Of Probes and Government’s Lack of Political Will – Adewale Kupoluyi

Published:18 Nov, 2012

Of Probes and Government’s Lack of Political Will – Adewale Kupoluyi

The nation’s yearning for development may continue to be an illusion as long as we are not ready to learn from our past mistakes.

Whenever one hears of committees or probe panels being set up to investigate some activities, what readily comes to mind is either — politics at play or nothing would come out of it.

Before the return to democratic rule, Nigerians used to take the failures of implementation of probe panel reports as part of the outcome of military dictatorship but events have shown that this is not so.

This worrisome trend is neither limited to the Executive arm of government nor the Jonathan administration — and if care is not taken — it may continue to be a burden the nation will live with.

The latest of such disdain for public reports is the alleged moves to discredit the submission by the Petroleum Revenue Special Task Force, headed by Mallam Nuhu Ribadu.

The drama began at the presentation of the report at the State House, Abuja, when Steve Oronsaye, deputy chairman of the task force and Ben Otti, another member of the 17-member committee tried, in a futile bid, to discredit the report. They claimed that they were not privy to the final draft being tendered.

The committee produced the 146-page document, based on the request by the Ministry of Petroleum Resources, covering 10 years     — 2002 to 2012.

According to the report, Nigeria had lost tens of billions of dollars in oil and gas income over the last decade from shady deals struck between multinational oil companies and government officials.

The report alleged that foreign oil traders often bought crude without any formal contracts, and that the state oil firm had short-changed the nation’s treasury by selling gas and crude oil to itself below market rates without any transparency.

The task force also found anomalies ranging from about $183m in signature bonuses for oil bloc licences not accounted for and $3.02 bn as unpaid royalties, theft of up to 250,000 barrels of crude per day and fraud by the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation in converting its dollar earnings to naira.

Discrediting the report, presidential spokesman, Doyin Okupe, had said “an obvious DISCLAIMER (emphasis mine) issued by the committee on the entire report, makes it impossible under our laws to indict or punish anyone except, and until, the Federal Government fully verifies and reconciles the facts as recommended by the committee in its submission to the government.”

Okupe also criticised part of the report which says, “Due to the time frame of the assignment, some of the data used could not be independently verified and the task force recommends that the government should conduct such necessary verifications and reconciliations.”

He blamed Ribadu for the politicisation of the report and claimed that it was a calculated attempt to overheat the polity and incite Nigerians against President Goodluck Jonathan.

Over the years, findings of many panels and committees have not been made useful to the nation, resulting into wastage of material resources and man-hours.

A very few examples suffice: Following the violence that trailed the 2011 general elections in the country, over 900 persons were said to have lost their lives. President Jonathan inaugurated a 22-man panel of enquiry, headed by Sheikh Ahmed Lemu, to look at the incident and make recommendations on how to forestall a recurrence.

On October 10, 2011, the investigation panel submitted its report and advised that “the first and probably the most important major cause (of violence) is the failure on the part of the previous successive regimes, since the military handover of power in 1999, to implement the recommendations of various committees, commissions and panels that had taken place in our nation.”

The panel also called for the implementation of the Babalakin Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Bauchi State Civil Disturbances, Justice Snakey Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Wase and Langtang Disturbances and Justice Uwais Electoral Reform Committee, Karibi Whyte Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Kafanchan Disturbances, Professor Tamuno Panel of Inquiry on National Security, Niki Tobi Judicial Commission of Inquiry and Justice Disu Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Plateau State Disturbances.

Several Judicial Commissions of Inquiry had been set up by both the Federal and the Plateau State governments, to investigate the Jos crises but unfortunately, many of these reports were not made public or the culprits made accountable.

The denial of the public’s right to know the content of these reports by successive governments had provided moral grounds for speculations, distrust, and disregard for constituted authorities which significantly contributed towards escalating the crises that had led to wanton destruction of lives and property.

Another of such hibernated reports is the Steve Oronsaye Committee on the restructuring of Ministries, Departments and Agencies.

The Oronsaye panel recommended that government should reduce its over-bloated statutory agencies from 263 to 161 and also called for the abolition of 38 agencies, merger of 52 and reversion of 14 agencies to departments in the relevant ministries. Again, nothing concrete has been done to the report after its submission to the President.

The Ndudi Elumelu-led House of Representatives Committee on Power and Steel set up to investigate the alleged $16bn expenditure in the power sector, the Farouk Lawan-led House Ad hoc Committee on Fuel Subsidy Management and the Nigeria Stock Exchange probe headed by Ibrahim El-Sudi, and the N6.2bn SIM cards registration probe had some reports that generated serious debates but are idling away.

In June 1999, former President Olusegun Obasanjo’s administration set up the Human Rights Violations Investigation Panel, popularly known as the Oputa Panel to review the human rights abuses experienced during previous military regimes.

While the panel worked assiduously according to its mandate, nothing came out of its report, as some powerful Nigerians even sought court orders to stop its proceedings.

Halliburton had sacked its top executive, Albert Stanley, for allegedly bribing senior Nigerian government officials with about US$180million to win Nigerian Liquefied Natural Gas contracts in the late 1990s.

While the Federal Government set up a probe panel, headed by the former Inspector-General of Police, Mike Okiro, to investigate the case, the Senate and the House of Representatives separately also probed the incident.

Till date, no result has come from the probes and nobody was ever prosecuted from the outcome of the probes even when other foreign countries had sanctioned those indicted in the Halliburton scandal.

The report of highly celebrated Dr. Pius Okigbo-led panel went the same way. The panel was meant to probe the Gulf War period oil receipts. The full report, submitted on September 27, 1994, never saw the light of day, and was declared “missing” from records till date.

The failure to implement previous reports has been attributed to the lack of political will on the part of government in bringing about a change.

It should be appreciated that probing is a core part of governance and public office management. It is a modern tool used all over the world to get to the roots of problems, not necessarily for witch-hunting.

– Adewale Kupoluyi writes from the Federal University of Agriculture, Abeokuta, vide adewalekupoluyi@yahoo.co.uk

  • Shittu A. Saheed

    We still have to wait for an action govt that will come n implement white papers’ cos if we expect any from this very one headed by GEJ,we will wait till thy kingdom come.

Related Posts

Recent Posts

CBN Re-instates Banks Banned From Foreign Exchange Market

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has re-instated all the banks that were banned from the foreign exchange market, the Director, Banking Supervision, Mrs Tokunbo Martins, has said. She said this on Wednesday in Abuja at a media briefing, stating that the decision was reached after a series of meetings with the body of bank Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) and the Chartered Institute of Bankers of Nigeria (CIBN). “Well, we have had engagements with the...

FEC Approves 3 Year External Borrowing Plan

The Federal Executive Council (FEC) on Wednesday approved a three-year external borrowing plan. Finance Minister Kemi Adeosun told State House reporters after the FEC meeting chaired by President Muhammadu Buhari that the borrowing plan would run from 2016 to 2019. The minister said the plan would be transmitted to the National Assembly for approval. She listed the benefiting sectors as power, solid minerals and agriculture. She said $150 million would go into power sector...

Five Day Old Twins Among 6,500 Migrants Rescued From Mediterranean Sea

Five-day-old twins were among 6,500 refugees and migrants rescued yesterday off the Libyan coast while attempting to reach Italy via the Mediterranean Sea. The twins were traveling with their mother before they were rescued by Italian coastguard and airlifted to an Italian hospital, according to Médecins Sans Frontières’ (MSF) also known as Doctors without borders, which took part in the operations. MSF ship Dignity 1 and the Spanish humanitarian group Proactiva Open Arms rescued the refugees and migrants believed...

Boko Haram Ready To Announce Chibok Girls’ Whereabouts In 24hours– Aisha Wakil

One of the individuals who is alleged to have strong connection and vital information on Boko Haram insurgency, Aisha Alkali Wakil, has on Wednesday, revealed that the Boko Haram terrorist group has accepted the peace move and now ready to make announcement on the whereabouts of the abducted chikbok girls in the next 24 hours. Wakil was one of the individuals earlier declared wanted by the Nigerian Army for concealing information on the whereabouts of the...

Buhari Signs N241.5b FCT Budget

President Muhammadu Buhari has signed the 2016 Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Abuja Appropriation Act, the Senior Special Assistant to the President on National Assembly Matters, Senator Ita Enang, has said. Enang said President Buhari assented to N241.5 billion 2016 FCT budget as passed by the National Assembly. A statement issued by the presidential aide did not however say when the fiscal document was signed. Enang said “The legal implantation of the budget, therefore comes...

Presidency List Gains Of Buhari’s Participation At TICAD

The presidency has listed the gains of President Muhammadu Buhari’s participation in the just concluded Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD VI) to include the billions of dollar to be injected into African economies by Japan. A statement issued in Abuja yesterday by the Senior Special Assistant on Media and Publicity to the president, Garba Shehu, said the Japanese Government had pledged to expend 40 billion dollars to boost the African economies in the next four years. He gave the...

Rivers: Wike’s Deputy Defends Amnesty For Criminals

The Rivers Government says it has no regrets initiating the ongoing amnesty programme for repentant cultists and criminals in the state. The Deputy Governor, Dr Ipalibo Banigo, told newsmen in Port Harcourt on Wednesday that the programme was in line with the peace initiative of the state government. The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the amnesty programme came under attack recently when some analysts described it as a measure to shield supporters of the state government. The analysts asked the...

Economy Will Be Better In Remaining Part Of 2016- FG

The Presidency has said that the nation’s economic ?outlook remains bright notwithstanding the drop in Nigeria’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP). In a statement issued in Abuja on Tuesday by the Senior Special Assistant to the Vice President on Media and Publicity, Mr Laolu Akande, the Federal Government said the remaining part of the year would be better. The National Bureau of Statistics on Wednesday released...

Man Abducts Teenage Girl, Turns Her To Sex Slave In Lagos

A 55-year-old man, Yekini Ogunjobi, who allegedly abducted a teenage girl for several days and assaulted her sexually, was on Wednesday in Lagos released on a N100, 000 bail. Police have pressed abduction and sexual assault charges at an Ikeja Chief Magistrates’ Court against the security man, who lives at 12, Esuola St., Oko-Oba, Agege, a suburb of Lagos.Prosecutor Rafael Donny told the court that the offences were committed between July 25 and July 28 at...

EU Split One Year After Merkel Migrant Offer

One year since Germany controversially opened its arms to Syrians fleeing war, the EU has tightened the borders of “Fortress Europe” but remains deeply divided over how to share the refugee burden. Angela Merkel justified her decision at the time by saying that the biggest migrant crisis since World War II “did not reflect well on Europe”, yet other countries furiously accused her of opening the floodgates. Since last year when one million migrants entered...

Facebook To Embrace More Nigerian Languages- Zuckerberg

The founder of Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg, has pledged to use more Nigerian languages in offering services on Facebook. Zuckerberg, who is currently on a business visit to Nigeria, made the promise at a meeting with software developers and ICT entrepreneurs on Wednesday in Lagos. He said the social media platform currently allows the use of Hausa language on Facebook. “I am glad we support Hausa and we are planning on supporting a lot more...

Nigeria Officially In Recession, GDP Growth Drops To -2.06%

The National Bureau of Statistics on Wednesday released the much-awaited Gross Domestic Product figures for the second quarter of 2016 with the GDP growth rate sliding further from -0.36 per cent in the first quarter to -2.06 per cent year-on-year. The negative growth rate recorded in the second quarter of this year is a confirmation of the predictions by the Federal Government and economists that the country was heading into recession. A recession is defined...

Ghana May Impeach President Over Car ‘Gift’

Three months to Ghana’s general elections, the country’s parliament has initiated moves to impeach President John Mahama.   Though the legislators are on recess, the Speaker, Joe Adjaho, has recalled them for resumption Thursday, September 1, to begin debate on the issue.   The President is alleged to have received an expensive car (Ford) as ‘gift’ from a contractor and national of Burkina Faso.   Opposition parties and a cross section of Ghanaians, however, insist the present was a bribe. The country’s constitution bars a sitting...

FG Receives N18.99 Billion NNPC’s Refund

The Federal Government received N18.99 billion from the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) during the second quarter of 2016, being installmental refund of the corporation’s indebtedness to the government.   The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), which made this disclosure in its second quarter report, added that the sum of N7.86 billion was equally distributed as exchange gain among the three tiers of government as 13 per cent Derivation Fund.   A breakdown of the allocation showed that Federal Government received N3.68 billion;...

ZTE Launches Technology Devices In Nigerian Market

To ensure that Nigerian market gets the best quality, affordable, unique, classy, easily accessible phones for its consumers, ZTE Technology has stepped in to meet these needs.   Speaking at a news conference weekend, in Lagos, to kick off ZTE’S Open Market Operations in Nigeria, organised by its media partners, Devset Mobile Services Limited, ZTE VP Mideast and West Africa, Xiang Pingnianm, said: “Every year, new technology meets forward thinking. We have seen many technology devices that keep pushing the boundaries...

Politics: In Rivers, It’s A Game Of Death.

I’m not used to too much prayer, but I must begin today’s piece with a word of prayer. I pray that God Almighty visits the killers of Barr. Ken Atsuwete (and their sponsors) with slow and painful death. Amen!   I pray that the divine punishment for the dastardly act of Monday constitutes the largest chunk of the inheritance, which the killers (and their sponsors) would pass on to their children and their children’s children in the fullness of time. Amen...

Pension Assets Hit N5.8tn As PenCom Seeks To Invest 40% In Infrastructure

The Director-General of the National Pension Commission (PenCom), Ms. Chinelo Anohu-Amazu, on Tuesday hinted that the total pension assets had hit N5.8 trillion, adding that the commission was targeting to invest 40 per cent of the funds in infrastructure and housing by 2019.   She was, however, quick to add that the safety of such investments would not be compromised, as they would require guarantees from government and stakeholders.   She said currently, 15 per cent of the assets are invested in infrastructure...

Why Team Nigeria Performed Poorly In Rio – Dalung

What appears another major controversy over the employment of German tactician, Gernot Rohr, to manage the Super Eagles cropped up yesterday following a declaration by Sports Minister, Solomon Dalung, that he knew nothing about the deal. ?? Recall that the Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) recently selected Rohr to manage the Super Eagles despite the minister’s preference for a local coach.   Dalung was at the State House yesterday, Abuja to brief President Muhammadu Buhari on the nation’s outing at the ?just concluded Olympics...

Osinbajo Urges Youths To Key Into Multi-tasking Age To Remain Relevant

Vice President Yemi Osinbajo on Tuesday advised Nigerian youths to see the present age as one that offers them an opportunity to embrace “multi-tasking”. He gave the advice while opening a two-day Google Digital Training programme for Youth Employment with the theme: “Diversifying the Nigerian Economy: Enabling Youth through Digital Skills Training’’. Osinbajo said that the opportunities abound for professionals with multi skills to excel in the period of economic hardship and joblessness, adding that innovation was the best way to...

Turkey Denies Reaching Ceasefire With Kurdish Forces

A Turkish minister has said that his country does “not accept” US claims that its military has reached a ceasefire deal with Kurdish fighters in northern Syria. The statement came after US officials said that Turkish-backed Syrian rebels and Kurdish forces had agreed on a temporary pause in fighting in northern Syria. The US has been warning the sides to focus on fighting the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) group elements there. “We do not accept in any circumstances...

I Am Not The Problem Of Nigerian Sports – Dalung

Sports Minister, Solomon Dalung, has fired back at those calling for his sack following the country’s poor outing at the 2016 Olympic Games and says he is not the problem.   Dalung was speaking to State House correspondents, after meeting with President Muhammadu Buhari to review the Olympics, where Nigeria finished with only one bronze medal.   He argued that poor performances have always been the case with Nigeria, even before he was appointed. “I am not the problem of Nigerian sports. Abysmal performance...