Rivers guber election peaceful

Mr Akuki Keneth, the Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) assigned to monitor the April 11 governorship poll in Rivers said on Friday that the election in the state was peaceful. Keneth, who is also the area commander in nine local government councils of the state, testified before the Governorship Election Petitions Tribunal for Rivers sitting in Abuja.

Borno govt. to relocate IDPs back to their hometowns

The Borno State Emergency Management Agency (BOSEMA) said it had concluded arrangements with the National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA) to relocate some Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) from Maiduguri to their hometowns. The Chairman of BOSEMA, Alhaji Ahmed Satomi disclosed this on Friday when he visited Alhaji Mohammed Kanar, the Zonal Coordinator, NEMA, in Maiduguri.

News Alert:Twin Bomb Blast In Kuje Abuja

Breaking News!!! Kuje market under Boko harram attack right now! A bomb has just gone off at kUJE market, and another at the Kuje police station Number of casualty is still unknown Details Later

Diezani Walks Out Of Jail On Bail

Nigeria’s former petroleum minister, Diezani Alison-Madueke, who was arrested earlier today by the London metropolitan police, has been released on bail. She was picked up alongside four others. However, she has been asked to report at Charing Cross Police Station on Monday for further grilling and her passport has been seized. She’s answering for corruption and money laundering charges preferred against her. Her Abuja home was sealed by the EFCC on Friday as well.

EFCC Swarms Alison Deziani’s House in Abuja

Reports have it that operatives of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) have begun a massive search of the house of the former Minister of Petroleum, Alison Deziani. She was arrested in the UK earlier today. Details later.

Battle of the Bridge: Eva Carneiro Comes for Jose Mourinho and the FA

Former Chelsea doctor Eva Carniero released a statement today as she broke her silence after several weeks. Read the statement below. "I was surprised to learn that the FA was allegedly investigating the incident of 8th of August via the press. I was at no stage requested by the FA to make a statement. I wonder whether this might be the only formal investigation in this country where the evidence of the individuals involved in the...

Jigawa police commissioner, Usman Tilli, accused of pocketing allowances meant for fighting Boko Haram

Some police officers in Jigawa state have accused their commissioner, Usman Tilli, of pocketing the allowances of personnel posted to fight Boko Haram. The aggrieved officers, in several interviews with Premium Times, alleged that for pecuniary benefit, the police commissioner deliberately reduced the strength of the...

Ex-Petroleum minister, Diezani Alison-Madueke, arrested in London over corruption

Former Minister of Petroleum Resources, Diezani Alison-Madueke was on Friday arrested in London, PREMIUM TIMES reports. She was arrested Friday morning alongside four other unidentified people by the UK National Crime agency. Diezani, who was one of the most influential ministers under the administration of Goodluck Ebele Jonathan, was reportedly arrested for offences related to bribery and corruption being investigated by the UK National Crime Agency. Two top British officials in London have however confirmed the development to Premium Times newspaper. They requested...

FG Seals Up 160 Drug Shops For Dispensing Poisons

The Federal Government has closed down 160 drug shops in Akwa Ibom State for dispensing poisons and engaging in other unauthorized services to members of the public. The Deputy Director and Head of Enforcement, Pharmacists Council of Nigeria (PCN), Abuja, Stephen Esumobi announced this on Friday while briefing Journalists after a one week visit of the enforcement teams of the Council to the state. He said those whose shops have been closed down had earlier...

Fake Gynecologist In Court For Raping His Patient

A Kenyan man has been charged with 12 offences including rape, impersonating a gynecologist and operating a clinic without a license in Nairobi, BBC reports. The accused, Mugo wa Wairimu pleaded not guilty and has previously denied that he raped his patients. Kenya’s Medical Practitioners Board has denied Wairimu is a registered doctor after a Kenya TV report in a footage revealed  an unidentified man allegedly assaulting an unconscious woman on a clinic...

“May your medical bill be high” -Ali Baba to corrupt Nigerian leaders

Ace comedian Ali Baba, in an Independence Day message, stated that his wish for corrupt Nigerian leaders is that "their medical bills be higher than they stole" and for “peace to be far from them.” Making the statement via his Instagram account, the comedian wrote:“Happy 55th Independence to all Nigerians. Our country will be great again. We will become...

PDP, Sylva Trade Words Ahead Of Bayelsa Poll

Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Bayelsa State chapter, and the Campaign Organization of Timipre Sylva, on Friday attacked each other verbally over the candidacy of the All Progressive Congress (APC) flag bearer for the December 5 governorship election. Sylva, who emerged the APC candidate, will slug it out with the sole candidate of the PDP and incumbent state Governor, Seriake Dickson. But the PDP said Sylva is not electable. The state Secretary of PDP, Keku...

The One Nigerian University Ranked Among World’s Top 800 Universities

Only one Nigerian university is ranked among the top 800 universities in the world, according to Times Higher Education World University Rankings for 2015/2016 released this week. Analysis report shows that the University of Ibadan, Nigeria’s oldest university, is ranked 601st of the world’s top 800 universities featured in the survey, 200 steps lower than Makerere University, Uganda, which is ranked 401st. The ranking was released on Wednesday, September 30, 2015. Read...

#BelieveItOrNot Bosnian Team Sack Coach Via Facebook Post!

Vladica Petrovic logged on to his personal account to find out that he had lost his job, and subsequently posted a comment, which has received over 200 likes on the social network Most people check Facebook to see what their friends are up to, and whether they’ve missed their mum’s birthday. Drina Zvornik coach Vladica Petrovic, however, logged on to find out that he had been sacked! The club, bottom of the Bosnian Premier League with...

Passenger airplane missing in eastern Indonesia

A small passenger plane with 10 people aboard is missing on a domestic flight in eastern Indonesia, officials said on Friday. Indonesia Transportation Ministry spokesman Julius Barata said the DHC-6 Twin Otter plane lost contact at 0636 GMT; 11 minutes after taking off from Masamba in South Sulawesi province. No distress signal was received. The plane which was headed for Makassar, the provincial capital, was carrying three crew and seven passengers, including three children, Barata said. "The aircraft is operated by Aviastar...

Ini Edo Stuns In Lounge Opening With Killer Dress

When we think she is a stunner, she stuns even harder. Sexy nollywood star, Ini Edo, flatters this glittered dress at a lounge opening and also shared a selfie showing her flawless make up. Plus Ini Edo has four gorgeous selfie snap angles... can you beat that? See Instagram pics below:

Footballer jailed for one year for breaking opponent’s leg

Nathaniel Kerr, a footballer in Britain's Sunday League has been jailed for a year after he deliberately broke an opponent's leg on Friday. The court said that the 24-year-old AFC Gold Cup player, pleaded guilty at Manchester Crown Court to assault. Kerr jumped on...

Abiola Akintunde: Nigeria At 55; The Path Towards Development

   Fellow Nigerians, greetings to you on this day as we celebrated together Yesterday, the crown we achieved as a reward of the agitation and struggles of our heroes past towards a free society freed from dependence and servitude forcefully imposed on our people over a century ago. The conditions of today may be a stumbling block to the realisation that; this is a day we should and must celebrate. Since it is the attainment of independence...

Muslims to pray for Mecca stampede victims Oct 4

A Nigerian Muslim body, Ansar-Ud-Deen Society of Nigeria, has said it is calling for a nationwide prayer for all the victims of the fallen crane and the Mina stampede during this year holy pilgrimage to Saudi Arabia. The body, in a statement on Thursday by its National Publicity Secretary, Alhaji M.A. Adebanjo, said the...

Mina Stampede: Emir Sanusi meets with Saudi Authorities on transparent probe

The Emir of Kano, Alhaji Muhammad Sanusi II, on Friday said he held a meeting with Saudi Authorities on the ongoing investigation into the recent stampede in Mina, Mecca. More than 747 Muslims, including 64 Nigerians, lost their lives and 805 others injured at a stampede on the way to Jamarat complex (stone throwing site) on Sept.24.