Jonathan and the $31bn Question By Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai

Published:30 Nov, 2012

Jonathan and the $31bn Question
By Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai

When I wrote an article in 2011, stating that the government of President Goodluck Jonathan was spending two billion naira every day, including weekends, on security without commensurate returns on the lives of Nigerians, the president’s reaction was to have his then chief goon, General Awoye Azazi, arrest and detain me for publishing ‘misleading information’. In retrospect, I agree with the accusation – because the amount I stated hugely understated the grand larceny going on in government.

An opening into what is really going on in government was provided a few days back by the Punch newspaper, which found that a staggering 5 trillion naira – or $31bn has been stolen under Jonathan’s 30-month stewardship of our nation’s affairs.

Assuming that Jonathan has been in power since May 2010, that works out to an incredulous $1bn stolen each month. If you add the average borrowing of another $1bn per month since Jonathan took office, then the true scale of the epic theft becomes clearer.

President Jonathan is making a mockery of himself if he continues to insist his government is determined to fight corruption, or that Nigeria under his watch has not finally lost the war on graft. It is no accident that Nigeria is perceived as the second most corrupt country in the world by a recent Gallup poll. According to International audit firm KPMG, the cost of fraud in the first half of 2012 alone is $1.5bn (N225bn), the highest on the African continent. And that is only because they have no real idea of what is going on in government circles While Nigeria is ranked third behind USA and China in backlogs of orders for personal private jets, the Economic Intelligence Unit (EIU) asserted that our nation is the worst place to be in 2013 due to deteriorating indicators of human security..

One day, we read that billions of naira of pension funds have been stolen, and the next, it becomes trillions of unbudgeted fuel subsidy monies. It seems Nigerians have simply gotten numb to these figures, or have not appreciated the opportunity cost of the sums being stolen in terms of goods and services forgone. To put things in context, if one spends one hundred thousand naira daily, it will take about 53 years to spend one billion naira! A billion dollars is of course some 150 billion naira, so go ahead and do the math.

In short, what would $31bn do for Nigeria or Nigerians? For a person who lives for 100 years, he would have to spend the sum of $310m dollars a year for an entire century – near a million dollars a day, weekends included to finish it all. And if he decides to join the league of private jet owners, that amount would purchase 1,550 planes at an average cost of $20m each.

If the funds were to be used to finance the operations of the Nigerian government, the $31bn sum effectively covers Nigeria’s N4.8trn 2012 budget with a leftover of about N200bn. And is only less than N1 billion short of the proposed N4.92trn budget for 2013. From another perspective, according to an MoU signed by government this year, 6 refineries would be constructed in modular forms within 30 months at a cost of $4.5bn. Each refinery would process 30,000 barrels of crude per day with an output of 5 million litres of gasoline. This means that with $31bn about 41 new refineries can be built.

The immediate implications of that are: the very volatile fuel scarcity situation existing all over Nigeria would be solved. And hundreds of billions of naira that are ordinarily stolen annually in the guise of fuel importation would be saved. Similarly, of the 41 refineries, one would be sited in every Nigerian state, with an extra five clustered or evenly distributed around larger consumption centres like Lagos, Ibadan, Kano and Abuja. There is simply no telling how many jobs this would create for Nigeria’s tens of millions of unemployed citizens.

And speaking of employment, some of the decisions by this government are simply confounding because the MoU for the refineries indicated that 6 months of construction work will be done in America, followed by one month of test-running and dismantling of the refinery. Another month is provided for transporting the dismantled refinery, and an extra 4 months to reassemble the plant and commence production. Not one Nigerian job will be created in the construction of the refineries for which $4.5bn was to be spent! And like everything with this hapless administration, nothing has been heard of the construction of these modular refineries, only a report of yet another committee on refineries.

The design and construction of rail services in Abuja which the Obasanjo administration awarded in 2007 and due to have been completed in 2010 was recently “re-approved” by the Federal Executive Council for about the same it was originally awarded – some $823m, less than a billion dollars. The vanished $31bn would have conveniently provided a project similar to the Abuja light rail system for 32 of our 36 states. Imagine the jobs we would have created, the savings on road repairs, reduction in accidents, cost of transportation and improvement in the standards of living we would have had.

Similarly, what became the Primus Specialist Hospital in Abuja, was awarded for less than N5 billion by the FCT Administration, and reportedly finally completed at multiples of the original price. Assuming it would cost N100 billion to build and equip such a facility, it would mean that if the looted $31bn was channelled into healthcare, it would have comfortably built about 31 hospitals of that calibre. And if it had not been inflated, the same amount might have built a world class hospital in every state capital with the best equipment anywhere. Incidentally, the First Lady would not have had to go to any German hospital for any reason. Nigeria would also have saved the N450 billion we lose annually, travelling overseas for medical treatment.

In the last two fiscal years, less than N20 billion have been budgeted annually for the capital needs of all federal universities. Between 2004 and 2007, the FCT administration and the Petroleum Technology Development Fund contributed about 200 hectares of land plus $10 million, and $25 million respectively as virtually sole contribution to the set-up of the African University of Science and Technology (AUST), Abuja. With the stolen funds, the federal government would have financed the capital programmes of all federal universities for some 250 years! And if the same funds were applied to building new universities, we could easily have got at least 60 AUST- like institutions up and running all across the country.

From every perspective one looks at it, the amount of stolen funds would have improved the lives of Nigerians: if the $31bn had been invested in road construction, Nigeria would have emerged with one of the best road networks in all of Africa; even at the reported N89.53bn at which the Lagos Ibadan expressway was ‘concessioned’ in 2009, the amount would have translated into about 525,500km of roads, several multiples of the paved road network we now have nationally.

Meanwhile, was it not this administration that set up an assessment committee to look into cases of abandoned Federal government projects? The final report of the committee can be summed up in 2 points: there are 11,886 abandoned federal projects across Nigeria, and it would cost an estimated N7.78 trillion to complete these projects. With the $31bn in stolen funds, Nigeria would have successfully completed about 65% or some 7,000 abandoned projects all across Nigeria that would create jobs and improve our standards of living.
The report of the committee has not been implemented; instead, President Jonathan recently sent a letter to the National Assembly requesting approval to borrow $7.9bn to fund a pipeline of projects between 2012 and 2014. This is not to say borrowing money to fund national developmental priorities is a bad idea. But we all know that most of these monies will add up to the Jonathanian statistics of stolen funds.

On the issue of debt, if we add the proposed borrowing to our currently known $5.7bn debt burden at the end of 2011, our external debt stock would rise to $13.6bn by 2014. It leaves little to wonder if Nigeria can sustain servicing its rising debt profile. Curiously, the proposed foreign borrowing and the requests were not included in the 2012- 2015 Medium Term Expenditure Framework presented to the National Assembly last year by the President himself, thereby violating the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2007.
The most frightening aspect of the $31bn question is: what if international and reputable audit firms had been engaged to audit Nigeria’s accounts not just at the federal, but also at state and local government areas? What would have been the findings? It is not hard to imagine that Nigeria would have been labelled the world’s most corrupt country by far, without a close second.

What should concern every Nigerian is that the President knows where mass fraud is being perpetuated, yet chooses to ignore the goings on. Why else have all the reports on the petroleum subsidy fraud only resulted in more ad-hoc committees, and then white paper committees whose reports are never ever published, and then finally abandoned to gather dust with no pretext at even attempting to implement any of the recommendations? No wonder, Dr. Faruk Lawan had to be compromised, while deliberate attempts were made to discredit the Ribadu Task Force report.

If the President wants to be regarded with any vestige of respect now or in the future, he must rise up with some spine, face corruption squarely and fight it with sincerity. He must de-emphasize reliance on foreign and domestic borrowings that simply line up the pockets of the lenders and the few unpatriotic Nigerians serving their interests. He must order the Debt Management Office to publish information on existing loans, tie them to the projects for which they were obtained, and make this information public to all Nigerians on a regular basis.
In the meantime, what most Nigerians simply want to know from the president is what happened to N5trillion in 30 months. That is the $31bn question which Dr Jonathan ought to answer

  • Modee Santuraki

    GEJ is the worst president on Earth. What pains me more is that there is more to what we just read.

  • Deji

    In as much as am not a fan of Elrufai, he has hit the nail on its head. President Jonathan is clueless, reckless and corrupt.

  • Gbemi

    This explains why the proportion of the population living below the poverty line Increases every day.

  • Akeem Iyanda

    Stealing in trillions…recklessness and coruption that can’t be rivaled!

  • Godswill

    Elrufai may not be too liked in some quarters but he is proving to be a possible rallying point, i wish he do a little tour of Nigeria and recruit interested persons in the new Nigeria dreams we must reborn Nigeria.

  • Yusuf

    What a country were a president cannot fight corruption rather encourage it i don’t think this clueless president can fight these el-rufai thanks for this information.

  • Danjuma

    Its unfortunate having GEJ as Nigerians president.he is certainly d worst of all presidents we had.may God punish dos dat punish others administratively.we hav our God they should have their money.future shall tell

  • Adamu Idris

    For all those that voted for Jonah’s ‘Fresh Air’ welcome to the real world of nemesis. The figure is just $31 billion and we have 3 more years to go, enjoy yourselves while you beath your last Fresh Air!

  • Adamu Idris

    For all those that voted for Jonah’s ‘Fresh Air’ welcome to the real world of nemesis. The figure is just $31 billion and we have 3 more years to go, so enjoy yourselves while you beath your last Fresh Air!

  • Yashim Joseph

    Stench…just spread my room some air freshner. 31bn ! The is unbearable.Pheeeww…!

  • Bilkisu

    What can we ordinary citizens do? There MUST be something we can do to help save ourselves and our country asides social media activism. Lest we be judged for not standing up to evil.

  • Ishaku Adamu Dada.

    El-rufai, if i develop high BP, be aware you are the cause. Your revealations are true but dificult to believe. El-rufai, help us one more time and find out from them how long they intend to live on this earth.

Related Posts

Recent Posts

Corps member raped, murdered two weeks to wedding

Thirteen days to her wedding and 29th birthday, a corps member, Miss Omolola Abogunrin, has been allegedly murdered by unknown criminals.   She was said to have been murdered in  the premises of an agriculture research institute located at Apata area of Ibadan, the Oyo State capital last Sunday.   The deceased was said to have been raped and strangled beside a stream within the premises of the institute.   Her lover, Olusola Babalola, has since been arrested and detained by the police.   Residents said the...

Senate free to set conditions for nominees, says Presidency

The Presidency is not opposed to the Senate setting conditions for the screening of ministerial nominees, the Senior Special Assistant to the President on National Assembly Matters, Senator Ita Enang said on Friday.   Enang told reporters in Abuja on Friday that the Senate is empowered by the constitution to set conditions for the screening of prospective ministers.   The Senate has set October 13, 14 and 15 for the screening of the 21 ministerial nominees submitted to it by President Muhammadu Buhari.   Enang,...

EFCC goes after former governor Suswam, grills ex-Finance commissioner

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) yesterday invited a former Governor of Benue State, Dr. Gabriel Suswam, in connection with the ongoing investigation of his tenure.   The commission also yesterday grilled a former Benue State Commissioner for Finance, Mr. Omadachi Oklobia, for eight hours.   As at 5.24 pm yesterday, Oklobia was battling to meet bail terms, but it was unclear if he was able to fulfill the stringent conditions.   Investigation revealed that Suswam is under probe based on the report of...

#OpenNASS: Senate to LiveStream Ministerial Screening

On Saturday, the 10th of October, 2015, the 8th Senate of the Federal Republic of Nigeria announced that the screening and confirmation process of the first batch of ministerial nominees by President Muhammadu Buhari to serve in his cabinet shall be streamed live on the National Assembly website. and Additionally, on Friday, the Senate through its official Twitter account @NGRSenate, has also announced that the general public...

Sen. Baba-Ahmed appointed as Chairman of the NYSC Hope Alive Foundation’s Board of Trustees

Sen. Yusuf Baba-Ahmed has been appointed as Chairman, Board of Trustees (BOT) of the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) Hope Alive Foundation. Brig.-Gen. Johnson Olawumi, Director-General, NYSC, announced this in a statement issued in Abuja on Friday by the NYSC Public Relations Unit. It said the BOT, which comprised persons from different sectors of national life, would be inaugurated by the incoming Minister of Youth Development. The statement explained that the foundation would be expected to drive the initiative of the scheme...

Kebbi govt. to establish international market at Nigeria-Benin Republic border

The Kebbi State Government on Friday said it would establish an International Market at Nigeria-Benin Republic border to fast track the take off of a Dry Port in the area. This is contained in a statement issued by Mr Abubakar Dakingari, Chief Press Secretary to Kebbi governor, Alhaji Atiku Bagudu, and made available to the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Birnin Kebbi. It said establishment of the market would enhance socio-economic activities and ensure sustainable development of the state. It assured...

EFCC nabs two with 448 travelers’ cheques, 108 ATM cards

Two Nigerians, identified as Jonathan Odu Isikwei and Paschal Onuora Udeh, have been arrested by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) with no fewer than 556 banking instruments purportedly belonging to four banks in America, Europe and Canada, with which they had been using to commit ‘unsuspecting large scale fraud,’ Vanguard reports. The two men were rounded up by operatives of the commission for unlawful possession of 448 travelers’ cheques...

Jurgen Klopp unveiled as Liverpool’s new manager, inks £15m deal

Jurgen Klopp was unveiled as Liverpool's new manager on Friday, succeeding Brendan Rodgers who was sacked last week.   The former Borussia Dortmund Manager, Jurgen Klopp signed a three-year deal with Liverpool FC at the city’s Hope Street hotel in the company of the chairman, Tom Werner, and chief executive, Ian Ayre, on Thursday...

NESG Presents the 21st Nigerian Economic Summit #NES21

The Nigerian Economic Group presents the 21st Nigerian Economic summit; theme: Tough Choices: Achieving competitiveness, inclusive growth and sustainability. Come and be part of the crucial talks targeted at addressing how to achieve competiveness and inclusive growth for the Nigerian economy through measurable outcomes This summit seeks to examine and facilitate stakeholders’ consensus on how best to achieve competitiveness and inclusive growth in a sustainable way, through measurable outcomes and as such...

Akwa Ibom govt. trains 700 civil servants on ICT

Akwa Ibom Government said a total of 700 civil servants have been trained on Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in the state.   The state Head of Service, Mrs Cecilia Udoessien, disclosed this on Friday in an interview with newsmen in Uyo.   Udoessien, the Head of Service since 2011, said that many civil servants had benefitted from various training programmes initiated by her office.   She said that she had introduced into the yearly public service week celebration, essay competition and debate among civil...

Messi, father to appear in court over $4.5 million tax fraud charges

Argentine forward Lionel Messi and his father Jorge have been ordered to appear in court on charges of defrauding Spanish tax authorities over an amount worth more than four million euros (about $4.5 million; about N990 million).   Spain's public prosecutor has recommended a jail sentence totaling 18 months and fines of more than two million euros for Jorge Messi.   This is for allegedly defrauding the state of 4.2 million euros for the years 2007-2009.   The prosecutor has however argued that Lionel Messi should...

Arsenal Goal Keeper Petr Cech Offers Thoughts On The Mourinho Vs Arsene Wenger Rivalry

The former Blues goalkeeper, who moved to the Emirates, in the transfer window has offered his thoughts on the two club's managers Arsenal goalkeeper Petr Cech has suggested manager Arsene Wenger and his Chelsea counterpart Jose Mourinho are regularly at odds because of similar personalities. Wenger and Mourinho have experienced a fractious relationship on the touchline...

Lacasera reinstates 700 sacked workers

The National Union of Food, Beverage and Tobacco Employees (NUFBTE) on Friday confirmed that Lacasera Company Plc has reinstated the 700 workers it sacked in September.   Mr Mike Olarenwaju, Head of Education Department in NUFBTE, confirmed the development to the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Lagos.   Olarenwaju said that the management of the company met with union members to resolve the issues in dispute and that the workers had been asked to start work.   He said that officials of the union...

Tribunal Reserves Judgement In Akwa Ibom Governorship Petition

The Akwa Ibom Governorship Election Tribunal has reserved judgment in the petition filed by the All Progressives Congress (APC) and its governorship candidate, Mr. Umana Umana, challenging the victory of Governor Emmanuel Udom at the April 11 election in the state. The tribunal resumed hearing after a 2-week recess to adopt the final arguments of the parties. The Chairman of the tribunal, Justice Sadiq Umar, reserved ruling following the conclusion of hearing...

Femi Gbajabiamila’s Election Victory Up Held By Tribunal In Lagos

The National Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal sitting in Ikeja on Friday upheld the victory of the Majority Leader of the House of Representatives, Mr Femi Gbajabiamila. The tribunal held that Gbajabiamila of the All Progressives Congress (APC) validly won the March 28 election for Surulere Federal Constituency I in Lagos State. The three-man tribunal led by Justice C.U. Anwuka resolved all issues raised in favour of the respondent. The tribunal consequently dismissed the petition...

Tribunal upholds Gbajabiamila’s election

The National Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal sitting in Ikeja on Friday upheld the victory of the Majority Leader of the House of Representatives, Mr Femi Gbajabiamila.   The tribunal held that Gbajabiamila of the All Progressives Congress (APC) validly won the March 28 election for Surulere Federal Constituency I in Lagos State.   The three-man tribunal led by Justice C.U. Anwuka resolved all issues raised in favour of the respondent.   The tribunal consequently dismissed the petition filed by the Peoples Democratic Party candidate, Mr...

Buruji Kashamu loses senate seat as Tribunal nullifies election

The Election Tribunal in Ogun State has nullified the election of alleged US wanted drug baron, Buruji Kashamu.   The tribunal made the decision today in Abeokuta and ordered a rerun in 110 polling units, where irregularities were established.   Indications that the Tribunal would arrive at this conclusion were foreshadowed in the cancellation of the election of Buruji’s party colleague in the House of Representatives, Aremo Adesegun Adekoya Abdel-Majid, who represented Buruji’s Ijebu North local council and two other councils.   Prince Dapo Abiodun,...

National security remains our topmost priority – President Buhari

President Muhammadu Buhari has said that significant improvements in national security remains the topmost priority of his administration.   The president made the statement on Thursday in Abuja when he granted audience to Britain's Chief of Defence Staff, Gen. Nicholas Houghton.   He said that security was imperative because other socio-economic initiatives could not be successfully implemented without adequate security in the country.   He reaffirmed the determination of his administration to end the Boko Haram insurgency as quickly as possible.   Buhari said: "for a country...

French Train Attack Hero Stabbed Multiple Times In A Bar Fight

Spencer Stone, one of the men who foiled a terror attack on a Paris-bound train in August, was seriously injured after being stabbed four times in the chest near a gay bar in downtown Sacramento early Thursday morning Police in Sacramento are searching for two Asian men after hero US airman Spencer Stone was knifed during a fight on a night out with friends in Sacramento. He suffered a collapsed lung and was being...

Serena Williams And Drake Deny Engagement Rumors

While we all  that Serena Williams and Drake have been dating, OK Magazine started a whole new round of celeb gossip on Thursday with the news that the two were now engaged. Even though no confirmation was given for the tabloid report, social media went crazy about the rumor and started to announce the couple’s supposed engagement. Ok Mag said Drake got down on one knee and proposed They...

Boko Haram: IDPs From Gwoza Write Buhari, Reveal Insurgents’ Hiding Place

Internally Displaced Persons from Gwoza have appealed to the Military High Command to undertake an operation within the Bayan Dutse area of Gwoza to flush out the insurgents and bring back peace to their homeland. In an open letter written to President Muhammadu Buhari on their behalf by five community leaders, the IDPs stated that if only the Bayan Dutse area would be attacked, all the Boko Haram insurgents hiding there would be flushed out and peace would...