Open letter to lawmakers on state creation – by Niyi Akinnaso (niyi@comcast.net)

Published:6 Nov, 2012

Open letter to lawmakers on state creation – by Niyi Akinnaso

Dear legislators,

Please, do not create more states. This is an appeal on behalf of millions of fellow Nigerians, particularly those whose voices may not be heard on this matter. To those among you who find the creation of additional states a preposterous venture, I applaud you. To those who have vested interests in creating fiefdoms for themselves after leaving the National Assembly or in fulfilling promises made earlier to traditional rulers and other petitioners demanding states of their own, I say, look beyond parochial interests. Look at the big picture. Do the right thing: Drop the idea of creating more states for various reasons stated below. There are far more important problems to be solved, including corruption, security, and infrastructural deficits than embarking on that voyage of fantasy.

My appeal also goes to the agitators for the creation of more states. From all indications, the 56 or so petitions came largely from groups which have suffered limited access to power within their present states. The problem with the petitions is that they are from the elite, without grass-roots input, which is why the Nigeria Bar Association suggested a referendum on the matter. Nevertheless, I fully understand the plight of minorities in the hands of hegemonic majorities within the existing states as well as their struggle for equity and social justice. I remember once being told by a professional colleague that my Yoruba was not “pure” because it was tainted by my native Idanre dialect. I told the fellow that he would have been taught my dialect in school had Bishop Ajayi Crowther based Yoruba orthography on it. But my response did not remove the dual feeling of inadequacy and unequal treatment as a result of my native dialect.

However, the creation of a new orthography based on Idanre dialect will not solve my problem, just as the creation of additional states for minorities locked within the existing states is not the right solution. Any government would be foolhardy to allow the development of a dialect-based orthography to function in public schools, partly because of costs and partly because of its political implications. Speakers of other Yoruba dialects may want to develop orthographies for their dialects in reaction to the hegemony of the Oyo dialect.

A short trip down memory lane will show how the orthography analogy applies to the creation of states. The balkanisation of the federation through the creation of states began as a Northern reaction to Gen. J.T.U. Aguiyi Ironsi’s Decree 34, which abrogated the federal structure in favour of a “unitary” system in which the centre became much more powerful than ever before. Ironsi’s action was interpreted by Northerners within the context of an Igbo-led coup in which two Northern icons, the Sardauna of Sokoto, Alhaji Ahmadu Bello, and Sir Abubakar Tawafa Balewa (then Prime Minister), were killed; but no Igbo politician was. Yet, the Igbo turned out to be the major beneficiaries of the coup. (Then) Lt. Col. Yakubu Gowon, who succeeded Ironsi after a coup that eliminated him, kept the strong centre but created 12 states to diffuse Ironsi’s unitary system. And that was the beginning of the agitation by minorities locked in the big states for the creation of their own states. As the government responded to their demands, the number of states kept increasing until we arrived at the present 36-state structure.

So, my dear legislators, the above summary is the origin of the 56 petitions before you today. There are many reasons why the creation of more states is neither a viable project nor a reasonable action to take at this time. First and foremost is the issue of viability. It is common knowledge that a number of the existing states are under distress. Inadequate capital and the lack of necessary infrastructure continue to hamper their ability to establish job-creating institutions, attract manufacturing industries, and facilitate the growth of small businesses. In the absence of job creators such as these, state governments became the largest employers of labour. This is particularly true of states such as Kano, Katsina, Niger, Osun, Sokoto, and Zamfara which spend 50 per cent and above of their gross annual revenue on a small percentage of the population, consisting of elected officials, political appointees, and civil service personnel.

To complicate matters, many of the existing 36 states are deficient in raising enough internally generated revenue to supplement their Federal allocations. The result is a recourse to local banks for short-term loans and to the capital market for long-term loans to finance capital projects. That’s not all. According to the Revenue Mobilisation Allocation and Fiscal Commission earlier this year, the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory were under a $2.165bn (about N339.9bn) foreign debt. The cumulative effect of these developments is diminished capacity to finance developmental projects. The critical question then is: By what magic will newly created states sidestep this conundrum?

The argument that the creation of new states will bring the government closer to the people falls flat in the face of extant realities highlighted by limited financial capacity, as illustrated above. Even more importantly, such an argument ignores the existence of 774 Local Government Areas across the country, whose function is precisely to bring government closer to the people, yet no real development has been seen even to the communities near the council headquarters. This immediately highlights an important issue that needs attention—the strengthening of the local governments to ensure equitable distribution of positions and resources within existing states.

By the way, did any of you ever think of the implications of the creation of additional states for the intensification of identity politics, which underlies the ongoing political and security crises in the country? How many more states will you create to satisfy all the nationalities in the country? What difference is there between a sub-ethnic or geographically contiguous group demanding a new state and a Northern Hausa-Fulani or South-Eastern Ndigbo group demanding the Presidency in 2015?

The more expedient way to respond to identity politics is not through the creation of further divisions but through various means of drawing upon the strengths of diversity by making various groups work together. This is why a national conference, which you have ignored, would have been useful in bringing various nationalities to the table to work out how they could work together as one nation. All we’ve had so far is a country, not a nation.

If your interest is not in expanding the corruption dragnet, which has enveloped many of the existing states and Local Governments, then you would desist from creating additional states and focus on tightening corruption loopholes and getting more resources to Local Governments. But if you insist on going ahead, concerned citizens will do well to mobilise protests against the move.

 

Niyi Akinnaso (niyi@comcast.net)

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Police Foils Sea Pirates’ Attack In Bayelsa

Bayelsa Police Command yesterday said its Marine Division in Southern Ijaw local government area of the state had repelled an attack by sea pirates on a passenger boat in the area. Mr. Asinim Butswat, an ASP and spokesman of the Command, said in a statement that the attack occurred on August 28 at Gina-Gbene area of Southern Ijaw. According to the spokesman, an AK-47 assault rifle and live ammunition were recovered from the pirates who...

Buhari Set To Swear In SGF, Others

President Muhammadu Buhari is set to swear in the newly appointed Secretary to the Government of the Federation, SGF, Engr. Babachir David Lawal. The event which would be held at the presidential villa, Abuja any time soon will also include other newly appointed presidential aides. President last week Thursday, appointed Babachir David Lawal as Chief of Staff to the President; Col. Hameed Ibrahim Ali (rtd.) as new Comptroller-General, Nigerian Customs Service; Mr. Kure Martin Abeshi,...

Low: Germany Less Reliant On Schweinsteiger Now

The 55-year-old boss believes he no longer needs to start the Manchester United midfielder in every game, while he is already laying plans to defend the World Cup in 2018   Germany boss Joachim Low has suggested he will use captain Bastian Schweinsteiger sparingly over the coming years amid concerns over the midfielder's...

ISIS Shows New Gold/Silver Coins In New Video

The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) has come out with plans to mint its own gold and silver coins,which it reveals in its latest video, entitled: "The Rise of the Khilafah and the Return of the Gold Dinar.” The hour-long video, released on Saturday, which ISIS narrated in English but subtitled in Arabic, began with an extensive analysis on “the capitalist financial system of enslavement, underpinned by a piece of paper called the Federal...

Sola Ajibola: The Case For Youth Inclusion in Top Government Positions In Nigeria

To many Nigerians, 'Change' has finally come and to some others, every move by the new government must be critiqued. The overall interest of Nigerians is priority and as such, it is important that we do not take the usual route of praise singing or blind criticism of the current administration, but point out salient issues that have held the nation bound for years. The general elections has come and gone, but it is safe to say the campaign...

Defence Chief Visits Site Of Kaduna Helicopter Crash

The Chief of Defence Staff, Maj. Gen Gabriel Olonisakin on Sunday visited the site at the Nigerian Defence Academy, where a Dornier 228 light aircraft belonging to the Nigerian Air Force crashed on Saturday, killing all seven people on board. The Defence Chief, who was accompanied to the crashed site by the Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Defence, Aliyu Ismaila and other top military officers, described the incident as unfortunate. Both the Permanent Secretary...

Probe Obasanjo, Ijaw Youths Tell Buhari

Some youth of Ijaw ethnic extraction have called on President Muhammadu Buhari to extend the ongoing probe of the administration of Presidents Umaru Yar’Adua and Goodluck Jonathan to include the two terms of President Olusegun Obasanjo, which began in May 1999. Writing under the Ijaw Youth Council, IYC, on Sunday, its president Udengs Eradiri in a statement said the group is aware Mr. Buhari has decided to probe weapons procurement from 2007 to date  “While we...

9ice, Timi Dakolo, Reminisce Give Fans An Amazing Time At The Celebrity Fans Challenge.

The biggest celebrity football showdown ever lived up to its promise on Saturday, as some of the biggest names in the Nigerian entertainment industry treated fans to exciting duels. 9ice, Reminisce, Timi Dakolo, Frank Edoho, Fred Amata, Illbliss, Segun Arinze and ID Cabasa locked horns in the name of their respective football clubs on an unforgettable night. The action kicked off with an exciting clash between Chelsea fan 9ice and Arsenal fan Illbliss. 9ice defeated Illbliss thanks to verdicts...

Jonathan Holds Meeting With Ex-Ministers

Former President Goodluck Jonathan has met with some members of his cabinet in a bid to defend his integrity. He was said to have told the former ministers that he was “not a thief in office as being portrayed”. He explained how he met President Muhammadu Buhari for 20 minutes on two issues, which include, advising Buhari against subjecting his person and former cabinet members to “media trial” on alleged corruption and; why the Election Petition Tribunals in Rivers...

Abba Moro Sued By ICT Firm, Claims N350m Damages

Former Minister of Interior, Comrade Abba Moro, has been dragged before a Benue State High Court, sitting in Makurdi, the Benue State capital, by Bosmos Infotech Limited, claiming the sum of N350 million as damages for false, wicked and malicious defamation to tarnish its hard earned reputation. Counsel to the plaintiff, Barr Ocha Ulegede and Co, who instituted the legal ac­tion for his client following public declaration by the former minister that Bos­mos Infotech...

Mikel Obi’s Two Secret Children Uncovered

John Obi Mikel, has fathered two secret lovechildren with different women. The Chelsea midfielder, 28, has a four-year-old son, who was born after he had a brief fling with the lad’s mum. He also has a one-year-old daughter by a woman he met in a nightclub two years ago. The footballer  paid about £80,000 a week  is not named on his son’s birth certificate, but bought a house in the Home Counties where the boy lives...

Nine Princes Battle For Ooni Stool

Nine princes, at the weekend, emerged top contenders from the Giesi Ruling House for the vacant stool of Ooni of Ife, vacated by Oba Okunade Sijuwade, who died recently in a London hospital. Initially, 35 individuals from the ruling house were said to have shown interest in the stool, a development that made the Giesi family to set up a committee to work on the list of contestants, with the intent to choose a capable candidate....

Graft Suspect, Audu Emerges APC’s Kogi Flagbearer

Former Governor of Kogi State, Prince Abubakar Audu, on Sunday received the nod of the All Progressives Congress (APC) to seek a return to the office he had occupied twice. He is currently being prosecuted by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) for alleged contract scams totaling N10 billion. After a landslide victory at the election primaries of the party, Audu pledged to repeat the feat at the coming election in the state. He...

Go & Defend Yourself Before Judicial Commission, Wike Tells Amaechi

Rivers State Governor, Nyesom Wike, has called on his predecessor, Rotimi Amaechi, to go and defend himself before the judicial commission of inquiry sitting in the state. Wike, who was reacting to Amaechi’s declaration on Saturday that he (Amaechi) would not appear before the Justice George Omereji-led panel of inquiry, said it was wrong for the former governor to describe the commission as illegal even when the court had ruled that the panel was in order.

Presidency Responds To Jonathan’s Ex Ministers

In a statement signed by the Senior Special Assistant to the President on Media and Publicity, Mallam  Garba Shehu, the Presidency asked the Association of Ex-Jonathan Ministers to do a bit of self-reflection on the sort of government they handed to President Muhammadu Buhari back in May to determine for themselves if it would have been right for any incoming government, not just this one to ignore the issue of the brazen theft of public assets, perhaps...

Saraki Leads Delegation To 4th UN Conference Of Parliamentary Heads

Senate President, Dr. Abubakar Bukola Saraki,  will today lead Nigerian delegation to  participate in the 4th United Nations Conference of Parliamentary Heads holding at the  organisation’s headquarters in New York, United States. This year’s conference which will be declared open by the United Nations Secretary-General, Mr. Ban  Ki-moon, will feature presentation of reports and general debate on “placing democracy at the  service of peace and sustainable development.” Other issues billed for debate include; “Challenges facing Parliaments today”,...

8,000 Nigerian Refugees In Cameroon, Chad, Niger

The Director General of the National Emergency Management Agency, Muhammed Sidi, at the African Union Regional Consultative Meeting for West Africa in Abuja, disclosed that about 58,000 Nigerians displaced by the Boko Haram insurgency in North-East Nigeria are taking refuge in neighbouring Cameroon, Niger and Chad. The consultative panel was slated for the development of a common African position for the World Humanitarian Summit. Mr. Sidi said there were about 57,743 Nigerian refugees in Cameroun,...

How Pilots, Toddler, Officers’ Wives Died

Hours after the ill-fated Nigerian Air Force (NAF) Donnier-228 aircraft crashed shortly after it took off, it was exclusively gathered that three of the civilians on board were wives of Air Force personnel and a toddler. The aircraft, with call sign NAF030, had on Saturday morning crashed into a house at Ribadu Cantonment, Kaduna killing all seven people on board. Before the plane crashed, the Abuja-bound aircraft, which took off from Kaduna military airfield at...

Boko Haram Kill 56 People In Fresh Attack On Villagers In Borno State

Islamic extremist group Boko Haram killed 56 villagers in a remote area, the governor of Borno State of the region said, as the government warned that the extremists are trying to extend their violent campaign. Gov. Kashim Shettima confirmed the attack in Baanu village during a meeting with the parents of the 219 girls abducted from a school in the region by the extremists last year. Thursday marked 500 days of captivity of the...

Obasanjo Is A Traitor Who Likes Nobody, Gani Adams Fires At Ex-President

The National Coordinator of the Oo’dua Peoples Congress, Mr. Gani Adams, in an interview with TOBI AWORINDE has also condemned a former president of Nigeria, Olusegun Obasanjo, saying he does things to satisfy his own personal interest and has no interest of anyone at heart. He said a lot and even mentioned the names of some people the president has fought. Part of the interview below... During the Goodluck Jonathan administration, ex-President Olusegun Obasanjo displayed a...

Boko Haram Suicide Bomb Coordinator, Other Front Line Members Arrested By DSS

The Department of Security Service has arrested 21 alleged commanders and front-line members of the Boko Haram terrorist group including the group's suicide bomb attacks coordinator. A statement signed by Mr Tony Opuiyo, DSS spokesperson, states that the sect members were arrested in different parts of the country from July 8th to August 25th. "They include those allegedly responsible for the coordination and execution of the suicide attacks in Potiskum, Kano, Zaria and Jos who were arrested...