OPINION: FG’s pyrrhic victory against corruption – by Uche Igwe

Published:21 Nov, 2012

OPINION: FG’s pyrrhic victory against corruption – by Uche Igwe

Corruption is the single factor that has the most catastrophic consequence on our national development. It amounts to idle repetition to say that currently, pervasive corruption has afflicted all levels of government in Nigeria. The raging debate around the use and abuse of plea bargain has thus raised fundamental issues about the celebrated lip service in the war against corruption in Nigeria and the helplessness of our anti-corruption agencies . For those who do not know, a plea bargain is simply an agreement between a criminal prosecutor and a defendant whereby both parties agree to get into a deal such that the defendant agrees to plead guilty in return for some leniency and concession from the prosecutor. It involves the defendant entering guilty plea to a lesser offence or to only one or some of the counts of a multi-count indictment, in return for a lighter sentence than that possible for a graver charge. Prominent legal scholars such as Dr. Chidi Odinkalu, Chairman of the Human Rights Commission, have justified the utility of this concept in the speedy disposition of many pending criminal cases in courts. However, many people disagree with him, especially as it relates to cases of corruption. The late radical jurist, Justice Kayode Eso (retd.), once lampooned the idea of plea bargain as an open instrument for the celebration of graft. A former Chief Justice of Nigeria, Dahiru Musdapher, also considers it as an obnoxiously dubious and fraudulent concept that amounts to granting undue leniency to criminals. Nevertheless, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission insists on the use of plea bargain in national efforts towards the recovery of stolen assets and has recently submitted a bill to the National Assembly to widen the scope of its application. EFCC officials argue that the application of plea bargain assisted them to reach a speedy conclusion of high profile corruption cases such as those that involved an advance fee fraud kingpin, Emmanuel Nwude; a former Inspector-General of Police, Tafa Balogun; a former Bayelsa State Governor Diepreye Alamieyeseigha; a former Edo State Governor Lucky Igbenidion; and ex-banker Cecilia Ibru, in a cost-effective manner. It was reported that these individuals willingly forfeited ‘some’ of the properties allegedly acquired with stolen funds but the level of transparency of the negotiations can only be a matter of endless conjecture.

What the EFCC appears to be saying is that public office holders can go ahead and loot the treasury and when you are caught in the till, you can simply make a deal. Surrender part of what you have stolen, negotiate a lenient sentence and go home to enjoy the rest of your loot. For instance, after allegedly handing over about $1.2bn (N180bn) in cash and assets, Mrs. Ibru was handed six months imprisonment which was mostly spent on a cosy hospital bed in Lagos. Observers are shocked that the corruption watchdog does not consider how such a method will act as a deterrent or motivation for potential offenders. It is only in Nigeria that indicted public officials walk around freely and even wield expansive political influence. What a country!

One must say that the promoters of plea bargain do have a very solid reformist argument that is valid in law. However, their zeal betrays a naïve confidence in the Nigerian judiciary. Is this not the same judiciary where Justice Marcel Awokulehin, who discharged and acquitted Chief James Ibori and his co-travellers, still holds sway? Where justice is still available to the highest bidder? Is it any news that the Nigerian judiciary is believed to play a huge role in frustrating the war against corruption by issuing suspicious injunctions even on weekends?

A former Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices Commission recently yelled that executive interference in the operations of the EFCC and ICPC had resulted in adverse consequences on the war against corruption in Nigeria. Really! That could provide some insight. So, where is this coming from? The push for the adoption of plea bargain sounds to me like an official surrender of troops of the Nigerian anti-corruption army to a superior firepower of the corrupt elite. How can those who have been mandated to prove cases of corruption beyond every reasonable doubt now stoop to start making a deal with those who they are supposed to prosecute and possibly put in jail? It is either corruption is finally winning the war eventually or one is just being naïve?

Even a cursory look at the list of beneficiaries of plea bargain will reveal that they belong to a particular class in our society. We have been told that the next set of deals that may be negotiated is that between the EFCC on one side and Mahmud Tukur, son of the Peoples Democratic Party Chairman, Bamanga Tukur; and Abdullahi Alao, son of Ibadan-based businessman, Arisekola Alao, for allegedly embezzling N1.9bn obtained from the Petroleum Support Fund purportedly for the importation of petroleum products. So, where is the slogan that there will be no sacred cows? How come such deals have not been extended to many awaiting trial inmates who have been detained endlessly in our over-crowded prisons and even forgotten? Or, is the deal-making specifically designed for the rich and the affluent?

Finally, we must consider the concept of plea bargain very critically before we allow the EFCC and their apologists to surreptitiously smuggle it into our statutory laws. Such an action could reverse some of the gains we claim to have made in the war against corruption. The exclamation of Justice Musdapher implying that this concept is a flagrant subordination of public interest that could ridicule our legal system sounds too important for us to ignore. The congestion in our courts can be eliminated with policies that prevent judges from granting frivolous applications. We must remember that countries that have utilised plea bargain are those where public officials take asset declaration seriously. Not our own where even our President does not give a damn about it!

 

Uche Igwe (ucheigwe@gmail.com)

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Politics: In Rivers, It’s A Game Of Death.

I’m not used to too much prayer, but I must begin today’s piece with a word of prayer. I pray that God Almighty visits the killers of Barr. Ken Atsuwete (and their sponsors) with slow and painful death. Amen!   I pray that the divine punishment for the dastardly act of Monday constitutes the largest chunk of the inheritance, which the killers (and their sponsors) would pass on to their children and their children’s children in the fullness of time. Amen...

Pension Assets Hit N5.8tn As PenCom Seeks To Invest 40% In Infrastructure

The Director-General of the National Pension Commission (PenCom), Ms. Chinelo Anohu-Amazu, on Tuesday hinted that the total pension assets had hit N5.8 trillion, adding that the commission was targeting to invest 40 per cent of the funds in infrastructure and housing by 2019.   She was, however, quick to add that the safety of such investments would not be compromised, as they would require guarantees from government and stakeholders.   She said currently, 15 per cent of the assets are invested in infrastructure...

Why Team Nigeria Performed Poorly In Rio – Dalung

What appears another major controversy over the employment of German tactician, Gernot Rohr, to manage the Super Eagles cropped up yesterday following a declaration by Sports Minister, Solomon Dalung, that he knew nothing about the deal. ?? Recall that the Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) recently selected Rohr to manage the Super Eagles despite the minister’s preference for a local coach.   Dalung was at the State House yesterday, Abuja to brief President Muhammadu Buhari on the nation’s outing at the ?just concluded Olympics...

Osinbajo Urges Youths To Key Into Multi-tasking Age To Remain Relevant

Vice President Yemi Osinbajo on Tuesday advised Nigerian youths to see the present age as one that offers them an opportunity to embrace “multi-tasking”. He gave the advice while opening a two-day Google Digital Training programme for Youth Employment with the theme: “Diversifying the Nigerian Economy: Enabling Youth through Digital Skills Training’’. Osinbajo said that the opportunities abound for professionals with multi skills to excel in the period of economic hardship and joblessness, adding that innovation was the best way to...

Turkey Denies Reaching Ceasefire With Kurdish Forces

A Turkish minister has said that his country does “not accept” US claims that its military has reached a ceasefire deal with Kurdish fighters in northern Syria. The statement came after US officials said that Turkish-backed Syrian rebels and Kurdish forces had agreed on a temporary pause in fighting in northern Syria. The US has been warning the sides to focus on fighting the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) group elements there. “We do not accept in any circumstances...

I Am Not The Problem Of Nigerian Sports – Dalung

Sports Minister, Solomon Dalung, has fired back at those calling for his sack following the country’s poor outing at the 2016 Olympic Games and says he is not the problem.   Dalung was speaking to State House correspondents, after meeting with President Muhammadu Buhari to review the Olympics, where Nigeria finished with only one bronze medal.   He argued that poor performances have always been the case with Nigeria, even before he was appointed. “I am not the problem of Nigerian sports. Abysmal performance...

Catholic Priest Faces Fresh Charge Over 10-Year-Old Girl’s Rape

The Federal Capital Territory Police Command, yesterday, said it had concluded plans to dock a Catholic priest, Reverend Father Anthony Ochigbo, before an Abuja High Court over allegation that he raped a 10-year-old girl.   The Officer-in-Charge of Legal Matters at the Command, Mr. James Idachaba, made the disclosure after he applied and withdrew an initial one-count rape charge Police entered against the priest before an Abuja Upper Area Court at Gudu.   The Upper Area court judge, Alhaji Umar Kagarko, had on...

Over 5,000 CSOs Support Buhari On War Against Insurgency

Coalition Against Terrorism and Extremism, CATE, a coalition of over 5000 Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) Tuesday in Abuja held a rally in appreciation of the success made by the administration of President Muhammadu Buhari and the current military leadership in the war against Boko Haram insurgents.   Addressing journalists during the rally which kicked off at the Federal Secretariat and ended at the Office of the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (SGF), Secretary General of the Coalitions, Comrade Daniel...

Donald Trump to Visit Mexico After More Than A Year Of Mocking It

Donald J. Trump will visit Mexico on Wednesday for a private meeting with President Enrique Peña Nieto — a trip that will take him to a nation he has repeatedly scorned — before quickly flying back for what is billed as a...

Duterte Ready To Defend Philippine Drug Killings With Obama

Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte said Wednesday he was ready to defend his bloody crackdown on illegal drugs, which has sparked U.S. and international concerns, when he meets with President Barack Obama on the sidelines of an Asian summit next week. Duterte said he would demand that he be allowed to first explain the context of his crackdown before engaging Obama in a discussion of the widespread deaths. The two will meet for the first time on...

Benin’s Move To Scrap Visas For Africans Lauded

A decision by Benin to allow Africans travelling to the west African country in without visas has been applauded by many social media users from across the world. Earlier, Rwanda made a similar decision earlier in the year together with Ghana in a move meant to promote intra-Africa trade in line with Africa Union’s 2030 Agenda for “a continent with seamless borders” to ease movement. “Keep on the good work. We will rule the world one day. Our time shall come,”...

Trump To Visit Mexico Wednesday, Meet Its President

Donald Trump announced he would travel to Mexico on Wednesday to meet its president, just hours ahead of giving a much-anticipated speech in Arizona on immigration. The Republican presidential nominee’s surprise trip south of the border comes as debate about his hardline immigration policies is reaching fever pitch. Although his visit holds potential political peril, Trump could seize control of the campaign narrative at a crucial time, showing a willingness to engage diplomatically on a...

CBN Licenses 11 New Int’l Money Transfer Operators

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) yesterday licensed 11 new International Money Transfer Operators (IMTOs). The new entrants are joining Western Union, MoneyGram and Ria, which had been cleared by the CBN. The new operators are Trans-Fast Remittance LLC; WorldRemit Limited, UAE Exchange Centre LLC; Wari Limited, Homesend S.C.R.L, Small World Financial Services Group Limited and Weblink International Limited. Others are Cash Pot Limited, DT&T Corporation Limited, Fiem Group LLC DBA Ping Express and CP Express...

FCT Minister Strips FHA Building Approval Powers

Minister of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Muhammad Bello, has directed the Development Control Department of the FCT Administration to take full responsibility for building plan approvals and construction supervision in the territory, in accordance with extant regulations. The minister gave this directive in reaction to Thursday incident of building collapse in Gwarinpa. He reminded the department that in line with the provisions of Section 7, Sub-section 1-3 of the FCT Act of 1976 and Part II, Section 27-41 of the...

We Spend N475m Monthly Fuelling Jets Combating Boko Haram- Air Force

The Nigerian Air Force (NAF) spends N475 million monthly to fuel its fighter jets and transport planes to fight Boko Haram. The Chief of Air Staff, Air Marshal Sadique Abubakar, said in Lagos yesterday that the force uses 1.9 million litres of aviation fuel monthly to fly missions in the North-East, the hotbed of Boko Haram insurgency. Aviation fuel sells for N250 per litres, meaning that at least, N475 million is spent on a monthly basis. He spoke during...

Nigerians Urged Not To Panic As Annular Eclipse Hits September 1

National Space Research and Development Agency (NSRDA) has urged the public not to panic over the Annular Eclipse which will be experienced between the hours of 7:15am and 10:03am on Thursday, September 1 with slight variations in actual timing across the country. In a press statement by the Head of Media and Corporate Communications, Dr Felix Ale, the Agency appealed to the general public not to panic or adduce any mystical interpretations to this...

Nigeria’s Recession Pushes Bonds To Lowest Point In More Than Two Weeks

Nigeria's dollar bonds have fallen to their lowest point in more than two weeks after official statistics  showed that the  economy had entered its first recession in 25 years.   The official data showed that the economy contracted by 2.06 percent in the second quarter.  According to a Reuters report “The 2023 issue chalked up the biggest losses, down 0.728 cents to trade at 99.417 cents in the dollar - its lowest since Aug....

Integrate Chinese Language Into Schools’ Curricular – NGO tells FG

A Non-governmental Oganisation (NGO), Initiative of African Friends of China, has called on the federal government to introduce the teaching of Chinese Language in secondary schools across the country. The President of the NGO, Mr. Fred Ogwazu, made the call while signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with DBS Media Ltd, a Nigerian creative media content agency in Lagos recently. Ogwazu said the development if considered will tend to explore maximally the socio-economic corporations, educational and cultural exchanges as well as...

Nigeria, UK sign MoU On Return Of Stolen Assets

The Federal Government has signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the British Government on the modalities for the return of Nigerian stolen assets. The Attorney-General of the Federation, Abubakar Malami, signed on behalf of the Federal Government in Abuja on Tuesday. Malami said that the MoU reflected the desire and willingness of both countries to continue cooperation and mutual support. Malami said that this was in the responsible and transparent return of all recovered assets. He outlined the objectives of the MoU...

Nigerians React To CNN’s ‘Zuckerberg Visits Sub-Sahara Africa’ Headline

International broadcaster, the Cable News Network (CNN), has angered Nigerians for omitting the country’s name in the headline of a report announcing the visit of Facebook founder, Mark Zuckerberg, to Africa’s most populous country. The headline mentioned Sub-Sahara Africa as Mr. Zuckerberg’s destination. That headline promptly sparked anger in one of the world’s largest oil producers, with citizens taking to Facebook and Twitter to attack the broadcaster for omitting ‘Nigeria’ and creating the impression that...

Marcus Rashford Is Spending His New-Found Fortune in Exactly the Right Way

He's a great kid, isn't he? Marcus Rashford picked up where he left off from last season at the weekend with Manchester United's late, late winning goal at Hull City, maintaining his side's perfect record for the start of the season.