Electoral Reforms (1) – To be or not to be! ~ Nasir El-Rufai

Published:14 Sep, 2012

The legitimacy of any government can only be derived from the will of the people as expressed in credible, free and fair elections held at regular intervals on the basis of universal, equal and secret suffrage; which explains why the critical importance of free and fair elections along with credible electoral process in any modern nation cannot be overemphasised.

This is underscored in one of the most important books I have read in recent times: Why Nations Fail – The origins of power, prosperity and poverty by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson; where the authors quoted Mohammed ElBaradei, the former director of the International Atomic Energy Agency as having written that: “In Tunisia, repression + absence of social justice + denial of channels for peaceful change = a ticking time bomb”. Clearly, Nigeria can be substituted for Tunisia and the truism of the equation would remain just as valid!

Elections in Nigeria began from the colonial era with the Legislative Council elections in Lagos and Calabar in 1923. Other elections also took place between 1951 and 1959. During the military interregnums, three elections took place; 1979 with the Murtala-Obasanjo regime, the 1992-1993 elections under Gen. Ibrahim Babangida and the 1999 elections conducted by Gen. Abdulsalami Abubakar.

According to an analysis of these elections by the EU Election Monitoring Group in its 2003 Report, the elections of 1959, 1979, 1993 and 1999 were the most free and fair while those of 1964 and 1983 were adjudged to be the most violent and chaotic. The reasons are obvious and not farfetched: the former were ‘transition’ elections to hand over power to civilian governments by the military with minimal vested interests while the latter were ‘succession’ elections laden with enormous political interests.

It is trite to state that all elections conducted in Nigeria have been characterised by malpractices to various degrees. Since the current republic began in 1999, every election seems to be worse than the one before it. In 2003, the elections led to a loss of about 100 lives with many more injured. The 2007 elections were characterised by massive rigging and violence with results being declared in many states before the arrival of ballot papers.

They were bad enough for the main beneficiary – late President Umaru Musa Yar’Adua to publicly acknowledge as such in his inaugural speech shortly after being sworn into office; along with a solemn promise to the nation that rigorous electoral reforms would be embarked upon to address the patent malpractices. To this effect and credit of Yar’Adua, an electoral reform committee with respected former chief justice Muhammed Uwais as chair was charged with the task.

That the Uwais committee did a commendable job is self-evident in the 319 pages long main report that was submitted to the Federal Government in December 2008. The introduction section of the report, inter alia states that: “Nigeria’s experience with democratic elections since independence has been rather mixed. Although the country has managed to transit from one administration to another, hardly any election conducted in the country has been completely free of charges of irregularities, electoral malpractices, violence and various degrees of disruptions.

The factors responsible for this state of affairs include, among others, the character of the Nigerian State as the arena for electoral contests; the existence of weak democratic institutions and processes; negative political culture; weak legal/constitutional framework; and lack of independence and capacity of the Election Management Bodies.”

The report’s main recommendations include:

The constitution should be amended to guarantee the independence and autonomy of INEC
In filling the position of INEC Chairman, the National Judicial Council (NJC) should advertise to the public, spelling out the required qualifications, receive the applications, shortlist three persons and send the nominations to the National Council of State to select one person and then forward to the Senate for confirmation
INEC should be unbundled into four units;
Political Parties Registration and Regulatory Commission whose duties are to register political parties and monitor their activities.
Electoral Offences Commission which is to investigate electoral frauds and other related acts. It is also to co-ordinate, enforce and prosecute all electoral offenders.
Constituency Delimitation Commission
Centre for Democratic Studies.
INEC should be removed from the list of Federal Executive Bodies
The Chairman and Board members of INEC may be removed by the Senate on the recommendation of the NJC by two-thirds majority of the Senate which shall include at least 10 members of the minority parties in the Senate.
Associations seeking registration as political parties must have functioning offices in at least two-thirds of the states of the Federation. These associations must also have 20% women membership in their governing bodies.
Political parties should not be allowed to receive funds from abroad.
Number of voters per polling station as well as layout of the stations should be specified. Each polling station should not have more than 500 voters.
Disqualification period of candidates engaged in corrupt practices should be increased to 10 years.
Post-election petition periods should take a total of six months.
No elected person shall assume office until their case in the tribunal is disposed of.
The police should be trained specially for elections.
INEC should be composed of a board which formulates electoral policy and a professional/technical election management team to manage elections.
State Independent Electoral Commissions should be organised in the same way as INEC.
Elections for President and Governors should be held at least six months before the expiration of their terms.
It is regrettable that almost four years after the submission of the foregoing excellent recommendations, not much has changed in our polity. But please do not take my words for this. The Economist Intelligence Unit’s Democracy Index measures the state of democracy in 167 countries throughout the world.

The Index was first produced in 2006 and it ranked countries on a scale between zero and 10, based on 60 indicators that were grouped in five categories: electoral process and pluralism, functioning of government, political participation, political culture and civil liberties.

According to the latest issue of the Index for 2011, whereas in 1945 the world only boasted of 12 democracies, it now boasts of 115 in three different classes of 25 full democracies, 53 flawed democracies and 37 hybrid regimes; with the remaining 52 countries being in the bottom of the pit class of authoritarian regimes as to be expected.

In the class of full democracies, it ranks Norway first with a total score of 9.80, keeping its position from 2010, when it replaced Sweden as the highest ranked country; whilst North Korea scored the lowest with 1.08, remaining at the bottom in 167th place, as in 2010.

Back home, in spite of the self-acclaimed “free and fair elections” that the Jonathan administration conducted in 2011, it did not come as a surprise that Nigeria is in the authoritarian regime class with a score of 3.83 and a ranking of 119; just behind Russia with 3.92 and 117 respectively. Meanwhile, Ghana is justifiably ranked way ahead of us at 78, in the class of flawed democracy with a score of 6.02!

What constitutes a free and fair election? According to Commonboarders.org, a ‘free’ electoral process is one where fundamental human rights and freedoms are respected, including:

freedom of speech and expression by electors, parties, candidates and the media;
freedom of association; that is, freedom to form organisations such as political parties and NGOs;
freedom of assembly, to hold political rallies and to campaign;
freedom of access to and by electors to transmit and receive political and electoral information messages;
freedom to register as an elector, a party or a candidate;
freedom from violence, intimidation or coercion;
freedom of access to the polls by electors, party agents and accredited observers;
freedom to exercise the franchise in secret, and
freedom to question, challenge and register complaints or objections without negative repercussions.
And a ‘fair’ electoral process is one where the ‘playing field’ is reasonably level and accessible to all electorate, parties and candidates, and includes:

an independent, non-partisan electoral organisation to administer the process;
guaranteed rights and protection through the constitution and electoral legislation and regulations;
equitable representation of electors provided through the legislation;
clearly defined universal suffrage and secrecy of the vote;
equitable and balanced reporting by the media;
equitable access to financial and material resources for party and candidate campaigning;
equitable opportunities for the electorate to receive political and voter information;
accessible polling places;
equitable treatment of electors, candidates and parties by elections officials, the government, the police, the military and the judiciary;
an open and transparent ballot counting process, and
election process not disrupted by violence, intimidation or coercion.
The flaws in the electoral system are known to almost every politically conscious Nigerian. Massive bribing and rigging, thuggery, insecurity during elections and the incompetence of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) in delivering its mandate are some of these problems.

If there is going to be any change in our nation for the better, it has to begin now! The first step will be a re-orientation of the populace. People have to believe that they have the power to decide who their leaders are irrespective of the flaws of the electoral system. They need to get more involved in the electoral process instead of sitting back and complaining.

9 thoughts on “Electoral Reforms (1) – To be or not to be! ~ Nasir El-Rufai”

  1. Electoral reform is highly needed in nigeria..also youth reorientation is higly required..bliv me, many of us don’t know that we r d instrument of change needed in dis country…well, I bliv I am and I know I will

  2. zipman says:

    Oh NaiJa my father everybody seems to know what is right & wrong but nobody wants to correct it. Its like saying everybody wan go heaven but nobody wan die. I bet you if the writer of this piece were in power today He’ll still dust all d recommendations & d good work done by Uwaise to River Niger pretending to be a saint. If Na to talk no action just leave am for Naija men

  3. VIMwRRSuPx says:

    buy generic valium no prescription buy valium sleeping tablets – valium online with prescription

  4. YafKzHkXSQ says:

    buy tramadol online no prescription cod buy tramadol in uk no prescription – order tramadol online tennessee

  5. bmTwipwVfy says:

    ambien 5 ambien side effects in women – buy real ambien

  6. TgsnSrZtNV says:

    generic ambien online 10 mg ambien enough – do drug test test ambien

  7. KzgnXDVoDW says:

    buy valium generic drug for valium – valium vs klonopin high

  8. zZdgeiIqZh says:

    ambien online without rx ambien side effects rage – ambience mall gurgaon contact no

  9. yfKborLPpJ says:

    valium without prescriptions valium 5mg for dogs – valium online new zealand

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Recent Posts

#MTVMAMA2016: Yemi Alade wins ‘best female’, says women not only good in the kitchen

Yemi Alade, self-acclaimed Mama Africa, beat Tiwa Savage to win the ‘best female artiste’ award at the MTV Africa Music Awards 2016. The Effyzzie Music act is one of three ladies hosting the award ceremony after Trevor Noah, US-based South African comedian, pulled out over health issues. To win the award, Yemi Alade fought off competition from Josey (Ivory Coast), Mz Vee (Ghana), Vanessa Mdee (Tanzania) as well as Mavin singer, Tiwa Savage, While delivering her acceptance speech, Alade reacted to president...

PRESS RELEASE: I have not withdrawn my case against Dogara and others” – Jibrin

It has come to our attention the circulating misrepresentation of facts that our client, Hon. Abdulmumin Jibrin has withdrawn his suit filed vide FHC/ABJ/CS/595/16 against The Speaker, House of Representatives and 14 others wherein we sought for injunctive reliefs restraining the the Defendants from suspending the Plaintiff, Honourable Abdulmumin Jibrin. This is not the true position of things and the said untrue information is calculated to misinform and in fact disappoint the teeming generality of Nigerians...

FG re-introduces teaching of History in primary, secondary school.

The federal government has finally re-introduced History as one of the subjects in the nation’s primary and secondary schools’ curriculum, explaining that its introduction as an independent subject and not a mere theme was necessitated by the clamour and concerns by several groups, including the Presidency, National Assembly and other critical stakeholders in the education sector. The Minister of Education, Mallam Adamu Adamu, had urged delegates to the recent National Council of Education, NCE, to consider the disarticulation of social...

Customs generates N11 billion in nine months in Oyo.

The Nigeria Customs Service (NCS), Oyo/Osun Command, said it had generated the sum of N11.1 billion between the months of January and September this year. The Customs Area Controller, Temitope Ogunkua, who disclosed this while briefing reporters on the activities of the command, said 188 assorted seizures were made with a duty paid value of N368 million within the period under review. Ogunkua, who assured of the command’s readiness to tackle economic saboteurs and work for the security well-being of the...

Kaduna To Spend N2.55bn On Drones, CCTV

The Kaduna State Government has earmarked over N2.55bn to procure CCTV cameras and drones, to provide adequate security cover in the state in 2017. More than N1.5 billion of the amount was earmarked for the procurement and installation of CCTV cameras in strategic areas of the state, to reduce crime. The figure is contained in the state’s 2017 budget document currently before the state House of Assembly. He said, “The N1.5 billion is for...

Commercial Sex Workers Take Over Jos Trade Fair

Activities of commercial sex works are overshadowing those of exhibitors and traders at the 2016 Jos Trade Fair, holding at the Jos Polo Field, in Jos North local government area of Plateau state. A reporter at the trade fair Thursday night noticed hordes of young sex workers brazenly soliciting patronage by male participants at the event. One of the young workers, who refused to give her name, said the illicit trade was booming because the...

Sultan’s 10th Anniversary Begins Nov. 2

The Sokoto State Government will hold an International Symposium on the legendary Sokoto Caliphate as part of activities marking the 10th anniversary of the Sultan of Sokoto, Alhaji Sa’ad Abubakar III on the throne. ” The caliphate’s contributions to the economy, politics, leadership and good governance in the sub-Saharan region will be the focus of the symposium.” Commissioner for Information, Alhaji Danladi Bako, made this known in a statement in Sokoto on Friday. Bako,...

Attacks on oil installations, vandalism crash monthly allocation by N90.2bn

Despite increase in average price of crude oil at global market from $46.0 per barrel in May to $48.43 in June, sustained attacks on oil installations and pipeline vandalism have reduced total allocation available for sharing to the three tiers of government by N90.2 billion. The picture was made clearer yesterday as the sum of N420 billion was approved for September for sharing as against N510.270 billion disbursed among the three tiers of government in August. Militant attacks on oil installation...

MTN Denies Illegal Transfer Of $14 bn From Nigeria

South Africa’s MTN has denied it illegally transferred $13.9 billion from Nigeria in the latest scandal to hit the telecom firm in its largest market in the continent. The Johannesburg-based firm is facing a parliamentary probe over accusations it connived with senior Nigerian officials to move the funds out of the country without complying with the law. “We would like to reiterate that at no point did MTN Nigeria (MTNN) illegally repatriate funds out of...

Trevor Noah pulls out of 2016 MTV MAMA Awards.

South African comedian Trevor Noah has announced his inability to host the 2016 MTV Africa Music Award (MAMA). The Comedy Central host made the announcement earlier on Friday, explaining he has been suffering from a severe respiratory and ear infection. “Due to the infection and strain on my vocal chords the doctor has ordered me to rest. I desperately wish I could dismiss the doctor but the added risk of flying means the decision would be highly irresponsible  and may cause...

How Mamman Daura became ‘Nigeria’s most powerful nephew’.

Mamman Daura is today described as the “most powerful nephew” in Nigeria by virtue of his closeness to President Muhammadu Buhari. At the centre of the recent complaints by Aisha, Buhari’s wife, is that those who did not participate in the campaign were the ones calling the shots in her husband’s government TheCable understands that Duara is one of those she was referring to, having already complained privately about him. However, what has often not been reported is how Daura came to wield...

No Plan To Reduce Nigerian Flights- Lufthansa

An international carrier, Lufthansa Airline, yesterday said it had no plan to reduce its flight operations in Nigeria. The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reported that the airline’s Media Consultant, Mr. Hakeem Jimoh, made the disclosure to aviation correspondents in Lagos. Two foreign airlines, Emirates and Kenya Airways , recently announced the suspension of their flights to the Nnamdi Azikiwe International Airport in Abuja. While Emirates Airlines said it would stop flights to Abuja from October 22, Kenya Airways said its flights...

World Bank raises 2017 crude oil prices’ forecast to $55 per barrel.

The World Bank yesterday revised upwards its 2017 forecast for crude oil prices, raising it from $53 per barrel to $55 per barrel as members of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) prepare to cut output after a long period of unrestrained output. The Bank, in its latest Commodity Markets Outlook, projected that energy prices, which include oil, natural gas and coal, will jump almost 25 percent overall next year, a larger increase than anticipated in July, while...

Suspension: Jibrin withdraws suit against House of Reps.

The Federal High Court, Abuja, on Friday struck out the suit of former Chairman, House of Representatives Committee on Appropriations, Mr. Abdulmumin Jibrin, challenging his suspension from the House. The judge, Justice John Tsoho, struck out the matter after Jibrin’s Counsel, Mr. Chukuma Nwachukwu, told the court that his client had filed a notice of discontinuance. Tsoho decline the request of the defendants for a N200, 000 cost, holding that the defendants were “strong institution and personality”. At the hearing, Jibrin’s counsel,...

Aregbesola tells Nigerians to practice birth control, shun foreign goods.

The Governor of Osun state, Rauf Aregbesola has urged Nigerians to practice birth control and curb excessive desire for foreign food items in order to survive recession. The governor said this on Thursday in Osogbo while hosting some youth who just returned from a training sponsored by the state government in modern agricultural technique at Germany. He explained that his government’s decision to send the youths for the agriculture programme is to boost food production in the state, adding that this...

Meet The Baby Who Was Born Twice

Margaret Boemer went for a routine ultrasound 16 weeks into her pregnancy with her third child. She quickly found out that things were far from routine. "They saw something on the scan, and the doctor came in and told us that there was something seriously wrong with our baby and that she had a sacrococcygeal teratoma," the Plano, Texas, mom said in an interview shared by Texas Children's Hospital. "And it was very shocking and...

Fashion for Charity, Spanish “LaLiga” Unite for IDPs with #KickForHope2016

Who Fashion For Charity Is... Fashion for Charity harnesses the power of fashion, entertainment, and the visual arts to help vulnerable people. From Abuja to Milan to Atlanta, various industry players in fash- ion design, fashion photography, fashion media, modeling and more, have come together to become a force for good in Nigeria and beyond. This year, Fashion for Charity has been focusing on the plight of internally displaced persons from north-eastern Nige- ria. Fashion...

Why Always Me: Another Supreme Court Justice accuses Amaechi of bribery.

The last of the two justices of the Supreme Court arrested during the invasion of the residences of the justices of the court by the Department of State Security Service, DSS, Justice Sylvester Ngwuta, yesterday accused the former governor of Rivers State and now, Minister of Transportation, Mr. Chibuike Rotimi Amaechi of masterminding the operation. Also yesterday, the Nigerian Bar Association, NBA called on the judges accused of corruption to cease adjudicating on cases until the allegations against them are...

First Contest For Mr & Miss Albino Held In Kenya

Youngsters with albinism are stepping into the limelight, hoping to be named Kenya's first Mr and Miss Albino. Albinism has been associated with many negative misconceptions and superstitions. As a result, many albinos suffer stigma, alienation and even physical abuse. The pageant being held later in Kenya's capital, Nairobi, also aims to boost the confidence of young people with albinism. Read More: BBC

Pulse: Obanikoro is going down, but he won’t do so alone.

The walls are closing in on Musiliu Obanikoro, former Minister of State for Defence. Obanikoro has been singing his way deeper and deeper into trouble, sources at the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) have told Pulse. Obanikoro surprisingly turned himself into the waiting arms of the anti-graft agency as soon as he touched down in Nigeria from the United States last week. The former Lagos State Governorship aspirant on the platform of the Peoples Democratic...

South Africa To Quit International Criminal Court

South Africa is pulling out of the International Criminal Court (ICC) because its obligations are inconsistent with laws giving sitting leaders diplomatic immunity, according to government officials. Justice Minister Michael Masutha said on Friday that the government will soon submit a bill in parliament to withdraw from the court in The Hague, a move that comes as several African countries express concerns over what they call the ICC's disproportionate targeting of the continent. The bill will propose...