OPINION: FG’s pyrrhic victory against corruption – by Uche Igwe

Published:21 Nov, 2012

OPINION: FG’s pyrrhic victory against corruption – by Uche Igwe

Corruption is the single factor that has the most catastrophic consequence on our national development. It amounts to idle repetition to say that currently, pervasive corruption has afflicted all levels of government in Nigeria. The raging debate around the use and abuse of plea bargain has thus raised fundamental issues about the celebrated lip service in the war against corruption in Nigeria and the helplessness of our anti-corruption agencies . For those who do not know, a plea bargain is simply an agreement between a criminal prosecutor and a defendant whereby both parties agree to get into a deal such that the defendant agrees to plead guilty in return for some leniency and concession from the prosecutor. It involves the defendant entering guilty plea to a lesser offence or to only one or some of the counts of a multi-count indictment, in return for a lighter sentence than that possible for a graver charge. Prominent legal scholars such as Dr. Chidi Odinkalu, Chairman of the Human Rights Commission, have justified the utility of this concept in the speedy disposition of many pending criminal cases in courts. However, many people disagree with him, especially as it relates to cases of corruption. The late radical jurist, Justice Kayode Eso (retd.), once lampooned the idea of plea bargain as an open instrument for the celebration of graft. A former Chief Justice of Nigeria, Dahiru Musdapher, also considers it as an obnoxiously dubious and fraudulent concept that amounts to granting undue leniency to criminals. Nevertheless, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission insists on the use of plea bargain in national efforts towards the recovery of stolen assets and has recently submitted a bill to the National Assembly to widen the scope of its application. EFCC officials argue that the application of plea bargain assisted them to reach a speedy conclusion of high profile corruption cases such as those that involved an advance fee fraud kingpin, Emmanuel Nwude; a former Inspector-General of Police, Tafa Balogun; a former Bayelsa State Governor Diepreye Alamieyeseigha; a former Edo State Governor Lucky Igbenidion; and ex-banker Cecilia Ibru, in a cost-effective manner. It was reported that these individuals willingly forfeited ‘some’ of the properties allegedly acquired with stolen funds but the level of transparency of the negotiations can only be a matter of endless conjecture.

What the EFCC appears to be saying is that public office holders can go ahead and loot the treasury and when you are caught in the till, you can simply make a deal. Surrender part of what you have stolen, negotiate a lenient sentence and go home to enjoy the rest of your loot. For instance, after allegedly handing over about $1.2bn (N180bn) in cash and assets, Mrs. Ibru was handed six months imprisonment which was mostly spent on a cosy hospital bed in Lagos. Observers are shocked that the corruption watchdog does not consider how such a method will act as a deterrent or motivation for potential offenders. It is only in Nigeria that indicted public officials walk around freely and even wield expansive political influence. What a country!

One must say that the promoters of plea bargain do have a very solid reformist argument that is valid in law. However, their zeal betrays a naïve confidence in the Nigerian judiciary. Is this not the same judiciary where Justice Marcel Awokulehin, who discharged and acquitted Chief James Ibori and his co-travellers, still holds sway? Where justice is still available to the highest bidder? Is it any news that the Nigerian judiciary is believed to play a huge role in frustrating the war against corruption by issuing suspicious injunctions even on weekends?

A former Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices Commission recently yelled that executive interference in the operations of the EFCC and ICPC had resulted in adverse consequences on the war against corruption in Nigeria. Really! That could provide some insight. So, where is this coming from? The push for the adoption of plea bargain sounds to me like an official surrender of troops of the Nigerian anti-corruption army to a superior firepower of the corrupt elite. How can those who have been mandated to prove cases of corruption beyond every reasonable doubt now stoop to start making a deal with those who they are supposed to prosecute and possibly put in jail? It is either corruption is finally winning the war eventually or one is just being naïve?

Even a cursory look at the list of beneficiaries of plea bargain will reveal that they belong to a particular class in our society. We have been told that the next set of deals that may be negotiated is that between the EFCC on one side and Mahmud Tukur, son of the Peoples Democratic Party Chairman, Bamanga Tukur; and Abdullahi Alao, son of Ibadan-based businessman, Arisekola Alao, for allegedly embezzling N1.9bn obtained from the Petroleum Support Fund purportedly for the importation of petroleum products. So, where is the slogan that there will be no sacred cows? How come such deals have not been extended to many awaiting trial inmates who have been detained endlessly in our over-crowded prisons and even forgotten? Or, is the deal-making specifically designed for the rich and the affluent?

Finally, we must consider the concept of plea bargain very critically before we allow the EFCC and their apologists to surreptitiously smuggle it into our statutory laws. Such an action could reverse some of the gains we claim to have made in the war against corruption. The exclamation of Justice Musdapher implying that this concept is a flagrant subordination of public interest that could ridicule our legal system sounds too important for us to ignore. The congestion in our courts can be eliminated with policies that prevent judges from granting frivolous applications. We must remember that countries that have utilised plea bargain are those where public officials take asset declaration seriously. Not our own where even our President does not give a damn about it!

 

Uche Igwe (ucheigwe@gmail.com)

Related Posts

Recent Posts

10 World’s Best Airports For 2016 Announced (SEE LIST)

For the fourth year in a row, Singapore Changi Airport has clinched the World's Best Airport title at the annual SkyTrax World Airport Awards, announced Wednesday in Cologne, Germany. The Skytrax awards are based on millions of votes collected in passenger surveys. Many of those passing through the island city-state are clearly pleased with the airport's innovations, such as two 24-hour movie theaters screening the latest...

#EdoDecides: Abdulmutallab, US Bomber’s Portrait, Name Appears In Voters’ Register

Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, who was jailed in the United States in 2012  for terrorism offences has appeared on the voters’ register in Edo state. Governor Adams Oshiomhole drew attention to the existence of  AbdulMuttalab’s  portrait in a fake voters register now in circulation. A high stake governorship election is due in the state tomorrow, with the All Progressives Congress candidate, Godwin Obaseki locked against Pastor Ize Iyamu of the opposition Peoples Democratic Party.

No Plan To Sell Any Asset Now- FG

The federal government Tuesday said it has not taken any decision to sell any national asset. Minister of Budget and National Planning, Senator Udoma Udo Udoma appealed to those opposed to the planned sale of some national assets to exercise patience with the government “as the government is yet to decide on assets sale in its stimulus package.” Udoma made the disclosure in Abuja at the 57th Annual Conference of the  Nigerian Economic Society (NES) where...

Fashola Promises Uninterrupted Power Supply

Former governor of Lagos State and minister of power, housing and infrastructure, Babatunde Raji Fashola has said the problem of Nigeria’s power sector is man-made and that he is determined to make sure the sector works, promising to deliver on uninterrupted power supply. Fashola, who is one of the speakers at the maiden edition of Made in Nigeria Festival taking place at Eko Atlantic, Lagos, presented a 3-phase blue-print of power-generation, steady supply of power...

2019 Polls In Danger Without RECs – Senate

The Senate on Tuesday said there were signs that the 2019 general elections would be inconclusive without enough Resident Electoral Commissioners (RECs) to oversee it. This followed a motion by Deputy Senate President Ike Ekweremadu and supported by the Senate Leader Ali Ndume. Ekweremadu expressed concerns that the rate of inconclusive elections in many states showed that the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) was endangering the nation’s democracy. He alleged...

Adele Cracks 10 Million US Sales Once Again

Adele’s “25” has topped 10 million sales in the United States, her second album to cross the threshold as the English singer cements her status as the century’s top-selling artist. The US industry body presented Adele a plaque certifying that “25,” released in November, had gone diamond platinum, or sold 10 million, at a ceremony backstage at New York’s Madison Square Garden where she just played six sold-out shows, her publicist announced Tuesday. The Recording...

Buhari Welcomes $5bn Investment From India

President Muhammadu Buhari on Tuesday welcomed the proposed five billion dollars investment in Nigeria by visiting Indian business delegation, led by Indian Vice-President Hamid Ansari. According to a statement issued by Buhari’s Senior Special Assistant on Media and Publicity, Malam Garba Shehu, the President made the remark when he received Ansari at the State House, Abuja. Shehu quoted Buhari as saying “India has already invested 10 billion dollars in the Nigerian economy. “Nigeria will...

Former Nigerian Naval Chief Arraigned For Alleged Corruption

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, EFCC, on Tuesday arraigned a former Chief of Naval Staff, Usman Jibrin, before a court in Abuja on corruption charges. Mr. Jibrin, a retired vice admiral, was arraigned alongside two others: Bala Mshelia and Shehu Ahmadu, both retired rear admirals. They were arraigned before Justice A. Umar of the FCT High Court in Maitama, Abuja on a 4-count charge of criminal conspiracy. They were docked alongside Habour Bay...

Lagos CJ Frees 20 Inmates

The Chief Judge of Lagos State, Justice Oluwafunmilayo Atilade, on Tuesday granted amnesty to 20 inmates at the Ikoyi Prisons in Lagos.   The CJ freed the inmates during her visit to the prison as part of the activities marking the commencement of the 2016/2017 legal year.   The 20 freed inmates had been in custody, awaiting trial for between a period of nine months and four years.   Atilade said...

You Need To Watch This Dance Battle Between Trump & Clinton

Seems like the US presidential debate extended to a dance battle between Donald Trump and Hilary Clinton. Well not the real duo, but the dancers represented each candidate by wearing their masks. Watch dance battle video below: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oKtxJ85h7P8  

Anambra State Police Declares Ex-419 Kingpin Chief Emmanuel Nwude (Owelle Abagana) wanted

Anambra State Police Command has declared wanted, Chief Emmanuel Nwude, (Owelle Abagana) over involvement in a case of conspiracy, malicious damage, murder, act of terrorism and attack on policemen. Chief Nwude, from Umudunu, Abagana is a convicted Advance-Fee fraudster. He and his accomplices were in 2005 convicted by a federal high court for pulling the biggest 419 fraud in history.   Before his conviction, Nwude was the biggest shareholder in Union Bank...

Nigerian Doctor Who Asked Patient ‘Do You Like Big Ones Or Small Ones?’ Is Suspended In Canada

A tribunal has found Dr. Adekunle Williams Owolabi guilty of all four professional misconduct complaints lodged against him and suspended his licence to practise for six months. The decision was given Monday in St. John's, at the professional misconduct hearing against Owolabi conducted by a tribunal panel established by the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Newfoundland and Labrador. At an earlier hearing, Labrador teacher Arlene Johnson testified that when she visited Owolabi for a pelvic exam he made...

Lil Wayne Officiated Same-Sex Wedding While In Jail

In Gone ’Til November, which covers his stint in New York’s Rikers Island , the rapper says that the union was toasted with 13 bottles of Gatorade  

Court Freezes all Imo State Government Accounts

The Court of Appeal sitting in Owerri, has ordered the freezing of all the accounts of Imo State Government and the confiscation of all monies domiciled in them. The court gave the order while delivering judgement on an appeal filed by the Governor of the state Rochas Okorocha, the Attorney General of Imo State, the Environmental Transformation Committee and the Ministry of Petroleum and Environment, Imo State. The state government had approached the court to upturn...

Senate Rejects Sale Of National Assets To Revive Economy

The Nigerian Senate has rejected the proposed sale of national asset by the federal government. The Senate took the decision on Tuesday at the resumed plenary after extensive deliberation. The Buhari administration has proposed the sell some asset to revive the economy. But many Nigerians are opposed to the plan, arguing that previous sales barely helped the nation’s economy. The government has suggested that if it eventually adopts the policy, it would insist on a re-purchase

Tinubu’s Allegations Not True – Odigie-Oyegun

The National Chairman of the All Progressives Congress, Chief John Odigie-Oyegun, has said he will not take issue with the National Leader of the party, Asiwaju Bola Tinubu. He, however, said “most” of the allegations in the media report were “not true,” noting that the party would focus on the September 28 governorship election in Edo State, which he said was his “priority”. Odigie-Oyegun said this on Monday in Benin in response to the call...

The Jewel In The North, Celebrating #ZamfaraAt20 – Ahmad Abdul Kareem

As Nigerians all over the world celebrated 36 years of Nigeria’s independence from colonial rule on October 1 1960, a different kind of celebration was going on in newly created Zamfara State. In an early nationwide broadcast on that memorable then, the then Head of State and Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces, Late General Sani Abacha announced the creation of Zamfara State out of the old Sokoto State. The celebration and jubilation in Zamfara on that day was...

Man Sentenced To 30 Months In Jail Over Stolen Slippers

A Kano Senior Magistrates’ Court sitting in Rijiyar Zaki on Monday sentenced, Rabiu Sani, 22, to 30 months imprisonment for theft of slippers. The Senior Magistrate, Aminu Fagge, sentenced Sani to two years and six months after he pleaded guilty to a one-count charge. Fagge did not give the convict of Aisami Quarters in Kano an option of fine. Prosecutor Yusuf Sale had told the court that Surajo Umar of Kurna Quarters, Kano, reported the case to Nasarawa Police Division, Kano,...

Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie’s Prenup Details Revealed; Custody Battle May Get Messy

Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie signed an ‘ironclad’ prenup before tying the knot in 2014. Its details have just been revealed as well as the fact that the real battle between Brad and Angelina will be over the custody of their children. According to TMZ, Brad and Jolie signed a prenuptial agreement that outlines exactly who gets what before they wed back in 2014. Their combined fortune is a reported $400 million. Brad & Jolie have 12 total properties together...

Donald Trump keeps Sniffling During Presidential Debate and the Internet Wants to Know Why

Republican party candidate Donald Trump who recently raised questions about Hillary Clinton’s health, claiming she had no stamina, appeared to be sniffling during the U.S presidential debate on Monday night—and social media users took notice. Clinton was diagnosed with pneumonia earlier this month and her campaign team has constantly refuted claims by Donald Trump that she is not medically fit to be president, so Twitter users reacted when they saw Trump sniffling repeatedly....

ISIS Monsters Executes Six Members who Fled Battle by Crushing them With BULLDOZER

There is no limit to ISIS barbarity as the monsters crushed six of its own members to death with a bulldozer after accusing them of running from a battle. The men, who were killed on Monday according to local reports, fled the town of Sharqat in northern Iraq. According to Iraqi News, civilians were forced to watch the barbaric execution. The strategic town outside Mosul fell to Government forces, who have launched a major campaign to retake the northern...