OPINION: In sympathy with Ribadu – by Chido Onumah

Published:9 Nov, 2012

OPINION: In sympathy with Ribadu – by Chido Onumah

I sympathise with Mallam Nuhu Ribadu, ex-Chairman of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission and, more recently, Chairman of the Petroleum Revenue Special Task Force. It is often said that once bitten, twice shy. That best describes the situation Ribadu found himself a week ago during the submission of his committee’s report to the President.

Nine months ago when the public awoke to the surprise appointment of Ribadu to head the PRSTF, it set tongues wagging. Many Nigerians had questioned the wisdom in accepting the job. The objection ranged from the fact that the committee was set up by the Minister of Petroleum Resources (who is deeply enmeshed in the controversy that dogs the oil sector) and not the President, to the fact that for an administration with a predilection for committees, this may just be another committee. The cynics had argued that it was an attempt to shore up the government’s integrity deficit and boost its anti-corruption credentials.

I was one of those who had some reservations about Ribadu’s appointment, but  I did not make my feeling public. Even though I had worked with him closely at the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission and much later during his presidential campaign, I didn’t attempt to discuss his new job with him. I assumed that as a man of strong convictions, he had his reason for accepting the job.

I met Ribadu in late August. Prior to that meeting, we had not seen for eight months since the public presentation of my book, Time to Reclaim Nigeria, in Abuja, on December 15, 2011, which meant there was a lot of catching up to do. Part of our discussion centred on his committee’s work. He expressed his frustration and explained some of the problems his committee encountered. He hinted about the pecuniary influence from oil “stakeholders” and the possibility of divided allegiance of some members of the committee.

Listening to him, I got a feeling that his was a committee primed to fail. I saw a man tormented by betrayal, yet upbeat. What was of interest to him was what to do to curb the monumental fraud his committee had discovered in the oil industry. He sounded to me like someone who knew the inevitable outcome of the report, but wanted to give the administration the benefit of the doubt.

Looking back, I am not sure he knew or felt at the time of our meeting that the government was contemptuous enough to undermine the report of a committee it set up. I left him and looked forward to the submission of his committee’s report. The submission of the report turned into a fiasco, predictably so. So much has been written about the events surrounding the presentation of the PRSTF report to President Jonathan on November 2. What is missing in the narrative is the complicity of the Presidency, the Minister of Petroleum Resources, Mrs. Diezani Alison-Madueke, and major oil multi-nationals in the effort to scuttle the work of the PRSTF.

For a man who promised to do things differently, President Jonathan is awfully predictable. Last week, as the nation waited patiently for the submission of the PRSTF report, I had noted that we would be treated to the same rhetoric that has become the hallmark of the Jonathan administration. It was exactly what happened; except that this time, the President conspired to embarrass himself and the entire nation.

When Reuters first put the PRSTF report in the public domain a little over two weeks ago, the Presidency promised that there was no attempt to “cover up” the findings of the committee. The Minister of Petroleum Resources said a committee had been given 10 days to look at the report and make some “input”. The minister had received the report more than a month earlier, but decided to sit on it.

So, what happened? Here is my take: I think the government was caught in a bind, it panicked and the result was the embarrassing situation that played itself out on Friday, November 2. The Presidency, it seemed, had been wondering what to do with the PRSTF report since August when it was submitted to the Minister of Petroleum Resources. A minority report by members who weren’t “comfortable” with the main report may have been an option. But once the report became public, it changed everything. Enter Steve Orosanye and Bernard Otti.

It is instructive that the report the Minister of Petroleum Resources promised would be ready in 10 days was not presented to the President as expected. Instead, Orosanye and Otti made themselves available or were recruited to wreck the final report submitted to the President. Their only reason: “The process adopted by the committee in arriving at its report was flawed”.

Orosanye’s verbal diarrhoea at the submission of the PRSTF report could only have come from a man who had the backing of the Presidency. “What I am saying is that the President has said come and submit the report, so what, if we are not ready, we are not ready,” Orosanye asserted confidently and condescendingly. “When I say so what, the President has spoken, we should be man enough to tell the President that we are not ready. That is the reason why you are handing over a report that is not process-driven”.

Two things are at play here. One, only a man that is incredibly reckless would speak the way Orosanye spoke before the President. I don’t think Orosanye is a reckless man considering he is a career civil servant who rose to become the Head of the Civil Service of the Federation. The only other thing is that his comments were carefully scripted and contrived. This was evident when he offered the coup-de-grace in these words: “I don’t know what the report contains. Therefore, in my view, I do not think the report should be accepted at this time, I challenge any member of this committee to take me on”.

Expectedly, Ribadu, the committee chairman, took him on. As it turned out, Orosanye and Otti, barely participated in the committee’s work. According to Ribadu, “He (Oronsaye) was not at the inauguration and he never participated in the deliberations of the committee.  The only time he came was when we wanted to start deliberations on recovery and he came on behalf of one company which is owing $1.5bn. That was the only time he came. In fact, he scuttled the payment of the $1.5bn”.

Whether it was for financial gains or compensation for their appointments while serving as members of the PRSTF — Orosanye became a member of the board of the NNPC and Otti became a director in NNPC — both Orosanye and Otti have written their names in infamy. So long as their sense of propriety did not detect a conflict of interest and instruct resignation from the committee so long will they remain on the wrong side of history. They sold their conscience and mortgaged the future of their children for lucre.

President Jonathan, in his characteristic tepid response to official sleaze, “urged Nigerians not to be distracted by the small disagreement, but to focus on the subject matter of the committee which is the sanitisation of the petroleum sector for the benefit of Nigeria and Nigerians”. The President said he was “not surprised there are disagreements between the members of the committee on the Petroleum Revenue Task Force. It is about money. There are some lapses and probably not everyone agreed”. He advised any member of the PRSTF “who had a contrary opinion from those expressed in the report to submit his opinion to him through his chief of staff or the Minister of Petroleum Resources”.

Clearly, we have heard the last of the PRSTF report, going by the President’s dismissive response. Like Ribadu, I weep for Nigeria!

 

Chido Onumah (conumah@hotmail.com)

  • Lawal Sulaiman Kayode

    Same old mentality about our leaders. Who’ll dry away our suffering tears?

  • @khay9yne

    Like El-rufai said, the report was already dead-on-arrival, ”a graveyard of white papers”. This administratn doesn’t suprise me anymore.

Related Posts

Recent Posts

#EdoDecides: Contrary To Reports El-Rufai Did Not Visit Edo State Today – Aide

Malam Nasir El-Rufai did not visit Edo State today, Wednesday, 28 September 2016. Contrary to the fiction peddled by one of the candidates who made the accusation on live television. Edo State Governor Adams Oshiomhole has kindly rubbished the lie and made clear that Malam Nasir El-Rufai is nowhere near the state. This clarification is made only to affirm a material fact. But it is important to stress...

BlackBerry To Stop Production Of Phones

Canadian company shifts focus to software having struggled to compete as mobile users opt for touchscreens  

Angry Brother Allegedly Beheads Man who Raped his Sister …and Takes the Head To the Police Station!

According to the Thai online user who posted the photos on September 25th, a man allegedly killed and beheaded his sister's alleged rapist...and went to report himself at the police station, carrying the murder victim's head. See the graphic photos below... jpg" style="margin-left: 1em; margin-right: 1em;">

Governor El-Rufai wants cut in cost of governance

Kaduna State Governor Nasir El-Rufai has kicked against the call by the National Council of State (NEC) as well as some senior government officials, including Africa’s richest man, Alhaji Aliko Dangote, for the disposal of national assets. El-Rufai, one-time Director-General of Bureau of Public Enterprises (BPE), spoke at World Pension Summit ‘Africa Special’ co- hosted by The Netherland-based World Pension Summit Organisation and the National Pension Commission (PenCom) in Abuja. He rather called for solutions from experts, just as he argued...

Hon. Jibrin Suspended From House of Reps

Whistle-blower lawmaker, Hon. Abdulmumin Jibrin, has been suspended by the House of Representatives.   The lawmaker from Kano at the centre of the unfolding budget padding scandal was on Wednesday suspended fron the house for 180 legislative days.   The House seats three days in a week and this consequently means that Mr. Jibrin’s suspension would last more than a year.   In a motion recommended by House Ethics Committee chairman, Nicholas Ossai, and adopted by the whole House, Jibrin will also not be...

Nigeria electricity challenge man-made – Fashola

Former governor of Lagos State and Minister of Power, Works and Housing, Babatunde Raji Fashola, said, yesterday, that Nigeria’s electricity problem is man-made. Fashola, who spoke at the maiden edition of Made in Nigeria Festival taking place at Eko Atlantic, Lagos, said his blueprint for the power sector is in three phases: power-generation, steady supply of power and uninterrupted power supply. He has also pledged to ensure the power sector works to the point where Nigeria has uninterrupted power supply. Speaking on...

Aero Airline Staff Protest at MMIA, Lagos

This is according to an eye witness account. Aero staffs were seen protesting over non payment of salaries for over 6 months and also they were been suspended by the company. The workers storm their premises and stopped any plane from taking off. See more pictures below..        

Waziri Adio: Recession as Opportunity for Reversing Resource Curse

And, sadly, it came to pass. It is well predicted that most countries blessed with natural resources, even in the best of times, perform worse economically than countries not so endowed; and that, when times are tough, countries that are dependent on natural resources come to an assured grief. There is a popular name for this strange but common condition: resource curse. It sounds metaphysical, it seems counter-intuitive even, but it is a position supported by enough...

Kwara State suspends plan to raise N20 billion for infrastructure

Following the launching of the Kwara State Infrastructure Development Fund IFK, the state government says it has suspended plans to raise a N20b bond from the capital market for infrastructure development. Governor Abdulfatah Ahmed disclosed this in a statement through his Senior Special Assistant, Media and Communications, Dr. Muyideen Akorede on Wednesday. The Governor noted that with the launch of the IF-K, which pools resources for funding infrastructure, the N20b naira bond has become unnecessary as all ongoing and new projects...

Kaduna Pursues Affordable Healthcare Through Contributory Scheme

A scheme to guarantee universal access to basic healthcare is to be introduced in Kaduna State. The state government is already providing free health services for pregnant women, children under five years and the elderly. The proposed scheme is designed to widen the net of coverage, and ensure that all residents of the state, including the poor and vulnerable, have access to healthcare without incurring out-of-pocket expenditure. The Kaduna State Executive Council on Monday, 26th September...

Video: Olamide – Owo Blow

Multi-talented artiste Olamide, whom become well known for his hit back to back since 2009 till date, Baddosneh turns up for all the dancers out there with the brand new compelling music video for his August-released single “Owo Blow. Olamide says “My music is different and it’s real. I don’t try to copy anyone, and I’m only going to spread a positive message while having fun doing it”. Check out the hitmaker’s new video below, Clarence Peters Shot It!” AUDIO DOWNLOAD Watch...

I did not ‘bomb’ Buhari – Tinubu

A National Leader of the All Progressives Congress, Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu, has denied a media report that he “bombed” President Muhammadu Buhari. Some posts had on between Monday and Tuesday quoted Tinubu as having taken on Buhari following his face-off with the National Chairman of the APC, Chief John Odigie-Oyegun. He was quoted to have made snide remarks about the President, including the fact that Buhari begged him to emerge president. But in a statement by the Tinubu Media Office, the...

Jose Mourinho reveals why he may be forced to drop Wayne Rooney again

Rooney could be left out of Manchester United’s Europa League starting lineup after Jose Mourinho claimed he needs to “protect” the striker. Rooney was dropped for last Saturday’s rout of Leicester and has not trained fully this week due to a back injury. The England captain returned to training today at Carrington and United manager Mourinho will discuss whether he should start against Ukraine side Zorya Luhansk or be on the substitutes’ bench. But Mourinho is mindful that the endless debate over...

Rivers rerun: Police must be apolitical – Wike tells AIG

Rivers State Governor, Nyesom Wike has advised the Police High Command to take urgent steps to weed out bad eggs from the force. Governor Wike made the call at the Government House in Port Harcourt during a courtesy call on him by the AIG, Abubakar Marafa of Zone Six. Governor Wike observed that the bad eggs in the police structure negatively affected the implementation of security measures. He assured the Zone 6 Police Command of the continued support of the Rivers State...

Education Reforms: How a Nigerian State is Blazing the Trail

Kaduna State is reputed as having the third oldest University in Nigeria and the only Aviation Technology Institute in West Africa. This is in addition to the fact that the state is home to at least 2 other Universities, 2 Polytechnics, 6 Colleges of Education and 4 Research Institutes that focus on diverse fields from water to leather and agriculture to health. The presence of these institutions has helped the State build a reputation as being...

Stop addressing Ize-Iyamu as Pastor, he’s a pathological liar – Oshiomole

The Governor of Edo State, Adams Oshiomhole, has berated the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP candidate in the ongoing governorship election in the state, Osagie Ize-Iyamu, for claiming to be a pastor. Addressing reporters, the Governor described Ize-Iyamu, who is his former campaign director, as a “pathological liar”, who “lies effortlessly”. Oshiomhole stressed that the PDP flag bearer is not worthy of being addressed as a pastor for alleging that some All Progressives Congress, APC, governors, including Akinwunmi Ambode of Lagos and...

Edo election: Female police officer arrested for collecting bribe from PDP chieftain

A female police officer who was caught by an agent of the APC while collecting money from a chieftain of the PDP at unit 28, ward 7 in Ikpoba Okhai LGA was arrested by APC supporters who handed her over to the police.   The female police officer was locked up at Ugbekun police station after her action caused a little tension in the polling booth.

Army denies Boko Haram hoisted flags near Chibok

The Nigerian Army has refuted the report that Boko Haram insurgents have hoisted flags in some communities near Chibok, Borno State. A statement by the army spokesman, Col. Sani Usman, said the troops of the Operations Lafiya Dole are maintaining a high level of vigilance in and around the area to forestall infiltration by the terrorists. The British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) had yesterday reported that the insurgents hoisted their flags in three villages in northern Borno, after over-running the area. The report...

Inconclusive elections: Senate to probe INEC’s performance

The Senate has resolved to investigate the performance of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) in the last one year, while calling on President Muhammadu Buhari to immediately nominate suitably qualified persons to fill vacant positions in the commission. The decision followed the adoption of a motion on the matter co-sponsored by the Deputy President of the Senate, Senator Ike Ekweremadu and the Senate majority leader, Senator Mohammed Ali Ndume, against the backdrop of the spate of inconclusive elections conducted...

FG needs to spend less, earn more, borrow way out of recession – Obasanjo

Former President Olusegun Obasanjo on Tuesday made a number of recommendations to the federal government as the surest way of getting out of the current economic downturn, saying that the government needs to spend less, earn more, and borrow its way out of the recession. Obasanjo spoke in Abeokuta, the Ogun State capital, yesterday at the National Council on Finance and Economic Development (NACOFED) conference with the theme: “Enhancing Revenue Generation and Obtaining Best Value for Money in Expenditure”. The former...

Jibrin explains why he shunned Ethics Committee hearing

The former Chairman of the House of Representatives Committee on Appropriation, Abdulmumin Jibrin has given reason for his absence at a hearing on his alleged breach of House Rules by the Committee on Ethics and Privileges. Jibrin told newsmen on Tuesday that he shunned the panel because the Chairman, Nicholas Ossai had demonstrated bias in words and action. His words: “Ahead of the resumption of the House I wrote a 17-page letter to all members and one of the issues I...