Open letter to lawmakers on state creation – by Niyi Akinnaso (niyi@comcast.net)

Published:6 Nov, 2012

Open letter to lawmakers on state creation – by Niyi Akinnaso

Dear legislators,

Please, do not create more states. This is an appeal on behalf of millions of fellow Nigerians, particularly those whose voices may not be heard on this matter. To those among you who find the creation of additional states a preposterous venture, I applaud you. To those who have vested interests in creating fiefdoms for themselves after leaving the National Assembly or in fulfilling promises made earlier to traditional rulers and other petitioners demanding states of their own, I say, look beyond parochial interests. Look at the big picture. Do the right thing: Drop the idea of creating more states for various reasons stated below. There are far more important problems to be solved, including corruption, security, and infrastructural deficits than embarking on that voyage of fantasy.

My appeal also goes to the agitators for the creation of more states. From all indications, the 56 or so petitions came largely from groups which have suffered limited access to power within their present states. The problem with the petitions is that they are from the elite, without grass-roots input, which is why the Nigeria Bar Association suggested a referendum on the matter. Nevertheless, I fully understand the plight of minorities in the hands of hegemonic majorities within the existing states as well as their struggle for equity and social justice. I remember once being told by a professional colleague that my Yoruba was not “pure” because it was tainted by my native Idanre dialect. I told the fellow that he would have been taught my dialect in school had Bishop Ajayi Crowther based Yoruba orthography on it. But my response did not remove the dual feeling of inadequacy and unequal treatment as a result of my native dialect.

However, the creation of a new orthography based on Idanre dialect will not solve my problem, just as the creation of additional states for minorities locked within the existing states is not the right solution. Any government would be foolhardy to allow the development of a dialect-based orthography to function in public schools, partly because of costs and partly because of its political implications. Speakers of other Yoruba dialects may want to develop orthographies for their dialects in reaction to the hegemony of the Oyo dialect.

A short trip down memory lane will show how the orthography analogy applies to the creation of states. The balkanisation of the federation through the creation of states began as a Northern reaction to Gen. J.T.U. Aguiyi Ironsi’s Decree 34, which abrogated the federal structure in favour of a “unitary” system in which the centre became much more powerful than ever before. Ironsi’s action was interpreted by Northerners within the context of an Igbo-led coup in which two Northern icons, the Sardauna of Sokoto, Alhaji Ahmadu Bello, and Sir Abubakar Tawafa Balewa (then Prime Minister), were killed; but no Igbo politician was. Yet, the Igbo turned out to be the major beneficiaries of the coup. (Then) Lt. Col. Yakubu Gowon, who succeeded Ironsi after a coup that eliminated him, kept the strong centre but created 12 states to diffuse Ironsi’s unitary system. And that was the beginning of the agitation by minorities locked in the big states for the creation of their own states. As the government responded to their demands, the number of states kept increasing until we arrived at the present 36-state structure.

So, my dear legislators, the above summary is the origin of the 56 petitions before you today. There are many reasons why the creation of more states is neither a viable project nor a reasonable action to take at this time. First and foremost is the issue of viability. It is common knowledge that a number of the existing states are under distress. Inadequate capital and the lack of necessary infrastructure continue to hamper their ability to establish job-creating institutions, attract manufacturing industries, and facilitate the growth of small businesses. In the absence of job creators such as these, state governments became the largest employers of labour. This is particularly true of states such as Kano, Katsina, Niger, Osun, Sokoto, and Zamfara which spend 50 per cent and above of their gross annual revenue on a small percentage of the population, consisting of elected officials, political appointees, and civil service personnel.

To complicate matters, many of the existing 36 states are deficient in raising enough internally generated revenue to supplement their Federal allocations. The result is a recourse to local banks for short-term loans and to the capital market for long-term loans to finance capital projects. That’s not all. According to the Revenue Mobilisation Allocation and Fiscal Commission earlier this year, the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory were under a $2.165bn (about N339.9bn) foreign debt. The cumulative effect of these developments is diminished capacity to finance developmental projects. The critical question then is: By what magic will newly created states sidestep this conundrum?

The argument that the creation of new states will bring the government closer to the people falls flat in the face of extant realities highlighted by limited financial capacity, as illustrated above. Even more importantly, such an argument ignores the existence of 774 Local Government Areas across the country, whose function is precisely to bring government closer to the people, yet no real development has been seen even to the communities near the council headquarters. This immediately highlights an important issue that needs attention—the strengthening of the local governments to ensure equitable distribution of positions and resources within existing states.

By the way, did any of you ever think of the implications of the creation of additional states for the intensification of identity politics, which underlies the ongoing political and security crises in the country? How many more states will you create to satisfy all the nationalities in the country? What difference is there between a sub-ethnic or geographically contiguous group demanding a new state and a Northern Hausa-Fulani or South-Eastern Ndigbo group demanding the Presidency in 2015?

The more expedient way to respond to identity politics is not through the creation of further divisions but through various means of drawing upon the strengths of diversity by making various groups work together. This is why a national conference, which you have ignored, would have been useful in bringing various nationalities to the table to work out how they could work together as one nation. All we’ve had so far is a country, not a nation.

If your interest is not in expanding the corruption dragnet, which has enveloped many of the existing states and Local Governments, then you would desist from creating additional states and focus on tightening corruption loopholes and getting more resources to Local Governments. But if you insist on going ahead, concerned citizens will do well to mobilise protests against the move.

 

Niyi Akinnaso (niyi@comcast.net)

Related Posts

Recent Posts

“Dogara Tried Breaking Into My Office To Discard Evidence” – Jibrin

A former chairman of House Committee on Appropriation, Abdulmumin Jibrin, on Thursday said unnamed individuals acting on the orders of Speaker, Yakubu Dogara, had moved computers used by officials of the committee.   Mr. Jibrin has accused the speaker of budget fraud, an allegation Mr. Dogara denies.   In a statement Thursday, Mr. Jibrin said there was also an attempt to burgle his office, saying all the systems were shut down.   “Speaker Dogara has ordered that all the computers in the appropriation secretariat be...

Bastian Schweinsteiger Retires From International Football

The midfielder brings an end to a 12-year spell with the Germany national team, during which he won the World Cup and picked up a silver medal from the European Championship Manchester United midfielder Bastian Schweinsteiger has announced his retirement from international football after making 120 appearances for Germany. The 31-year-old is one of his country's most capped players and featured in five games for Die Mannschaft at Euro 2016 as...

President Buhari Reopens ABUJA Airport Runway After Renovation.

The federal government has reopened the runway of the Nnamdi Azikiwe International Airport, Abuja for the landing of all kinds of aircraft.   The minister of state for Aviation, Hadi Sirika, who stated this yesterday, while inspecting the airport, said the runway was opened after the successful completion of the renovation work that had been going on there.   While calling for the return of full business to the airport, the minister noted that with the completion of repairs in the...

Hollywood Star Launches Scholarship for Terrorized Nigerian Girls

Oprah Winfrey is also the scholarship’s major seed funder, which Oyelowo hopes is a step towards combatting cultural and gender inequality. David Oyelowo (Selma, Queen of Katwe) is paving a way for three Nigerian girls to continue their education with the announcement of a scholarship in his name starting this year. The David Oyelowo Leadership Scholarship stems from the actor’s close partnership with the GEANCO Foundation, a Los Angeles-based non-profit organization...

WikiLeaks Releases Hacked Voicemail Recordings Of The DNC Days After They Released Nearly 20,000 DNC Emails

Days after WikiLeaks hacked into the US Democratic National Committee (DNC) emails and released their private email communication, they released voicemails of the DNC. The voicemails are related to the batch of about 20,000 leaked emails WikiLeaks published earlier this week, which revealed that people within the supposedly neutral DNC were in fact working to help Hillary Clinton secure the Democratic nomination against Bernie Sanders. According to CNN: Wikileaks released a series of voicemails Wednesday from the Democratic National Committee...

Britain’s Biggest Nuclear Family Welcome 19th Baby, And They’re Not Ruling Out 20

We first read about this family years ago when the children were 'just' 15. i am sure we are all now therefore shocked that they have added 4 more to the brood. Childhood sweethearts Sue and Noel Radford, from Lancashire, welcomed Phoebe Willow earlier this month, joining her 9 brothers and 9 sisters. Sue got pregnant with their first child, Chris, 27, at the age of just 14 and since then she has been popping them out on an...

Ijaw Militants Hit As Heavy Military Bombardment Begins At Arepo Creeks, Other Parts of Lagos.

There was pandemonium on Thursday in the Arepo area of Ogun State and some part of Lagos State after the military bombarded the base of suspected militants in the states.   The PUNCH learnt that scores of militants were reportedly killed in the joint military operation which lasted for more than one hour.   A source said the military attacked Fatola, the base of the militants, adding that houses around the area were shaken by the impact of bomb explosions on the Ijaw...

Failed Coup: President Erdogan To Close 17 Turkish Schools In Nigeria

Ripples of July 15 botched coup in Turkey have berthed in Nigeria with the Turkish Ambassador to Nigeria, Hakan Cakil, urging the Federal Government to shut  17 Turkish schools in Nigeria.   The ambassador, who made the call when the vice chairman, Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs, Shehu Sani, paid him a courtesy visit, said the Turkish Government had nothing to do with the schools. The ambassador said investigations by the Turkish government showed that a movement led by US-based Fethullah Gulen...

Our Convention Will Go On As Scheduled Despite The Illegality – PDP

Okon Abang, a judge of the federal high court in Abuja had earlier ruled that the caretaker committee was illegal and could not conduct any function on behalf of the party.   But in a statement issued on Thursday, Dayo Adeyeye, spokesman of the committee, accused Abang of “deliberately” engaging in acts capable of derailing the country’s democracy.   “We have just received information that Justice Okon Abang of the federal high court in Abuja has granted an order of interlocutory injunction stopping...

Stronger Together – Full Text Of Hillary Clinton’s Speech At The Democratic National Convention

Thank you! Thank you for that amazing welcome. And Chelsea, thank you. I'm so proud to be your mother and so proud of the woman you've become. Thanks for bringing Marc into our family, and Charlotte and Aidan into the world. And Bill, that conversation we started in the law library 45 years ago is still going strong. It's lasted through good times that filled us with joy, and hard times that tested us. And I've even gotten a few words in along the way. On...

#SaveMayowa Is Not A Scam – Family

The family of Mayowa Ahmed has denied claims its fund raiser to fly the University of Lagos graduate abroad for cancer surgery was not a scam.   The family had raised $100,847 via crowdfunding site gofundme.com, backed by popular Nigerians, including actress Toyin Aimakhu.   Additional donations, reportedly running into millions were also received via a bank account provided by her family.   However, on Thursday, Blogger Linda Ikeji reported that...

Mikel Denies Donating $30,000 To Dream Team

Captain of Team Nigeria to the Rio Olympics, John Mikel Obi has denied media reports making the rounds in Nigeria that he gave $30,000 dollars to his teammates in the U23 football team. Speaking from the team’s camp at the Hyatt Place in Atlanta, USA, Mikel said, “I was first told of this unfortunate story by a friend who called me from Nigeria. I thought he was joking until he sent me the link. “I...

Rotimi Amaechi Challenges Nigerians To Hold Govt Accountable, Demand Answers

The Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Mr Abubakar Malami, has said that Nigeria has received a fresh boost in the fight against corruption.This came as the Minister of Transportation, Mr Rotimi Amaechi, challenged Nigerians to hold government accountable by asking relevant questions and demanding satisfactory answers. Malami made this known at a stakeholders meeting on the London summit on anti-corruption and the Open Government Partnership (OGP) in Abuja on Wednesday. He said the country...

FUTA Suspends Four Students Involved In Alleged N16m Internet Fraud

The Federal University of Technology Akure (FUTA) has indefinitely suspended four students of the institution, who were arrested by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) for the roles they played in an alleged N16 million Internet fraud. Out of the five suspected undergraduate scammers that were arrested, 4 are from (FUTA) while 1 is from Adekunle Ajashin University, Akungba. They allegedly swindled unsuspecting foreigners and others to the tune of N16M by engaging in fraudulent activities...

Fix The Economy Now, Gowon Tells President Buhari

Former Head of state , General Yakubu Gowon (retd), yesterday, took a retrospective look at the situation in the country and asked President Muhammadu Buhari to ensure that the country’s economy regain its strength to alleviate the suffering of the masses. Gen. Gowon Gowon spoke at Ile-Ife at a programme, Health Caravan and Award ceremony for the Ooni of Ife, Oba Enitan Ogunwusi, who was conferred with the Royal Ambassador for Hepatitis Advocacy in Nigeria by the Seham...

Saraki, Akpabio, Daniel, Odili, Ladoja Included In AGF’s List For Fresh Probe, Trial

Senate President Bukola Saraki, factional Chairman of the Peoples Democratic Party, Ali Modu Sheriff; and Senate Minority Leader, Godswill Akpabio, are among 31 former governors whose alleged corruption cases investigated by the anti-graft agencies are likely to be reopened soon. The PUNCH had exclusively reported on Tuesday that the Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Mr. Abubakar Malami, had written to the Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices and other related Offences Commission, directing the reopening of...

Photos From Requiem Mass For Former Super Eagles Coach, Stephen Keshi

The Funeral rites of former Super Eagles coach Stephen Keshi has commenced with a a requiem mass currently holding at the St Paul's Catholic Church in Benin City, Edo state. His children, family members, Football enthusiasts and others are attending the mass. More photos below...          

Woman Caught On CCTV Dumping Her Baby Just Two Hours After Giving Birth

20-year-old woman has been arrested for allegedly dumping her two-hour-old newborn baby inside a plastic bag and running away.  She abandoned her baby in a pink plastic bag that was later spotted by shocked locals in Wangjiaoqiao village, south-west China. The child whose gender was not revealed, was rushed to hospital by police for emergency treatment but did not survive. In an attempt to find her, Investigators...

Senegalese footballer, Demba Ba Returns Home After Undergoing Leg Surgery

Senegalese footballer Demba Ba has returned home after he had a surgery for his broken leg. Demba suffered a horrendous leg-break on Sunday July 17th during a match with his team, Shanghai Shenhua against bitter rivals Shanghai SIPG. Sharing this new photo on his IG page, Demba wrote   "Feels good to be back home after 10 days at the hospital. Thanks once again to everyone single one of you guys in every corner of the world . I feel...

Elle Magazine Features Omotola As One Of 50 Women Shaping Africa

Elle magazine SA in its August Edition featured 50 Outstanding women shaping the Continent and names them #TheIncredibles. In an Article put together by International writer Dimeji Alara, the careful selection was made from different works of life and ages, mostly for their leading positive influences on the continent. Also on the list are  Supermodel Liya kedebe, writer Chimamanda Adichie, Style House files MD Omoyemi Akerele, film director Mildred Okwo and many...

SHOCKING!! [Video] Pope Francis Falls Over During Mass In Front Of Worshippers

This is the moment Pope Francis fell over during Mass in front of a television audience of millions while visiting Poland's holiest site. The 79-year-old Pontiff stumbled at the altar and had to be helped to his feet as he celebrated a Mass at the at the Jasna Gora Monastery in the southern city of Czestochowa. He was at the monastery, home to an ancient Catholic icon believed to work miracles, ahead...